NYE with the gf and a previous crush [MFF]

Felicia and I had been dating for a bit when we decided to go to my fiends NYE party. She knew I didn’t like meeting new people so was willing to go to a party with some of my friends.

Felicia by the point was dressing super preppy. Her black hair had turned back to her normal color and went to her shoulders. She was hardly a gym rat but wasn’t fat. She had nice curves with smooth pale skin.

She oozed sex. She talked in a low voice almost a whisper at times and was very touchy feely with everyone.

She was also a major slut. I was aware that she had slept with more men then I knew I real life before we met. And part of me was kind of suspicious that she still had some guys on the side.

I couldn’t judge too much since this was a period of time I occasionally had a guy or two. We both just didn’t ask many questions and both were open about trying anything. (See previous stories)

The party was a typical New Year’s Eve bash. There was alcohol, stupid drinking games and dumb shit on the TV. I knew a few folks there, I was friends with all the women actually. I didn’t know the boyfriends well. So it was kind of awkward. It got worse when Mandy showed up.

Mandy was a girl I had semi hooked up with a year before. It wasn’t an exciting story and it was a one night thing that didn’t really go anywhere. She was tall, curvy with long curly hair. She was from down south and came to visit our mutual friend from time to time. I didn’t realize she was in town for this.

I introduced her to Felicia and be two of them hit it off. I had briefly mentioned to Felicia that I had a past with Mandy but it didn’t go far. For some reason that got her excited.

Fast forward a couple of hours and I’m talking to people with Felicia and Mandy no where to be seen. I roam around and find them outside in the cold chatting. They both smile and look at me and Mandy excuses herself.

“She is fun,” Felicia started in. “Do you know she is kind of part of a couple thing back home? She joins her roommates in their bed from time to time.”

I was a bit shocked by this. First for not even thinking that someone like Mandy would be like that and for Felicia able to get someone to open about their sex life so easily. It was a talent I would always be amazed at.

“So you never fucked her right? I think we can change that tonight. Are you up for it?”

Did my girlfriend just arrange a threesome? My heat was pounding out of my damn chest.

“She claims she isn’t bi…but we will see,” Felicia continued just smiling to herself.

We talked for a few minutes and I told her I was for it. She jumped up and we went to find Mandy. I didn’t realize they wanted this to happen now. It was a good thirty minutes before the ball dropped and I was fine for heading to some place private after the party. But Felicia didn’t want her to back out I think.

We found Mandy in the kitchen and without saying a word Felecia got her to follow us upstairs unnoticed.

We found a bedroom (my friends mothers room) and closed the door behind us. Felicia turned on the lights (she wanted to see her).

“Ummm. This door doesn’t lock?” I commented.

“So?” My girlfriend responded.

She led Mandy to the bed who looked very nervous. I stood by the door leaning against it scared to death that someone would come in.

Felicia quickly stripped Mandy to nothing. Mandy didn’t even look at me. She just stared right at Felicia. Mandy had a great body. She was 6 feet tall and not model thin. Just perfectly portioned, her ass was round and tight. She had amazing d cup tits that Felicia began to slowly suck on. Watching two 20 year olds go at was something that I look back and still wonder how the fuck I was able to get that to happen. Then remembering I had little to do with it.

Felicia took turns kissing her tits and Mandy just slowly let her hands run up and down Felicia’s body, almost scared to touch anything.

Felicia took the lead and laid her down on the bed and began to slowly strip in front of her. She looked at me and smiled.

“Get naked with us, I know Mandy needs a cock to distract her,” Felicia commanded.

I took my clothes off as I slowly walked to the bed. I got on the bed with my half hard dick and put it to Mandy’s mouth.

She looked up at me and had a look of uncertainty. I began to wonder if we were pushing her own limits. Our one time together didn’t even go this far.

I looked at Felicia but all I could see was her hair spread out all over Mandy’s thighs and lower stomach. Mandy has spread her legs and gave access to her pussy for Felicia’s mouth.

I felt a mouth on my dick and looked back at Mandy’s face. Her eyes closed shut and slowly sucking my dick.

I was unsure what to do so I just stayed in my kneeling position receiving a blowjob from a girl I never thought I’d see again.

For a few minutes this continued. My eyes darted from the mouth sucking me to my girlfriend eating pussy like it was her last meal.

She eventually came up for air and I could see she had a few fingers in Mandy was slowly moving them around.

“Your pussy is fucking so good,” Felicia said.

The fingering and licking went on for a couple more minutes before Mandy fully gave up blowing me. She kept my dick in her hand and started cumming on my girlfriends face. Her body just shook and little gasps escaped her mouth.

Felicia let go of her clit and smiled.

“My turn,” she said.

Mandy just laid their frozen.

“Come on, it’s just eating pussy you’ll be fine,” Felecia reassured her. I stepped back and watched them switch positions.

“Get that tongue in there,” Felicia demanded in almost a dominate tone. She knew she was in charge. Mandy hesitated at first but slowly lowered her mouth onto my girlfriends pussy and began licking around her clit until eventually finding the sweet spot.

I got back on the bed and Felicia took my dick into her mouth and went to town on it.

She could tell I was close to cumming. The scene was just too much.

Felecia stopped what she was doing and grabbed Mandy’s head with both hands.

“That’s it. Lick my fucking pussy. You want some cock?”

Mandy moves her head a little and moaned. She positioned herself a little better so that she was kneeling with her pussy available.

“You want his cock don’t you while you lick my bare pussy? Good.”

I took the hint and moved behind Mandy and got on the bed behind her. I entered slowly but she was soaked and was already prepared for a fuck by Felecia’s fingers.

I slowly began moving my dick in and out of her.

“What the fuck guys?”

I looked and saw my friend there with the most disgusted look. She slammed the door shut as quickly as she opened it.

Felicia started laughing. I started to go a little soft from that.

“Busted.”

Was all my girlfriend said as she closed her eyes again and held Mandy’s head down.

I don’t know what Mandy was thinking. But here I was having a threesome on my friends mothers bed as the ball was dropping.

That sudden realization of how hot this was sent me over the edge. I pushed deep holding on to Mandy’s ass and came hard in her. I heard Mandy moan in unison and my orgasm shook my own body.

I pulled out and Felicia let go of Mandy and sat up and made out with her a bit.

Mandy looked shell shocked by the whole thing.

Felicia got off the bed and started to dress. I went to Mandy and asked if she was okay. She smiled and we kissed. Her mouth covered in my girlfriends juices.

We all dressed and then headed back downstairs.

My friend glared at us. Beyond pissed. We chilled out with Mandy for a bit more but we had to head out.

Mandy later told us that after we left and most guests were gone she was grilled about what happened. And tried to convince them she wasn’t bi. Our friend later confronted me about the whole thing. She was a very open type person and we were very close. She was mostly my pissed we messed up her mothers bed.

We sadly only hung out one more time but it was very platonic. I think Felicia scared Mandy in some way.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ajpens/nye_with_the_gf_and_a_previous_crush_mff