[FMF] Two girls, a guy, and a twin bed; AKA the best night of my life

I’ve never opened up about this before to anyone except to my ex, so I’m going to type some preface and a couple missed threesome opportunities I’ve had before I get to the story that’ll help give some context for why this night was so incredible and lucky for me (skip to the 5th paragraph for the story).

Context: I’m a 23 year old male living in a small college apartment. Ever since I was around 12-14 I’ve fantasized about being with two girls or more. My first ‘porn’ experience was looking up youtube videos where one guy was being wrestled or flirted with by more than 1 girl (had to keep it pg being in a religious household, if I was caught with actual porn I was going to be in huge trouble). I guess you could say it’s my preference, or you could call me polyamorous. One girl doesn’t really do it for me anymore, despite being with so many girls over my life. I guess you could say I’m embracing my preference for the first time.

Despite being this way, I’ve never been with more than one girl at a time. It’s always been my hugest fantasy, but I’ve struck out when I’ve had the opportunity. I’m terrible at taking a hint, and usually guess that a girl isn’t into me by default, usually waiting for them to make the first move (another preference of mine). I’m a decently good looking guy, so girls have always liked me, but I was always too uncomfortable to signal back I can think of 2 stories in my life where I’ve missed cues or been too timid from having a potential threesome.

First missed threesome: One time was with my ex during my sophomore year in college, a beautiful short Indian girl who would often talk about how much she loved sex. We only dated a month, so we never ended up sleeping together. A few months after we break up, I get a late night text from her inviting me to come join her in her friend’s dorm room. I assume what she’s thinking, but when I got there she was in this cozy dorm chair cuddling her friend, a tall blonde girl who looked like she was in a sorority or something, so I assumed sex was out of the equation. My ex was always really touchy-feely, so I didn’t think anything of it. When I got in the room she told me to sit down and started cuddling me the same way, and her and her friend started sharing sex stories. At one point they said this guy wanted to have a threesome with them, and asked me what I thought. I felt unsure of whether they were talking about it in a positive way, so I played it safe and was like “oh no thats not good” or something. That was my first fuck up. Then they both got up and started undressing in the closet next to me. I didn’t think anything of it again (yeah I was **that** bad at taking hints). Then they started cuddling again and saying that they ‘needed a guy for something’. Blonde girl gets up to use the bathroom, and my ex comes over and starts making out with me. I was still kind of bitter about the breakup (she had cheated on me) so was a little withdrawn from the kiss. She backed off and her friend came back. I think that was my last strike, because they asked me to leave shortly after. My ex kissed me again on the way out and pulled her waist in close to mine. I didn’t see the signs until waaaay later and have regretted it since.

Second missed threesome: This one went a little further. I had met this girl off of tinder, lets call her Sue, around my freshman year at school, and ended up losing my virginity to her. She wasn’t super attractive, but she was really forward from the start and that excited me a lot. We messed around a lot after that, and one day she brought up renting a hotel one night with her friends. She said she wanted me to herself and we could have a bed with just the two of us, but more people showed up and we ended up having to share it. I ended up paying for most of the hotel, so I got to decide who shared the bed with us (there were about 5-6 of us so we didn’t have a choice at that point). One of Sue’s friends showed up who was this super cute short black girl, let’s call her Katie, and was also really forward. Her and Sue were super flirty with me all night, and once the alcohol started flowing and the night got late, the 3 of us climbed into one of the beds. Sue was super comfortable with her body, and stripped down to her panties and bra. I was in the middle of the two girls, and put my arm around Katie while Sue was fighting for my attention. After a little while I unhooked Sue’s bra and the three of us started making out. Katie climbed onto Sue and started making out with her, but I started feeling uncomfortable since there were like 4 other people in the room probably watching it happen. Sue mentioned after a bit she was hungry and that the 3 of us should go out and get food, so I stupidly took that as a hint that they wanted to take it elsewhere. We ended up just actually getting food, coming back and going to sleep. If I hadn’t been so uncomfortable maybe something would’ve happened, but who knows. Me and Katie kept in touch and stayed friends for awhile after that.

The Threesome: About 3 months ago I broke up with my girlfriend of 4 years, and hadn’t been with anyone since. I had pretty much given up at ever having a threesome, but a couple months ago Katie hit me up after a long time asking if she could stay over. She and I used to just cuddle and watch movies etc, but never took it further than that. I’m guessing she found out I was single, because she started asking me if we could start cuddling again. We smoked, drank a bit, cuddled every few nights, and it was exactly what I needed after the break up. I wasn’t really looking for sex or anything, so this was just a simple, wonderful thing to help me get over my ex. After a week or two of this, she messaged me drunk saying she wanted to have sex with me. I told her no because I wasn’t quite over my ex and it didn’t really feel right. She was persistent, but nothing came of it. Whenever she would come over she stripped down to nothing but a t-shirt and would tell me how comfortable she felt with me. Last night me and her plan on kicking it with a guy friend of ours, and she asks if she can bring over her friend ‘Laura’. About an hour before they all came over, Katie messages me saying Laura thinks I’m really cute and would have sex with me if I felt the same way. I looked at her facebook pictures, but they were all kind of vague, dark pictures, and I couldn’t really see her, so I just assumed she wasn’t that attractive in person. Fast forward to when they get to my place, Laura ends up looking hella cute. A little chubby, but like the busty kind of chubby. The four of us hang out and drink, the girls pop some xanax, and Laura starts to be extra flirty with me and Katie. You know, touching my arm when we’re talking, sitting close to me, we both know where it’s going. At this point I’m just waiting for our guy friend to dip so I can get with Laura. Right before he leaves both Katie and Laura start getting more touchy with me and sitting super close etc, but since me and Katie are usually like that I didn’t think anything would happen between us. I’m starting to get really attracted to Laura since she was starting to get super forward, and we all decide it’s time to sleep. Katie mentioned before they came that she would need a place to sleep, and I said the 3 of us could see if we could fit on my twin mattress, and if not I had a blow up air mattress. So we all squeeze together, Katie on one end, me in the middle, and Laura near the edge, and it wasn’t as uncomfortable as we thought it’d be. Katie and Laura are both only wearing one of my t-shirts and panties at this point, so this was just pure bliss for me. Laura was laying on me with her leg over my crotch touching me all over with her hand up my shirt and her face in my neck and Katie was sleeping with her back facing me hugging my arm that’s around her shoulder. Keep in mind this is a twin bed, so we were all super close together. I’ve always been more about the foreplay/cuddling/kissing etc, so this was absolute heaven. Laura is super high off the xanax and was excited to do things with me, so she had this huge smile and was humming peacefully, and Katie starts to nudge a bit closer to us. Laura starts kissing my neck softly and we start making out. Katie turns her head back at us and starts watching, and Laura turns her around so they’re both laying on me with their legs over me. They both start to kiss and I’m just laying between them in awe over the moment. I never expected my Tuesday night would end up like this. Me and Laura start making out again and Katie starts touching Laura and playing with her a bit. They ask if me and Laura could switch so the girls could mess around, so I start touching Laura from behind and we start fucking while the girls make out. I can feel Katie touching Laura as we’re fucking, and then started to notice Katie eating her out at the same time. After a little while of this, I roll Laura over and start fucking her from behind while Katie continues to kiss/fondle her. They start to get a little tired from the xanax, so I start to just finger both of them until they both cum until we all got tired and went to sleep. It all lasted about 20-30 minutes.

So there’s my threesome story. The actual threesome was kind of short, but it was more than perfect for my first time. It happened right when I had pretty much given up hope that it would ever happen, so the whole thing was completely surreal and random. I’ve never shared anything this personal before online but I wanted to write about this mainly for myself and anyone who’s interested. I don’t think there could have been a more perfect way to move on from my ex. *Raises glass* here’s to more threesomes and new beginnings!

Thanks for reading!

Edit: Formatting

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/97n82q/fmf_two_girls_a_guy_and_a_twin_bed_aka_the_best