Let me set the scene. I’m [M] a senior in high school in a small town, dating a girl that was a mature sophomore. I was your good kid that didn’t do anything wrong. I was very active at church and was still a virgin. Of course I had seen porn but making out was as far as I had been since it was with other christian girls.
I have a friend, she was a junior and was dating a good friend of my girlfriend, he was also a sophomore. She started coming to church and became a regular. We got to know each other just by being in the same group of friends and from church.
She did not have a car. I did and I conveniently lived pretty close to her apartment. On our Christmas break we spent a lot of late nights out with friends. At the end of the night I would give her a ride home, drop her off and say bye. Over the days/weeks we began to get closer and flirt a little. Before I knew it we were getting in my truck and holding hands, still dating other people.
Then movie night came. A group of people stayed after church one night to watch a movie. This was just a bunch of friends, no adults. Halfway through the movie we both walk out at different times. I met her in the dark hallway and we kissed. After a few minutes we left to find an empty classroom. Before I knew it she was on her back on the floor and we were making out/dry humping. We went back to the movie.
Another night I was taking her home and she had her hand in my leg. Before I knew it I was hard and she was rubbing my virgin cock through my pants. She was the first girl to rub me. We made out in her apartment parking lot and she went home.
And finally the fun night. We went to a friends house to watch a movie. We started sitting beside eachother but by the end of the movie she was snuggling beside me. I had my arm wrapped around her under the blanket. Through the movie I rubbed my hand over her until I reached the top of her pants. Total virgin here but I knew I wanted more. I slowly slid my hand into her pants rubbing, feeling the shaved hair under her panties. Eventually this stopped and we left. That night I was driving my parents suburban because we all rode together to eat, so at the end of the night me and my friend got into the suburban and I was going to take her home. As soon as we got in we started making out. I slid my hand back into her pants and felt her pussy for the first time. We ended up stopping and driving to her apartment.
We were sitting and talking. I assumed she was just going to get out and go home. We started to kiss again. Before I knew it we had moved to the middle seat of the SUV. The windows were dark and it was night so we didn’t worry about others seeing us. She sat in my lap making out. I was hard already and she started grinding on me while we kissed. A few minutes later I slid my hands from her butt cheeks up her back until I reached her bra. She stopped and looked at me. “Want to take it off?” I slowly pulled her shirt up. For the first time in my life I had a shirtless girl on my lap. My actual girlfriend never crossed my mine. She unbuttoned my pants and looked at me. “Are you a virgin?” Of course I said yes. She thought for a second and then asked me if I wanted to stop. I knew we should but I didn’t want to. She said she didn’t want to either. We were both about to lose our virginity.
At that point she pulled my pants down. My dick was as hard as could be and was wet with precum. She looked at it and slowly touched it. I she rubbed it for a few minutes before I started undoing her pants. Pulled them down until she was just in her panties. I reached around and unsnapped her bra, seeing her tiny little tits for the first time. I kissed her lips. Then under her ear. Then down her neck to her collarbone. Slowly down her chest until I reached her nipples. They were small but hard. I rubbed one boob while sucking her. She set up and I grabbed her panties and slid them down her hips. Touching her wet pussy for the first time. She kissed me then worked her way down my chest and stomach. She slid her lips over my head and sucked for a few minutes, I could tell she was trying to figure it out as she went. I made her stop so I wouldn’t cum. She got back in my lap and grabbed my dick. I watched as she slowly slid her body down in mine.
So obviously the rest did not last long. A few minutes of slow moving and he rolling her hips did it for me. I had masturbated enough to know when it was time to pull out. We were taking it nice and slow and then she lifted her body up so that it almost came out and then went down, as deep as she could go. This did it for me. I quickly pulled out and came on us both, my christian sister, in the backseat of my parents car, in the parking lot of her apartment, without our bf/gf having any idea.
Of course we had sex a few more times before losing touch during college.
Btw, typing this at work on my phone , so sorry for the typos.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/7mow7k/mf_bad_church_kids_virgins
Ahhh the memories… great story!
Hot story.
I’d only suggest giving some people in the story some fake names. To help tell the difference between your girlfriend and your first partner.
Thanks for sharing.