[MFF] Had another threesome thanks to Fetlife

A lot of backstory to this one, so skip to below for the dirty stuff…

The last one sort of fell into our lap (you can read about in my post history) but that was a few months ago. We finally got off our asses and did some work to make it happen again, and it paid off. That’s despite Rachel saying things like, “I forgot sleeping with ladies is like… hard and requires work. Sleeping with men is literally effortless.” Yes, babe, I know. I’VE HAD TO DO THIS ALL OF MY ADULT LIFE THANK YOU FOR CHECKING YOUR PRIVILEGE.

Anyways.

So we went on Fetlife and reddit, did a couple of local events, and we found a few potential girls we liked. The one on whom we settled, Elle, 25 years old, is about 5’10 and has a dancer’s body with small breasts and a great, spankable ass. Long reddish hair and blue eyes, too. We messaged for a while online until moving over to a group text and flirting some more. She had been a little flaky in returning our texts, so we were unsure if anything would ever materialize, but then on Thursday she sent us a face picture and we finally settled on a date on Sunday night. We talked about the renaissance faire we were going to that weekend and she promised I’d enjoy Shakespearean wrestling (in which WWE-style wrestling is performed to the story lines of Shakespeare) and I told her that I’d hold her personal responsible if I didn’t. She told me that I could spank her if I didn’t, but that she wanted me to spank her either way. She even added a few pictures of her ass to whet our appetite.

More dirty texting happened over the weekend, including a good morning text we sent to her in which I was going down on Rachel, but nothing particular of note. We met up at the bar on Sunday night and I did my best to ignore the football on the tv’s on the wall. I was wearing a white henley with black jeans and Rachel had on a black dress. I’m 5’10, 155 and covered in tattoos and body hair. I do yoga, rock climb, and run a lot, so I have a pretty athletic body, something which Rachel never tires of telling me. Dark brown hair that I keep shaved with one of the shortest settings on my trimmer, and a full beard a tiny bit longer. Rachel is maybe 5’4, and I won’t try to guess weight because I’m bad at it and I’ll probably offend someone, but suffice it to say she’s stacked. Like, bad at Tetris stacked. Like fantastic breasts and a great ass stacked. Dark brown hair that falls past her shoulders, fair skin, a killer smile. Elle came and she was wearing a royal blue dress.

We hugged and said hi and whatnot and had a few beers over conversation. Our last threesome just fell into our laps and happened to be with a friend, so we were super comfortable. This time, though, we were meeting a stranger and were a little nervous. The conversation was a little awkward at first, but we eventually got comfortable and were laughing and having a good time. We talked about what we like in bed, and her kinks/limits– lots of spanking, no choking, and she warned us that she can’t orgasm with people, so to temper our expectations. A little disappointing, but as long as she was still interesting in me still going down on her (she was), it was fine. I put my hand on her leg under the table and that’s when I was sure we were going home together. She let me keep it there as I asked about her living situation. She said she’s in a dorm with no guests allowed, so I talked about Rachel’s house and asked if she’d like to see it. Of course she did. Ten minutes and an uber later (she sat in the middle, obviously) we were back home.

——-

We got some drinks and brought them downstairs to the bedroom, but they remained pretty untouched. I put on some St. Vincent and before the second song on the album was over, we were making out on the bed. Hands wandered, bodies grinded on one another, and Elle’s dress came off pretty quickly. Rachel and I kissed her stomach and her neck and her legs, and I could already smell how wet she was. I fucking love that smell. But I also fucking love a wet gusset, so instead of pulling her panties down, I kept them on as I rolled her onto her stomach. I owed her a spanking.

I started off light, letting her get used to my hands. I stroked her cheeks and her legs and ran my fingers along her fabric-covered mound before bringing my palms down on her, hard, again and again. I listened to her whimpers and did it harder and softer as seemed to be appropriate, kissing the flesh that was now warm to the touch and bright pink. I slipped a finger inside of her and she was soaked, so I helped myself to a taste before offering Rachel one, pulling her away from her makeout and breast play session only for a moment. I noticed that Rachel had taken her dress off– god knows when– and both girls had their bras off as well. I was still fully clothed.

I pulled Elle’s panties down eventually and turned her over so I could go down on her. Rachel and I teamed up on her breasts and I kissed my way down her flat stomach, kissing her inner thighs and nibbling on them before finally kissing the source of her wetness. I made out with her clit like a first kiss– gently and slowly at first, then passionately and with wandering hands. I hooked one arm around her thigh while I teased the other inside of between her thighs and got one, then two fingers inside of her. They continued making out and Elle was fingering Rachel as I focused on her clit and stroked her g spot for a long while, until my beard was soaked with her juices and my jaw was a little tired. I kissed both Rachel and Elle and asked the latter if she wanted me to get a condom or if she wanted to watch me with Rachel first. She chose the latter, so I finally undressed. Rachel got on her back next to her and I slipped a couple of fingers into Elle to use her arousal to get my cock wet.

I pushed inside of Rachel and began fucking her in missionary, trying to go slowly because I knew I was so close to cumming already. I took my cock out and slapped her clit a few times to give me a break, looking at both of them in turn and exchanging lustful glances while they weren’t focused on each other. As I was approaching orgasm, Rachel asked me to cum in her mouth, so I pulled out at the last second and was more than happy to oblige. I was still hard, though, the veins bulging from the side of my shaft, but I was a little tired, so I laid next to Rachel for a little bit while we kissed some more and Elle and I both felt her up.

I went down on Rachel and made her cum pretty easily, the same way I had eaten out Elle. It’s all about the two fingers on the g spot and the mouth trapping the clit so your tongue can attack it relentlessly. In any case, once I finished, I crawled between them and we all kissed some more. At some point, Elle mounted Rachel and got on her hands and knees, so I positioned myself behind her and licked her from behind some more, happily lapping up all of her wetness. She asked me to fuck her, and who was I to say no? I got a condom and rolled it on before getting on my knees for doggy style. I eased into her and she warned me to go slowly at first, so I did. I’m glad I’d already cum once, because seeing how Rachel smoldered at me was just too fucking hot. She was touching herself as Elle had her head down on the bed and was moaning as I thrusted into her. I went for a while, slapping her ass occasionally and trying not to enjoy Rachel’s facial expressions too much. Eventually, though, I came again and buried myself deep inside of her as I shook and emptied into the rubber. I slowly pulled out and took it off, lying down again, this time with Elle in the middle.

Rachel went to the bathroom and we cuddled, debriefing a little. I asked if I could have gone harder (spanking, yes, fucking, no) and what else she liked. Rachel got back and we talked about what Rachel likes, so I decided to show her. I slapped her face and pulled her fair, spanked her clit and her breasts, and eventually had Elle hold her wrists down above her head as I fucked her hard in missionary. I called her a slut and kept hitting her until she came on my cock, and I quickly followed suit.

We cuddled again, even longer this time, and Elle was talking about how she loved hickeys but couldn’t really get them because, well, she’s not in high school anymore. So we made do with her breasts instead. And her thighs. And her ass. She was pretty bruised up by the time we were done. Rachel began slapping her breasts and I teased Elle, telling her, “What do you say? Hm? What do you say when she slaps you like that? You say Thank you.” Which she did, every time, for the rest of the night. I lazily rubbed her clit and eventually went down on her again, this time only using my mouth and tongue to pleasure her.

After another long while, I asked if she wanted to fuck again, but she said she was sore, so I had Rachel mount Elle while I fucked her instead. We both came again and cuddled, stroking each other faces and kissing lightly as the minutes ticked by. It was past midnight at this point, and we had been at it for 5+ St. Vincent albums, or about 3 hours. She really wanted to stay over, and it was hard to disappoint her, but Rachel had work the next morning at 6, so she had to go. Luckily, I have off today or else I would have been miserable. Lol jk no I wouldn’t, I would have been ecstatic because I got super laid.

In any case, I called her an Uber and we made sure to make plans for another play session soon. This time, on a Friday, so we can all fall asleep in each other’s arms.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/75bc9z/mff_had_another_threesome_thanks_to_fetlife