I got lucky and made my HS varsity wrestling team as a sophomore. My HS had both male and female wrestling teams. The heavyweight on the girl’s team was an all-state senior. Her coach decided she needed someone her size to spar with so she made arrangements with my coach for her and I to drill after our respective practices.
At 6’3″ and #235 I had maybe 2-3″ and zero pounds on her. She had a reputation as being a good student, a big jock (she also played softball) and a thug of sorts. She was a black/Samoan mix with a rather beautiful face.
I was extremely nervous before our first training session given her experience, age and reputation. Two minutes into the session it was clear my physical strength and speed made it a horrible mismatch. Still, she was a very good technician, she was serious and it was a worthwhile learning experience for both of us.
After one session she said she needed to work on escapes and asked if I would spar with her again? I said sure — to meet me at the “state (university) wrestling room” tomorrow (Saturday) at ten AM. This room is always open during the season and unless practice is going on, anyone can use it to drill or cut weight.
We both showed up wearing our HS practice singlets. The first thing I noticed is that she smelled really good that morning and that her skin was very soft. While I did my best to hide it, I’m sure she felt my hardon rubbing against her — the first time that ever happened during our training sessions. As we are working, the assistant college coach entered the room and observed us. We told him we were from the local HS (we knew each other by sight) and we were there to work on escapes. He graciously spent about 10 minutes instructing us and then said to be sure to shut the door on our way out. The team was on their way to an away match and the door had to be locked while they were gone. Sure, no problem.
We continued to work when we decided to take a water break. As I was sucking water out of the water fountain, she closed the door and turned off most of the lights in the room. She then said “let’s get naked” as she began stripping off her singlet. I stood there like a dork with my jaw on the ground watching her — my brain simply couldn’t handle the overload. Free of the singlet she begins pulling her tight sports bra over her head. I was still frozen when she said “well?”, which triggered me to begin removing away my own singlet.
She was down to her panties and I was down to my jock when I finally recognized just how sexy and beautiful she was! Huge boobs, sculpted/thick bottom and that face! Like a complete jerk I momentarily contemplated how she was not the petite blonde Barbie I always assumed I would lose my virginity to. When she finished dispensing with her panties (revealing an almost bald pubic area), leaving only her wrestling shoes. OMG! Hot! I struggled to maneuver my jockstrap over my now steel-hard cock when she assumed the “down” position on her hands and knees. The beauty of her broad bottom in that position just about made me pass out with lust.
Shaking, I knelt behind her as she reached underneath herself for me. She very carefully guided me into her very wet, very hot and very tight pussy. Her vagina seemed to be sucking me into her body as I ever so slowly pushed until I was balls-deep inside of her. I held onto her hips, arched my back, pressed as tightly as I could into her and just luxuriated in the overwhelmingly wonderful feeling as I felt her pussy pulsate against my dick.
I don’t want to move when I hear her hiss “fuck me!” I begin to thrust my hips like a pro (thanks to years of practice based on the advice of a wise sage and my hours of studying porn.) After far too short of a time I felt her squirm. I became alarmed thinking that somehow I had offended her and that she was done with me!?! In reality she was turning onto her back so that we could share another position together. While listening to the beautiful melody of my bloated balls slapping against her firm butt, she told me to pull out before I climaxed, so as not to cum inside of her. In far too short of a time I did just that as my multiple huge spurts of cum showered the wrestling mat, replete with guttural/screaming sounds from yours truly.
In the span of maybe 10 seconds I regressed from a total boss into an overwhelmed, deeply embarrassed HS sophomore. Clumsily I begin mopping up my boatload of cum with a towel, while she squirmed to the edge of the mat, sitting with her back against the wall. We were both shaking, sweaty and nude as I sat next to her. Once we regained our composure we acted out just about every porno scene I had ever witnessed — plus a few she brought to the party. What an experience!
Once we were completely spent we managed to say goodbye to one another, before making sure to close the door behind us as we headed downstairs to our respective locker rooms to shower and change into street clothes. My head was absolutely spinning as I took what must have been a 30 minute hot shower. As I existed the locker room there she was — also freshly showered and smiling. We spent the next hour or two sitting on a bench, necking. No one cared — we were simply two anonymous students innocently enjoying ourselves.
We shared more wonderful times after that. I never told her that she popped my cherry that day — although I suspect she knew…
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/7mejsj/mf_was_your_first_time_as_offthewall_good_as_my