The time I [F] had a threesome.

[https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/alx0pb/the_time_i_f_cheated_on_my_boyfriend_with_my/](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/alx0pb/the_time_i_f_cheated_on_my_boyfriend_with_my/)

​

That’s how we got to where we are now. You’ll probably want to read that to understand how we got here. Now get ready for my life to fall apart.

​

Between that last story and this one, I continued to date David, and I continued to hookup with Cindy. Life was amazing. I had a boyfriend and a girlfriend. I pretty much alternated nights between them. Neither of them knew about one another, I didn’t do it on purpose, I didn’t feel like I was cheating, the conversation just never came up, and I didn’t volunteer it. Eventually after a few months Cindy and I started using the L word together. It seemed more like puppy love to me, but she seemed really into it, and it really did enhance the relationship, so I went with it.

​

I started taking birth control, I was pretty serious with David and we didn’t use condoms often, so I wanted to be safe. He still wouldn’t cum in me, he was a little paranoid. He usually pulled out and came on me, or on the floor which was ok by me. It was easier to clean up.

​

Cindy and I still hadn’t found a room mate by the two month later mark. We figured we could hold out until school started, and find someone then, but the budget would be tight for me.

One night when David and I were hanging out, he had me over the bed, face down, my arms behind my back, slamming away at my pussy. I was soaking wet, and loving every moment of it. Then he spoke up while fucking me, and said, “Remember that time your room mate watched us? I want you to invite her over here so we can mess around again.” I loved the dirty talk, I loved that he was taking charge of me, and so I agreed. We finished, and cleaned up, cuddled a bit, and I thought about what he had said. I didn’t know if I was ok with Cindy coming around. I suddenly realised that they might not be ok with one another.. but I put that out of my mind.

​

That night I headed home to my bed, and hung out at my place. Cindy came home later and joined me on the couch, we cuddled, had a bit of wine, and a toke. Eventually late that night, I broached the subject with her. I still don’t know what I was thinking, I just kind of started talking and didn’t think to stop.

“Hey remember David? The guy you watched me with?” She Mmhm’d in response. “He wants to fool around again like that, told me to ask if you were interested?”

She looked surprised, but intrigued. She said, “Ya we could do that, if you’re ok with it? But only as long as you still love me after!” I thought it was a strange thing to say. The beginning was fine, but the end part was weird. Of course I’d still love her. In fact it’d make it a lot easier to be with her if she was ok with me going and getting a cock once in a while… we dropped it for the night, but hooked up that evening in my bed. She slept in it with me and we woke up in the morning when I had to go to work. I left her in my bed before heading out.

​

I texted David and told him that she was into it, and he suggested a few nights later that I knew would work for all of us. That was the night that Cindy and I both had class and would be walking back past David’s place that evening anyways. We’d stop by, I’d get fucked, Cindy would watch, it was going to be great.. I thought.

​

That night finally arrived. Cindy wore her usual type of clothes. A school girl skirt, socks, and a shirt with a little tie. She was nothing if not predicable. I wore my yoga pants and a long sleeve shirt. If I was going to just be naked anyways, I might as well be comfortable before then in class.

​

Class ended, and I walked to Cindy’s class, she got out just after me, and we started our walk across campus to Davids place. When we arrived, he opened the door. He was wearing sweatpants and a t-shirt. He invited us in. His place was cleaner then usual, and the bed was made, but it was nothing special. He closed the door behind us, the lights were off, but the screen had a glow. There was some of his music playing quietly. The dorm building had maybe 10 occupants in the 100+ rooms, so it’s not like we had to mask the sound. David leaned in and gave me a kiss. His arm around his waist. Then he gave Cindy a hug. She giggled and squirmed.

​

We put our bags down, and he invited her to sit on the bed. We watched her crawl onto the bed, and thats when I noticed that she had omitted the panties tonight. Somewhat out of character for her, but I figured she was just excited. David looked at Cindy and asked her “are you ready?” she nodded. He grabbed me a kissed me passionately, while taking my shirt off, exposing my bra, it was a simple cute bra. It had comics on it, mostly yellow and pink. The panties I was wearing were matching. He put his hands inside my yoga pants and grabbed my ass, gave it a big squeeze and then turned me and pushed me down on the bed.

​

I was bent over the edge of his twin bed, kind of at an angle, Cindy was at the head of the bed, and that’s when I noticed that she hadn’t held back, her skirt was hiked up, and she was already playing with her clit through her bush. David peeled my pants and panties off in one motion, leaving me bent over the bed, my face between Cindy’s knees, unable for my tongue to make it to her pussy, but I could smell her. She was hot and wet, I could easily see the wetness in her pussy.

​

My pussy was soaking wet by this point, David teased his fingers over my lips and toyed them with his hands, before pulling his cock out as I looked back at him. I nodded in agreement, and he gave his cock a few pumps. I looked back at Cindy. David entered me, he slid right in just as he had many times before. I collapsed onto the bed with my hips, as I enjoyed the sensation, and he leaned into me. There was no reason to try and fight back at him, he was going to do all the work in this position, I just needed to hold myself here. He started to slide in and out of me. I was in heaven.

David looked at Cindy and said, “Take off your top.” She obliged. She un buttoned her shirt, and took it off, and then quickly undid her bra and released her perfect breasts. Her nipples were hard, and dark brown as usual. A contrast to her bright pink pussy. She gave them a few gropes, and flicked the nipples. tugging on them.

​

My boyfriend was in my pussy with his perfect circumcised cock, my girlfriend was in front of me, rubbing her clit and massaging her hairy pussy lips. David was holding my hips, moving in and out, and I put one hand below me, finding my clit and starting to rub it. I was soaked, I was dripping on the bed making a wet spot. I took the other hand and managed to get it onto Cindy’s leg, I felt her thigh, and then I moved my hand to her pussy. I knew David was watching this, and I knew it was driving him crazy, I could feel him slamming into me harder and harder. I let Cindy continue rubbing her clit. was way better at making herself orgasm with a hand then I was. My tongue was better then her hand, but I knew from experience that if she was going to orgasm her hand was probably going to work fairly well this time. Instead it took a finger and slid it in her pussy. I hooked it up and rubbed her G-spot. David kept pounding me. I rubbed my clit.

​

I had one finger in Cindy, one hand rubbing my clit, and my boyfriends cock in my pussy. This must be what heaven felt like. I was getting close, and so I moaned. “I’m going to cum.” as I breathed deeply. David slammed away at my pussy, and Cindy started moaning. Then moments later, I came. It was one of the most powerful orgasms I’d had before. It was incredible. My legs shook, David grabbed my ass and squeezed, and I bit the comforter to not get completely out of control sound wise.

​

As I came down from my orgasm David pulled out of me, Cindy was still rubbing her pussy, my fingers had slipped out when I had my orgasm and my body had tried to go into the fetal position, with David holding my ass and hips. She kept playing, clearly she hadn’t cum yet. I felt selfish for a moment, but couldn’t really think about what to do so I just kept my body moving to ensure it didn’t stop. David moved back and leaned on the desk behind him. I moved beside him and dropped into the chair. My thighs were slick with grool from my bare pussy. His cock clearly had my grool on it too.

​

It was mostly at the base, there was clear grool all over his cock, but on the base, and down the sides of his balls he had some white bits where it had gotten worked up. I smiled looking at his hard cock after sex. He hadn’t cum yet, and I thought I could blow him in front of Cindy. But I needed a moment so I sat there and caught my breath.

​

Cindy kept rubbing her clit. Then unexpectedly, she looked at David, and gave him the “come here” finger. I wasn’t really sure what she was doing. I just sat there recovering. David walked his naked body over to the bed. I figured he was maybe going to go tease her? Help her with her orgasm? Rub her clit.. maybe if she was really lucky he would go down on her, but I doubted it. He climbed on the bed on his knees. His cock now rock hard, swinging in front of him.

​

David grabbed her knees that were spread, and pulled on them, she slid onto her back, her head landing in the pillow she was leaning on. He was now kneeling between her knees that he was holding onto.. she put her hands on his sides, right above his hips.. and she pulled on him. I didn’t comprehend what was going on. Cindy took his cock in her hand. The first cock she had ever touched, and it was still wet with my grool. I still wasn’t comprehending what was going on. I was in my post orgasmic daze.

​

Cindy guided Davids hairless circumcised cock into her pussy, and gasped. He pushed himself completely into her. She gasped even deeper, and put her wrists on his shoulders, he laid into her, their chests touching. Her hard nipples poking into him. I mumbled something, but it wasn’t coherent. It was supposed to be “Excuse me!”

​

Cindy had just lost her virginity to my boyfriend. My boyfriend was fucking my girlfriend. I was aghast. But I was an adult, and I was mature, and I wasn’t going to get jealous. This was just a threesome. David started sliding in and out of her, just as he had moments before with me. Cindy put her arms around his neck and pulled him in close. He kissed her neck, and she moaned. Her breasts were bouncing up and down on her chest. Her nipples were hard.

​

She then picked up her feet and wrapped her legs around David’s waist, her ankles locked with one another and her feet pulled David into her. She was moaning loudly, he was grunting. I was starting to break down. I hadn’t expected this, I really had thought it would just be her watching. David wasn’t just a fuck buddy, he was a lover, and Cindy wasn’t just a fling, she was a lover too. They kept fucking there on the bed.

​

After about 5 min, I heard the familiar moaning from Cindy, she was about to cum. I was somewhat glad that it would be over soon, but also upset that David had managed to give her an orgasm just from penetration. At almost the same time, I heard David’s familiar grunt and groan. He moaned “I’m cumming.” Cindy pulled him in tight with her heels, he grabbed her ass and pulled her into him. He looked at her, and kissed her very deeply, she kissed back. It had been their first kiss. His hips bucked and squirmed and he slowly slowed down his thrusting. He collapsed into her, and they continued to make out, clearly feeling one another’s tongue.

​

I was very upset by this point. This was supposed to be David and me, with Cindy watching, and now he had just cum inside her. Something he had never really done with me. They continued kissing passionately. By this time I was just sitting there in the chair. I was no longer aroused. Partly because I normally came down pretty hard after an orgasm, but also partly because I was really really upset. I was mad, and felt cheated, and I was very jealous.

​

David slowly pulled out of Cindy and backed himself off, his cock was softening after it’s orgasm, and it was covered in a mixture of her grool and his cum. Cindy grabbed his balls and gave him a quick massage, she pulled him towards her mouth as she sat up close to him. She gave his head a little lick cleaning up a dribble of cum that was beading on the end of his head. She looked at me. “Come taste!?” David smiled at that comment. I declined.

“I’m ok, thanks.” I said, full of rage. I covered my breasts with my arm, and crossed my arms over my stomach.

Cindy gave it another quick suck, and a big “Mmmm” noise. “You taste good.” and she looked at David. He then got up, and went to the closet to grab a towel. He grabbed one from the laundry pile that I’d hid in months and months before. He wiped his dick off, while looking me in the eye, I was disgusted. What had turned me on like nothing else a day before, now made me upset. His flaccid cock was cleaned, and I turned my head away. I was trying to keep my composure.

I looked over to Cindy. She was sitting against the wall, her legs were still spread, and a bead of Davids cum was now dribbling out of her pussy. It was supposed to be my pussy. I had loved licking that pussy, but now I wasn’t interested at all. Her spreading her legs allowed her lips to spread, I could see right into her pussy hole, it gaped open after Davids cock had been in it and exploded. Cum leaked out over her hairy ass hole. The bush around her pussy was all covered in grool and cum, and it was slick, and all matted down. Not the perfect lofty bush I had known.

​

She dragged her fingers from her asshole, over her pussy, scooping up the cum and massaging it back into her pussy. She looked like a porn star, but that wasn’t doing it for me either. A drip landed on the back of her skirt taht she was sitting on.

​

that’s when I broke down. I started to cry, and got up from the seat before they could see. I grabbed Davids house coat and mumbled something about going to the bathroom and then ran across the hall into the bathroom. Locking the door behind me I sat on the toiled and balled my eyes out. I was so upset. I can’t explain how much I was hurt.

I stayed there probably 10 min. I eventually composed myself. I wiped my eyes and cleaned myself up. I wiped my pussy up, and cleaned my legs where the grool had been. I wrapped myself up in David’s house coat. I was determined to go back into the room and play nice. I even considered ensuring they didn’t suspect anything by going back in and sucking David off infront of Cindy. Make it more like a competition and see if I could get another load out of him.

​

As soon as I entered the room I knew something was up. They were sitting there, David in the chair, still naked except for the towel over his lap, Cindy was still on the bed, her skirt was covering her lap, her legs were crossed, she was wearing her shirt that she had hastily put on, the buttons were mismatched, and her bra was still on the bed. She wasn’t a super elegant sitter, and her soggy and matted bush was trying to peak out from behind her skirt.

I looked at them both. David spoke first.. “I think we all need to talk…” he led with.

I looked at him and started, “I’m sorry, I just wasn’t ready for that, I didn’t know I’d be so emotional.” I tried to say. My voice was broken.

“Cindy told me about you two, I told her about us.” David started again. I half interrupted him.

“Uh, ok?” He looked at me and he was clearly upset, so was Cindy.

“It’s not ok, you’ve been cheating on me, with her.” He started.

“It’s not cheating, she’s a girl…” I started again.

“It is cheating, and It’s not ok.” He said.

I started to stammer out an excuse, I don’t know where I was going with it. He interrupted me.

“You should probably just go.” He was very deliberate, I immediately understood that he was saying it was over between us.

I started grabbing my clothes off the floor. I put on my panties under the house coat, and then had to awkwardly drop it on the ground while I put my bra on. I was humiliated. Naked in the room with the two of them, staring at me. While I picked up my things like a cheap whore and dressed in full view of them. I felt disgusting. I got most of the clothes on, and the rest were under my arm. I grabbed my bag and looked at Cindy, she had her head turned sideways, looking at the floor. Tears in her eyes. I could still see her brown nipples through her shirt.

​

I let my self out. No one said another word.

On my walk home I balled my eyes out. I got home and took a shower, I felt so dirty, it all started to sink in. My infidelity, how I’d been going behind their backs. That I’d justified it to myself, but that hadn’t made it ok in the long run. I did love both of them, and now I had neither.

​

The next few days were really rough. Cindy came home a day later, and told me she was moving out. Going to live with friends. I couldn’t afford the place on my own, so I packed up my stuff and moved into a bedroom in another house with some other people. David never talked to me ever again. Not a single word. Cindy said very little to me, we avoided one another in the house until she moved out.

​

I realised a little bit later, that every time I thought about either one of my lovers, that thought would be pushed out of my head, as the two of them having a very intimate orgasm together was pushed in, followed by David withdrawing his spent cock from Cindy’s bombed out pussy, after he had taken her virginity. Cum and matted hair starring me in the face. Cum leaking from her gaping pussy. And to this day, the smell of their sex has stuck with me. I’ve had partners since, and if our sex smells anything like they did, I’m instantly turned off.

​

I ended up throwing out the bra and panties I wore that night. I didn’t want to see them anymore. I threw out my toy as well as it reminded me of making her cum, I threw out the lube that David and I used. Anything that tied them to me in a memory was thrown out. After this I stopped dating or messing around with anyone for almost a year, and when I started back up again looking for intimacy, it was not good, or healthy at all.

​

And I suppose that’s my story for now. This one was really difficult to read. It was a high, that so quickly turned into what is definitely the lowest part of my life, but typing it out is kind of helpful as well. I hope everyone enjoys it.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ao8mg8/the_time_i_f_had_a_threesome