My twin brother and I, and a hot fitness girl [MMF]

Hi! We are Oliver and Alex (writing), and we are two college students, and identical twins. We are identical in every way, and we are wired the same way, so we both enjoy the same kind of activities (sexual and otherwise). We have been writing about some recent experiences in /r/gaystoriesgonewild (which you can find [starting with the first part here](https://www.reddit.com/r/gaystoriesgonewild/comments/9ftf6z/my_twin_brother_and_i_had_our_first_encounter/)…), but be warned that Oliver and I have been experimenting with each other. In the course of our stories, we mentioned a [threesome with a girl](https://www.reddit.com/r/gaystoriesgonewild/comments/9graez/my_twin_brother_and_i_and_other_people/), and people were interested in hearing more details, but that’s mostly straight sex, so we decided to write it here in this sub instead. So here we go.

Oliver and I are gym rats, 6′ 2″, and well endowed (8 – 8.5 inches). We were not always muscular (pretty twinky in high school), but we have been spending a lot of time at the gym while in college, and keeping track of our diet, and we have been getting awesome results, so we graduated from twinks to full-blown college jocks. We are kind of shy, but we do get a lot of attention from our female friends (in other words, we are “hot as fuck” haha). We were sophomores and already pretty nicely built, when this girl approached us at the gym for a spotter, and chatted us up (again, we are fucking shy). We will call her Sue for the purpose of this story. Sue was hot as hell, and my brother and I had already noticed her at the gym. She is about 5′ 5″, in great shape, fantastic breasts, and an awesome ass that you can only get by squatting a hell of a lot. She was not shy either to show her shape, and she wore these amazingly sexy sport bras and tights, that showed off her best features: her amazing cleavage and her award winning legs+ass. We would check her out, and say “hey, sup”, but that was about it, so it had to be her who called for spotter help, and introduced herself. We started seeing each other regularly at the gym, and chatting, and soon we were bar buddies as well.

All three of us, Oliver, Sue, and I, were in and out of relationships in our freshmen year. Nonetheless, when we partied together, there was an undeniable sexual tension, and obvious willingness by all three of us to take this a step further. Oliver and I had hot debates about whether Sue was more into him or me, but we figured she would fuck either one if given the opportunity. Unfortunately, either she was with someone, or we were, or Oliver and I were, well, exploring, and not interested in other people. Regardless, I did have [a brief date with Sue](https://www.reddit.com/r/gaystoriesgonewild/comments/9g3zg8/my_twin_brother_and_i_go_with_the_flow/) when I was first semester sophomore year, and she was obviously hoping for more than a dinner and a drink, but I was at the time figuring things out with Oliver. Later that academic year, however, I did get to see her again, and after some dinner, we ended up at her place, and as soon as we went thru the door, our clothes flew away, and we had some incredible sex. She looked amazing in gym outfits, but she looked even better naked, riding my dick hard, while her boobs jumped up and down. We did it a couple times, but her roommate wanted to come back to the room, and we had to end it.

I went back to my room, and told Oliver about Sue, and how we fucked, and how much I was able to last while she was riding me like crazy, and how she didn’t let me put a condom on because she wanted to feel it all. We had also debated for a long time if her boobs were fake, because they looked so nice and big, and I could happily confirm they were real. Yessss.

A busy week went by, and I got together again with Sue at a bar, got buzzed, and then we went to a common friend’s house, were we smoked a joint together. We got super horny, and I asked her to go back to her room… Fuck, her place was busy. She asked if we could come up to our room. “Nah, Oliver is there”, I said, and she said “is that a problem?” I replied “well, I don’t want to be a jerk and kick Oliver out of the room…”, and she replied “he can stay…” Apparently I am not a very quick thinker, and replied “well, no, it is a small room and I’m not gonna put him thru that”. Sue had to explain with a wicked smile:

– no silly, I mean, maybe we can party together?

– ohhhh,… are you serious? Do you mean… – finally it hit me.

– yeah why not. You are both cool boys <wink>

She winked, and placed her hand on my crotch. I immediately imagined the possibilities and got VERY excited. “Let me ask Oliver”. I texted Oliver, and explained the situation. “You think she wants to fuck with both of us??” he replied. Yep, I thought so! He gave us the green light, and headed over. We are always shirtless in our room, and my brother made no exception. He was in shorts, barefoot, shirtless, and I couldn’t help but notice that the bastard must have been doing push ups and sit ups while we were on our way, because he looked pumped and fucking hot. She noticed too, said “fuck Oliver, looking great” and ran a hand slowly from chest to abs. I followed his lead, and took my shirt off, and she smiled and said “you are not too bad yourself Alex”, but she didn’t take the hand off Oliver’s abs. Oliver had also found some beer, and he offered us something to drink, while some music was playing. We had a sip of our beers, and Sue turned to me, grabbed my neck and started making out with me. Oliver stood there just watching the show. Then, Sue turned around, and kissed Oliver too. So hot. I moved in closer, and grabbed Sue’s breasts from behind, while she was still hanging from Oliver’s neck and making out. We made a twins sandwich out of her, and I started kissing her neck, while still rubbing her breasts over her top. Oliver’s hands had gone down to her butt, and he was squeezing her cheeks over her yoga pants. They kept making out heavily, and I took the chance to grab her shirt and take it off, and undo her bra and throw it as far away as possible. Then went back to grab her amazingly full breasts and kiss her from behind. My brother’s arms were still down, grabbing hard onto her butt, I noticed his impressive triceps tensing up as he kept playing with her. I brought another hand to her butt, and placed it between her thighs. Her crotch seemed very moist… she wanted this as much as we did, probably more.

My brother was still making out with her until he lowered his head and started eating her neck, and then the top of her breasts, and then dove onto the nipples. My hands were on the way, so I lowered them, and pulled her pants down, until they were off, and found myself on my knees, with her amazing worked out butt in front of my face. I sank my face into her crack, and pulling her legs and butt cheeks apart, started eating her from behind. She moaned loudly, and shook as my tongue found her pussy lips.

My brother took his pants off, and moved on to a bed, taking her torso with him, and placing her head right by the head of his beautiful cock. I moved her lower body onto the bed also, putting her on all fours, and now I had better access to her pussy. She was dripping wet, so I sucked her juices out with my tongue, and used my fingers to open her up, and get my tongue further in. In the meantime, she was making some muffled moans, because she had my brother’s big dick in her mouth. I was still going down on her, when she popped the dick out of her mouth for a second, and begged “oh please fuck me already”, and kept sucking on the dick. Following her lead, I got up on my knees behind her, and found that my cock was just as hard as if she had been sucking on it. I asked if I should put a condom on, and shook her head negatively, while she didn’t even take my brother’s cock out of the mouth. So I went for the kill. I looked at Oliver’s eyes, while pushed my dick inside her, and he gave me a “fucking yes bro” look. He kept looking at me while I started going in and out of her, slow at first, until I was able to fuck my entire dick into her pussy. I picked up the speed, and started banging her hard.

She started screaming in pleasure, and losing it, so she could barely concentrate on Oliver’s cock, but it didn’t matter, because Oliver was mesmerized looking at me fucking this gorgeous chick in front of him. He started jacking off his own cock, which was really hot, and I was banging so hard, that I could tell I was going to blow my load, so I reduced the pace, so I could last more for her. I kept fucking her for a while, and she started having orgasm after orgasm, and shaking in between orgasms. I looked at my dick and her cream was all over my dick and her pussy. This put me over the edge, and fucked her hard until I came, pushing myself as far inside as I could before shooting a huge load. She had yet another orgasm, and her face collapsed on the bed, while her butt and legs were trembling. My brother got up, and took my place. He gave me a high five, a quick kiss that she didn’t see, slapped my ass, and got behind Sue. Her head was resting on the bed, her eyes had rolled up in pleasure, and her ass was still up in the air. My cum had started to drip out of her pussy, mixing with her own milky white cream. My brother couldn’t resist, and took a big gulp off her pussy, licking and swallowing the mix of juices. She trembled again, and he went back for more, eating her with his full mouth, and digging into the pussy for more cum with his tongue. He looked at me in between gulps, and his lips and chin was full of cum and cream. She kept having aftershocks with each lick of her pussy, and then without much warning, he got up standing on the bed, and squatted on top of her, digging his dick all the way into her pussy in one move. She screamed but he put his hand on her back, so she wouldn’t move. He took the dick out, and he and I looked at his dick, covered now in my cum and her juices. I wanted to suck on it right there and then, but Oliver said no with his head, knowing full well I wanted that.

He went all in one more time, and she screamed a second time. He pulled out, and she whimpered “more”, so he started fucking her like this. His quads were popping out of his massive legs in this position, and I thought it was the hottest thing ever. I approached Sue’s head, and popped my dick into her mouth, while Oliver kept holding her down with his hand, and fucked her hard. He got a good rhythm going, and she started moaning and saying “yes, yes, yes” with every thrust. Soon she was having orgasm after orgasm, and I could see my brother’s dick getting more and more of her cream out of her pussy. Finally, Oliver was spent, and he came during three powerful thrusts. He dismounted, and what was left of Sue was on the bed, still shaking with orgasm aftershocks. She passed out, and I went to Oliver, and kissed him. He looked so fucking strong and manly, that he looked incredibly sexy. We made out a bit, laid down on each side of Sue, and slept like warriors after a battle.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/9gz05g/my_twin_brother_and_i_and_a_hot_fitness_girl_mmf