[MF] Halloween Hookup Part 2 (Cheating)

[Part One Here](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/b1gczo/mf_halloween_hookup_cheating/)

The party goes on – Melissa disappearing back into the crowd of celebrants to deal with her husband (and to make excuses for her sudden lack of makeup and the extended bathroom trip). I find my girlfriend and tell her what happened, which she thinks is highly amusing and somewhat erotic, and we continue to enjoy ourselves.

Hours later, I’m rather drunk, and I decide to go into the back bedroom to “rest my eyes” a bit and try to regain some sobriety before I wind up passed out on a couch. I’m usually pretty good about keeping myself in control, but that night I went a bit overboard and I wanted some recovery time before I rejoined the party. I doze off to the sound of the bass of the dance music vibrating through the house.

I am woken up by my girlfriend – I have no idea how much time has passed, but I’m feeling a lot less out of it than I was before – and she leans in, “Are you hammered?”

“No, I’m okay.”

She grins. “Well, pretend to be worse off that you are. I have a surprise for you.” I nod and put my arm over my eyes while she slips out of the room. She comes back, and I’m laying motionless, pretending to be mostly out.

I hear my girlfriend whisper, “See? He’s practically passed out.” Then I feel a hand – not hers – rubbing my crotch.

The touch is insistent, grabbing and squeezing my cock through my pants, and I can feel myself getting hard again. Then I hear a voice – “Help me get his pants down?” It was Melissa.

The two women work swiftly, getting my pants and boxers down to my knees, my half-hard cock on display, then I feel Melissa’s hand gripping me again, squeezing and stroking, pumping me back to full erection.

“Lock the door,” she says, and I hear my girlfriend fiddling with the handle.

I am keeping my arm over my eyes, my face mostly obscured, because I don’t want to “ruin the moment” – but it was so hard not to react! Next thing I feel is Melissa climbing onto the bed, straddling me, and then guiding my cock into her pussy. She rolls her hips a couple of times to make sure I’m nice and snug inside of her, then she starts bouncing on me, moaning low, trying to keep quiet.

My girlfriend gets in behind her, kissing her neck, groping her breasts, grinding her own pussy down on my leg. She’s whispering to Melissa, “Do you like it? Isn’t his cock so nice? Don’t you miss him so much?” All the while, Melissa can only moan, muttering the occasional, “uh-huh” between panting breaths.

This goes on for a few minutes, but not being able to control the pace or even react much, I knew I wouldn’t last long. Melissa was riding me for all she was worth, and my girlfriend was only urging her on, making her fuck me harder.

Then I feel my girlfriend’s hand down between us. She’s rubbing Melissa’s clit and my shaft at the same time, whispering something I can’t hear into Melissa’s ear (she later told me she was saying all kinds of dirty stuff to her, calling her a cheating little slut and a depraved size queen, which was only making Melissa moan harder), and then Melissa cums – hard. She’s quivering and moaning, writhing hard on top of me, pushing her pelvis down against me for all she’s worth. I can feel her body spasming, squeezing my cock – and that triggers my orgasm. With a shallow moan I cum inside of her. She whimpers “God he’s cumming!” as she writhed, and I think she may have even cum a second time feeling the rush – or at least it was a renewed aftershock.

I hear the two of them kissing, Melissa still writhing a little, my cock still inside of her, then I hear Melissa meekly ask, “You promise this is our secret?”

My girlfriend just giggled, “OF course. He won’t even know what happened.”

Melissa climbs off me and leaves the room, and my girlfriend says to her “I’ll be out in a minute.”

She then leans down and whispers to me “Happy Halloween, sweetie,” and kisses me before leaving herself.

I pull my pants back up and happily doze off again. I’ve never told Melissa that I knew what happened that night, and we haven’t had any sort of sexual encounter since, but I’ll always remember that Halloween very fondly.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/b2kmry/mf_halloween_hookup_part_2_cheating