A low key New Years Eve party turned into an orgy [Group] [MM] [MF] [MFF] [MMM]

I’ve debated back and forth about posting this story but I think it’s one I can sufficiently anonymize this. Apologies if that leads to anything weird like mixed up names. For descriptions heights and weights (Except mine) are all estimates. Cock sizes are on point because they’ve been discussed. Also this is a combination of my memory + other peoples reports.

**First let me introduce you to the cast of characters**

**Fred**: 28, a runner in college, he is now working as a regional sales manager for [company]. Dark hair, blue eyes, 6 ft 2 and 240 lbs, he gained weight after college then got into crossfit (my suggestion) . He’s very blessed downstairs – 8.5 inches or so and quite thick.

**Adam**: 30, 5 ft 8 with light blonde hair, blue eyes and very delicate features his cock is almost 7 inches long and 5.5 in around. His parents are noted academics in their field and former hippys He’s a Physicians assistant at an urgent care clinic

**Greg**: 26 5 ft 9-10, also a runner in college. Sandy brown hair brown eyes. He’s a mechanical engineer at [company]. Definitely the smallest of the guys in terms of endowment, he’s about 5 in long.

**Casey**: 26 brunette with pale skin, blue eyes, she’s 5 ft 2, maybe 110 lbs with perky d cups that look enormous on her frame. She switched from engineering to English in college and does some kind of technical copywriting

**Laura**: 28, full on ginger, bright red hair with green eyes. She’s a life long dancer and gymnast, 5 ft 6 with a dur body, 110-120 with c cups. She’s Bi and very adventurous in general. She does PT and teaches dance.

**Me aka Ryan**: 6 ft, 230 lbs with brown hair and blue eyes. I also lift at the same gym as Fred. I do IT sales and am not as blessed as Fred but still above average – 7.5 in long, little over 6.5 around

————————————————————————————————————————

**Background**

Now we mostly know one another from college. Fred and I were roommates for all of college. Laura was Fred’s girlfriend Freshmen year (he didn’t come out till sophmore year). Greg and Fred both ran track together. The three of us were roommates in an apartment Fred and I’s senior and Greg’s sophomore year.

Oh, and Laura and I started hooking up Junior year. We would be an awful couple (though we tried once and will pretend on occasion for social reasons), but we hook up on the regular when we are both single, which we were at the time of this story.

Casey and Greg met on like the first day of Freshmen year in the laundry room. They’ve dated basically constantly since (we refer to them as “Lily and Marshall” from HIMYM).

A few months before New Years eve they mentioned they’re going to try and open relationship. This was a shock because they’ve only ever slept with each other, plus they were also trying for a kid so we didn’t know how those mixed. They’ve been married two years.

Adam is the one “new person”. Fred had a run of pretty bad boyfriends for a while. Swore off dating at 4:30 one day, and by 10 the same night he was in love with Adam. They moved in together about 6 months prior to this (ending Fred and I’s nearly 10 year roommate streak). They’ve been dating for ~2 years as of these events and have a partially open relationship. Idk the details, but I know they mess around with other guys occasionally.

Also, as a general group note, we are all pretty open sexually. Not like doing stuff in front of each other (before this…) but like everyone knows generally what the others are into (or thought we did).

Anyway onto the story.

————————————————————————————————————————

**The Story**

We were all discussing what to do for new years eve, esp since the friends who usually host big events are all out of town. Bemoaning how much everything cost. Adam wanted to stick close to [neighborhood he, Fred and I live in] because he has to work at 7 the next day. Finally Fred suggests we all just have a low key night in, watch some tv shows, drink a little etc.

Fred and Adam have a very nice place, it’s a two bedroom (the master a and guest bedroom/office) with a sizable living room for events. I agree, Laura objects until I offer for her to stay at my place and Casey agrees on behalf of her and Greg (who later objects because he hates leaving his nicer neighborhood).

So the night begins pretty normally. We chill and chat, start drinking. We watch a movie, then start playing cards against humanity.

At around 10:45 we have a tv show on and Adam starts to give Casey a back rub. Adam is *very* good at back rubs (he has a masseuse license) he likes giving them and Casey is all about it. Adam suggests she take her shirt off and Casey is down but not in front of everyone.

They go to the master bedroom. Soon moans start coming from the room. Everyone assumes it’s the massage – Adam has never been with a woman, I”m honestly not sure he’d even kissed one. But it keeps going and vaguely sexy words come out too, so Fred and Greg are like “we’re gonna check this out”. I think they were just bored of the show and Adam makes a production out of his massages.

Laura and I shrug and are cuddled on the couch. groping each other a little.

Soon Casey’s moans are added by a dudes moans. We try to ignore it but finally we are just curious, So we go into the room. It’s lit only by the moon and light peaking in from the hallway but on one side was Adam, on top of Casey, massaging away,on the other was Fred on top of greg.

Two things were notable – first only Adam was wearing anything besides underwear (he had his pants on, his shirt was discarded). The second was that Fred was *really* on top of greg, like he was rubbing his back but….there was also serious crotch to ass contact. And it was pretty evident Fred was worked up.

(You might wonder how this state of affairs happened – I found out later, that Adam had asked casey to take her pants off too so he could massage her thighs. When greg came in, he made some comment about being jealous – of Casey – so Fred had offered a massage, but after five minutes Greg had to give him one in return. They both stripped down like Casey had as a result.)

Soon Adam and Casey’s massage stopped, they curled up and were laying there cuddling, watching greg and Fred uh do amassage. I remember the look I shared with Laura like “is this…is this gonna happen?”, though Laura was very into it (she’s always been into guy-guy stuff).

Soon Fred started to kiss gregs neck from behind and before I knew it they were facing each other, making out and rubbing one another.

Meanwhile Casey and Adam are just kind of laying there, Adam is, I think, trying to stimulate casey but he has no idea what he’s doing, Laura and I are just kind of taken aback When Greg and Fred’s underwear comes off she’s really getting into it and is groping me.

We start making out, taking our own clothes off, tossing them into the pile., She is pulling me towards the bed,
stroking my cock., But it isn’t going anywhere, It won’t get fully hard.

She whispers “did you drink too much?” I laugh – i don’t think anyone had more than 2 drinks – and say “no, but the two dudes grunting isn’t really doing it for me…wanna go to the spare room?”

She was nonplussed – she likes dude on on dude so she pushes for us to try.

We wind up laying down on the other side of Fred and Greg and doing 69.

I’ll be honest Laura has a fantastic mouth and she really got me going. My tongue is pretty skilled too, and Laura was absolutely soaking and cumming (she cums *very easily*)

Casey and Adam are on the other side, just watching.

I’m laying there thinking, “Ya know, this might work, maybe Fred and I will fuck someone next to each other”.

Then In their very active make out/dry hump session, Greg moves and soon Fred is off balance. He slides into Laura and soon the three of us are spilled onto the floor.

Everyone kind of laughs, boners deflate a little as we move up. make sure no one hit their head or whatever. Laura and I decide that we’re gonna go to the other bedroom, just for logistics.

Soon we are making out on the spare bed, my cock’s hard, her juices are flowing and I start to go in. She’s on the pill, and we’re both good about using condoms with ONS’s and such so we aren’t worried.

It feels nice and soon we are in our own world, her knees against her shoulders, me thrusting hard into her. She is *very* mutli-orgasmic as I mentioned before, so she’s cumming up a storm and I’m very close myself. And that’s when adam comes barging in.

“Laura, Ryan you guys gotta see this”. I’m annoyed but he insists and Laura is intrigued so we get up and go.

Now, for context Greg was, as far as we all knew, straight, Obviously this was being questioned by the uh wrestling from earlier, but still I figured it would end in some kind of mutual jerk off session or something. I didn’t think it was going to go zero to 100.

Instead when we walked back into the room there was Greg on all fours, with Casey watching from the side while Fred began gently pushing his cock into him, I was genuinely shocked. It took a while but Fred was patient and eventually he was balls deep. Greg was…very vocal. Casey was watching it intently, I could get a read of what she thought though.

Soon Fred was going harder and Greg was enjoying it. Casey, at Fred’s encouragement began playing with Greg’s cock.

Barely a minute after she began rubbing it Greg came. Fred took that as his cue and came himself.

Laura and I were shocked but we also wanted to get back to fucking (esp her. she was very turned on). We retreated to the guest room. We began making out, rubbing each other and were 69ing again when Casey came in.

She asked if she could join in with us, since Greg, Fred and Adam were doing stuff in the other room and she didn’t feel like she belonged.

She put on a chipper face, but I think both Laura and I knew she was shaken – the only guy she’d been with, the love of her life, had just been fucked in front of her, and that’s a lot to process. Laura sat next to her, with me on the other side. Laura kissed me, then turned to Casey, kissing her, Then she pulled us together. We kissed. First hesitatingly, but soon we were really making out.

Laura wiggled out of the way and my hands were on Casey’s hips. Laura was on my other side and I felt her hands on my

cock. Then I felt her take Casey’s hands from my back and soon enough those hands were on my cock too.

Laura asked Casey if she’d rather be eaten out by her or fucked by me.

She paused, and I think the sight of her husband being fucked came to her because she said, very definitively, “fucked”.

Laura took charge and instructs me to lay back. Casey straddled me. At first just sliding her pussy on my cock. I warned her that I had been close already tonight so not to overdo the teasing. Soon Laura held my cock and positioned Casey over me.

Casey was not used to a cock my size, so I knew I had to be gentle.

She was, as I expected, extremely tight. She was also very vocal about the sensations. She kept exclaiming how big it felt. She more than once declared she could not take more. But eventually I was balls deep. She was amazed, but soon started to ride me slowly at first then harder and harder. Laura and began to fondle her big tits, teasing her nipples. Soon they were making out. If Casey hadn’t been riding my cock I would have felt left out.

Then, despite my best efforts, I came. Casey was visibly annoyed “I was so close!” she declared. In my defense we had been going for a fair bit and I had been close to cumming more than once.

I pulled out and really became the Laura and Casey show. They were making out, fingering one another and eating each other out. Soon enough the orgasm I had denied Casey came, as did another. Laura had her share as well.

In the following hour this had a…restorative effect on me. the girls did not completely leave me out, especially as my cock came back to life. Once it was fully hard I asked which girl wanted it and Casey loudly declared that I owed her an orgasm, but she wanted to be on the bottom.

Laura demanded if she was going to hog my cock that Casey eat her out.

So Laura lay on he back, with Casey eating her out, while I moved behind them, gripping Casey’s hips as I pumped away. I used one hand to reach under and begin to rub Casey’s clit, which…well Laura objected because it interrupted Casey’s focus on her. But suffice to say I gave her the orgasm I owed her.

We went at for a bit more, then moved positions, This time I was eating Laura while Casey was in missionary under me while Laura stood on the bed. That wasn’t super comfortable so we returned to the prior position. Then we just turned Casey onto her back, with Laura riding her face.

Laura and I made out, while I fucked Casey’s pussy and Laura rode her face, I came for a second time.

By now it was close to 2:30 am and we were exhausted. The three of us lay where we fell and slept, all intertwined.

The next morning we all kind of rubbed and moved around. Eventually Casey and I had a third round of lazy morning sex.

(In the other room, I don’t know the details, But i know they did a train, with Fred fucking Greg, while Greg fucked Adam. Adam wasn’t wild about it because Greg is not well endowed but Greg enjoyed it)

Then we all got up, got dressed (minus adam, who left in time for work) and had an awkward breakfast.

——————————————————————————————————————————–

**Afterward**

There have since been…complications from all of this. I don’t want to get to into it, but one issue is that Casey is pregnant and there is confusion about who the father is…

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/aqyeoi/a_low_key_new_years_eve_party_turned_into_an_orgy