Hello all. This happened roughly ten or so years ago. When I was around 19-20 I was dating my wife (30 now). We met in high school and are still together today. Anyways, her wife was in my year, and we always got along well. Flirting here and there, but it was rather innocent. Flash forward to this night.
At this time my wife who was 18 and lived at home. I would usually hang out till she fell asleep then leave. She is not a night person and passed out around nine I believe. Surprisingly I dosed off and awoke around ten. I shut her door and walk downstairs and hear pans being banged together in the kitchen. This is unusual because her family is usually in bed before ten. What I didn’t know was hat her older sister (my age/year) was in there with her two friends. I walk into the kitchen and it’s fairly a mess. I can’t tell her and her friends have been drinking. I say hello and they ask me to stay and talk to them. This wasn’t super unusual, so I oblige.
There was nothing specific in the conversation that I can remember. However, her sister starts flinging chocolate at her friends (she was making brownies). They’re all giggling, and then she flicks some from her spoon and it hits my cheek. We make eye contact I laugh and ask if she would hand me a towel. She says, “I’ll wipe it off for you”, and proceeds to literally lick it from the bottom of my cheek up to right under my eye. She did this rather slow. Her friends were laughing, but I was stunned. She then spread more on the other cheek and did the same thing by cleaning it with her tongue. As you’d imagine, I have a growing erection. I (or so I thought) slyly slip my hands in my pants to make an “adjustment”. She notices, and without a word slides her hand down my pants and without saying a word grips my shaft. Which at that point became extremely erect, and gave me maybe three strokes. Went down to my balls with her fingertips and stroked up from there a couple of times. At this point I’m sort of tripping balls with her sister upstairs (also her bf was an acquaintance of mine), so I panicked and backed up. Laughed it off and said, alright ladies I got get going. The other girls smiled and said goodbye (they may have either been too drunk to notice what happened, or didn’t give a shit). It was all rather quick, but slowed down as fuck in my mind. As I turn my back and walk out of the kitchen, her sister jumps on my back, I turn around to I guess hug her, and she kisses me. Tongue in mouth, a little seven second make out (if you want to call it that). Little me is still fucking stunned and confused lol. She pulls back almost suddenly and says “oh fuck!” I deescalate the situation and say no worries enjoy your night. She sort of smiles and I leave.
She texts me at like five in the morning asking me to keep what happened to us and to never speak of it.
I never pursued anything further. She’s married to the guy that was her bf at the time, and I obviously married her sister. I regret not acting at that time, and have never brought it up to her. I’ve always wanted to but haven’t taken the risk to do it. Should I? Haha. Anyways, I hope you all enjoyed this. Any and all feedback/comments are welcomed.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/7gxc1n/mf_old_encounter_with_wifes_older_sister
Nice teaser, I probably would of taken her in front of her friends, and let them watch, but I’m screwed up in the head.
Now this is believable unlike the other stories where your wife somehow gives you permission to fuck her sister.
You both made your choices in life. Move on.