If you like me, you aren’t straight

David pumped the break and guided his 2005 sunfire onto the gravel. The night was pouring buckets and the hitch hiker on the side of the road was drenched as she got into the small two door vehicle. He gave the stranger a once over, he couldn’t tell at first if they were a man or woman but he noticed the modest breasts on their chest and concluded they were female.

“Where you headed, little lady?” He pressed on the gas.

“The next town.”

He was taken aback by the rude tone, “What landed you out here all alone on a night like this?” He waited for a response, but got none. He noticed this girl he had picked up had no bags, just a loose shirt and a skirt. “Do you have somewhere to stay? You’re going to catch a cold.”

“Sorry…” they huffed and choked on their breath.

“Are you okay?” He probed, a semi passed them illuminating the hitchhikers face. A bruise rested on their cheek.

“I will get you a hotel room, you don’t have to worry anymore.” He said calmly

“Oh, um…” the hitchhiker choked again.

“You’re a very pretty girl, whatever happened to you I am sure you didn’t deserve it.” He rested his hand on their shoulder, patting them gently. They recoiled instinctively.

“You… think I’m pretty?” They asked. He looked them over again, they were cute, he wasn’t sure about their age though so he hesitated.

“How old are you?” He removed his hand and placed it back on the wheel as he turned around a sharp bend. His passenger fell into him slightly, apologizing as they buckled into their seat.

“18” They explained. David felt his heart skip a beat and his mind wander. “I’m trans.” They whispered. Dave stopped the car, he looked down at the passengers lap, he could see a slight bulge in the soaked skirt that was sticking to their contours. He tore his eyes away and started driving again “I didn’t notice, don’t worry I’m not into people like you.”

The passenger let out a snort. “Right, but you think I am pretty.”

“There’s nothing sexual about that.” He retorted.

“I can see your cock through your pants.” They pointed to his lap.

He slammed on the breaks, the car skidded a little ways farther. “You want out?”

“No… I’m sorry.”

They sat in silence as they continued onwards. He turned on some music, country, then classic rock. The lights of the next town Shawn on the horizon. The passenger finally spoke again.

“I’m Mala by the way.”

David was still struggling to get his cock under control and didn’t think before snapping his name back at them. He took a breath. Nice to meet you Mala.

“It doesn’t make you less of a man you know…” Mala whispered. He glared at them. “I mean, you wouldn’t be gay…” David’s scowl softened a bit. “you wouldn’t be straight either… I’m nonbinary, so.”

“Non-what now?” David turned down the on ramp.

“Non-binary, I am not a man or a woman… but I can do a lot of feminine things.” Mala placed their hand on the partition between their seats. David took his time to process this, he came to a stop at the first set of lights. No one was around.

“Like what?’ He asked quietly.

Mala moved their hand further, brushing up against David’s cock. “All kinds of things.” With just one hand they unbuckled and unzipped David’s pants and began rubbing up against his exposed boxers.

“I’m straight…” David choked on his words.

“Are you sure?” Mala pulled their hand away and placed it to their face. Taking in a deep breath of David’s sent.

“Yes…?” He muttered. “I think.”

“Do you want me to stop?”

There was a silence as they pulled into the motel parking lot. David zipped up his pants and buckled up. “Wait here” he got out and walked into the lobby. Mala watched him through the windows, paying for a room. He looked over and their eyes locked for a moment. But he blushed and turned his gaze.

He walked over to a room and motioned for Mala to come. They got out of the car, the rain was pouring just as hard as before. Mala approached the door, David had closed it behind him. Pushing it open, they entered to see David standing there, cock exposed.

“Show me what you can do.” He said. Mala closed the door behind them and knelt down before David. Both of them dripping wet from the rain. They gripped his cock and gave it a few strokes, it wasn’t that big but it was thick. When they leaned in they could smell his sent again. It was intoxicating. His cock brushed across their lips. As they opened wide and enveloped his throbbing member they tasted him. He was salty, unclean. He moaned “You slut.” Mala felt their own genitals begin to moisten.

Coming up for air, Mala responded “I’m your slut.” Then went back down on him, pushing his cock as far into their throat as they could. David took hold of their hair and began pumping inside their mouth. Mala could barely breath, it was exhilarating. They tapped on his leg as they felt their head start to rush. He pulled out and immediately lifted them up, throwing them on the bed.

He pulled their shirt off over their head, grabbing at their breasts and sucking on their nipples. Mala moaned in ecstasy, their genitals throbbing and dripping. David pulled down their skirt and ripped their panties to the side. He stopped, surprised. Is that…

“I had an experimental surgery…” Mala explained. “When my parents found out about that and my hormone treatments… they kicked me out.” David reached out and touched Malays slit, their cock lifted up in anticipation.

“So are you… intersex?” David tried to make sense of it all.

“No, I wasn’t born this way. Please don’t think about it to hard… I need you inside me.”

David’s cock went rock hard, he took hold of Malays penis and gently stroked it. They lurched back at the sensation and both of their holes began to leak sticky clear fluids. “Please…” They gasped, “fuck me, David.”

His cocked pressed into Mala’s warm pussy as he continued to stroke their cock. They soon motioned the, to slow down with stimulating their over sensitive penis. As he let go they shot a hot load of clear cum across the both of them. David didn’t care, he was taking his time pumping into this strangers tight pussy. Enjoying each thrust. It blew his mind how good it felt. He turned Mala around and fucked them from behind. Now and again turning them around again. Fucking their mouth or pussy as he saw fit. Mala just kept coming. Though their ejaculations were less and less they were well lubricated.

The bed and their bodies were drenched when David felt himself edging. He kept pumping inside the little play thing, pushing as deep as he could. They came again, their pussy flexing and their cock shaking in an attempt to erupt one more time. The friction on David’s cock drove him over the edge, he pushed in one last time before he came. He hot semen filling up his partner. “Yes!” Mala cried out.

He threw them off of him and down on the bed, they lay in that spot, curled up as David’s cum slowly dropped out of their vagina. David looked over what he had just done, turned and sat down on the bed. Mala reached out and touched his back, he flinched.

“It’s okay.” They wrapped their arms around him, press their body to his. “You are an amazing man.” David turned to Look at Mala, reached up to touch their face and pulled them in for a kiss.

“Thank you.” He said.

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/7mhbr2/if_you_like_me_you_arent_straight