[MF] First cream pie while watching another couple

I lived in fraternity in college, and the house a bit of unique architecture. Some of the bedrooms on the top floor have vaulted ceilings, and brothers had built massive lofted platforms 10 feet up for sleeping. These platforms went wall to wall over half the room, like a ghetto balcony.

One alumni weekend, I knew I had to be up early so called it an early night with my girlfriend. We had some sex and fell asleep. Around 2 am I was woken up by the sound of my futon being pulled out. I propped myself up to look over the edge of the loft to see an older alumni and a sophomore girl rolling around and making out.

I was actually behind my girlfriend in the spooning position, and saw that she was awake and mouthed “oh my god” to me. I put a finger to my mouth in the “shhh” motion and we both watched. I was silently cheering on the alumni. We had spoken earlier in the night; he was 31 and had just gotten out of a bad engagement. He and a few guys from his years came up for the weekend to help him blow off steam.

Now he was sliding his hand up the skirt of a 19 year old that. The gasp that escaped her lips was proof he was fingering her.

Watching this all happen started to get me hard, and my girlfriend felt it against her ass, and she started to wiggle her but into me. I reached around her to find her hand in her panties, making slow circles on her clit. My hand went lower to find her dripping, and I pushed the tip of my finger into her. Her other hand covered her mouth to stay quiet.

We continued watching as the alumni slipped off the panties if hero’s conquest, and then she pulled her shirt off. She was flat as a board, but had perfect pink nipples. He sucked on them, the worked his way down between her legs. He undid her skirt, exposing a perfectly shaved pussy, and he dove in. Her moans indicated that this old man had experience.

At this point I was rock hard and I pulled out my cock and started running against my girlfriend’s ass. Using the hand that was now soaked in her juices, I pulled her thong to the side and tested the waters of pushing my cock into her. At this point in our relationship we still wore condoms, so the feel of hot wet pussy was the best thing I ever felt. She didn’t stop me, so I pushed all the way in, and felt her take me all.

At this point, the little coed was now deep throating the guy, and her bare ass was in the air towards us. I was so happy for him, and me.

My girlfriend pushed her ass into me, and we made slow grinding motions. Her hand was working her clit, and I was biting her shoulder.

I was so close, and whispered in her ear hat I was going to cum. She just said “me too”. In the moment, I couldn’t do anything, and her pussy squeezing me was the last bit I need, pumping her with my cum.

My whole body twitched at the glory of this first experience of cumming in a girl. A few seconds later, are show ended as the poor girl was surprised by the dude’s load in her mouth.

They cleaned up and left the room, while my girlfriend and I kissed and cuddled in the post cream pie glow. I slowly pulled out of her, feeling my cum leak out. We fell asleep like that, and that was the start of us not wearing condoms.

I talked to the alumni at the tailgate the next day, telling him I saw the whole thing. He was a new man, and ended up buying me drinks all night as a thanks for the futon.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/7lw84k/mf_first_cream_pie_while_watching_another_couple