[MFM] Our First Time Marking One of the Fantasies List

Long time lurker, my wife and I finally decided we wanted to share one of our most memorable adventures.

**The Fantasy List**

This started with my wife and I visiting a popular website that allowed you to take a quiz and match what you were into sexually. We did it mostly for a laugh, but what we discovered was that both of us answered almost uniformly ‘I’d be down with that if my partner was’.

After that we’d have discussions/play games where we’d talk about fantasies. We would go through the list of things that we both liked and decide if it fell into the category of ‘Something I actually want to do’ (She loves taking facials for example, I like watching her touch herself), or ‘Something we’re more interested in fantasizing about than actually doing’

The biggest fantasy we both had in the later category was different forms of group sex. After a few of these discussions, we decided that we were both most into having an threesome with another man. The way it kept coming up, we decided that it would be the first thing we’d ever try to move from ‘The Fantasy List’ to ‘Thing we actually try’. We decided to see if we could try it on our next vacation.

**To introduce ourselves:**

I’m a Canadian white guy. I’m about 5’11, 205, 30 years old. Medium muscle build. My wife loves big guys – she tells people she only married me for my broad chest and thick neck (and when she’s been drinking she mentions other areas of girth.)

She is East Asian Canadian. She’s about 5’2″ and 105 pounds, 28 years old. She’s all muscle and tone. She loves to work out, kick box, run marathons. You name it. She has beautiful hazel eyes, long brown hair, washboard abs, tits that cup perfectly in your hands, and an ass that fills out her yoga pants.

We have a home base in Canada, but travel around Asia a lot, so it wasn’t long until our next holiday.

We spent the couple of weeks before that enjoying the anticipation of the act, and also going out people watching and talking about what type of guy we’d like to have join us. (She needs those broad shoulders!)

**The discovery**

Our vacation comes and we’re traveling around Asia. For about the first week not much happens – no opportunities, we tried one time and sorta chickened out a bit (the conversation didn’t go well.)

Then we hit the resort we’re staying at for the last week of our trip. First of all, we were instantly in the mood by the setting. It was a beautiful place right on the ocean, our accommodation was huge and luxurious. Views of the moonlit ocean from bed, sounds of waves, relaxed atmosphere…just everything put us in the mood.

The second day there, we spot a guy that’s seemingly perfect. Big, strong, bulking guy. Baseball cap with sandy blond hair poking out the sides, t-shirt showing the guns, long swim trunks. Not a huge ‘bro look, but built like one. I knew it was my wife’s type. Ruby player sort of look. It was just in passing and we didn’t talk about it, but later we’ve both said that we noticed him and were into it. We’ll call him Rugby

Low and behold, the next night we’re sitting at the bar near the pool and Rugby walks in and sits a few stools away from us.

I look at my wife, she gives me a sly nod, and I strike up a conversation with him. He’s here with his mates from Australia. They’re out on the town one last time before heading back, but he wasn’t feeling an all night bender so he stayed in.

Chat, chat, chat, drink, drink, and my wife’s sitting between he and I now. She asks him if he’d like to come back to our room for some cheaper drinks (It really was expensive and we really did have a ton of liquor in our room!) He looks at me, I give a look of approval, and ‘Sure yeah!’ and we’re headed back.

At this point I gotta give the guy credit, he was pretty smooth in the situation too. Without being blunt about it, once we got back to the room, he brought up something like ‘Wow, this room is really seductive. You guys must have great sex in here.’ (Both comments were true) and that led us to talking a bit more flirtatiously.

Finally my wife mentions that ‘Yeah, to be honest, we’d always wanted to have a threesome’ ‘Yeah…me too’ Rugby said (or something along those lines). My wife gives a ‘Why not?’ nod that meant approval, and we laid out our quick rules – which were no problems.

With that she went to the bathroom to freshen up.

**The Act**

While she was in the bathroom, I noticed Rugby rubbing himself on top of his shorts – he was clearly raring to go. I was feeling pretty hot myself. Impulsively – I wasn’t sure how this was all going to start anyway – I pulled down my shorts and briefs and started playing with myself.

Rugby took my lead and dropped his shorts to his ankles as well. He was built and had a definite inverted T look to his chest which led down to a cock that was thick and straight. My cock is about 7 inches long and 5.5 around. He was probably a bit shorter and a bit thicker. Exactly what my wife likes – she later said it was just right. *(Striking out by finding a ‘pencil cock’ as she puts it was a big worry, luckily avoided)*

So there we were both with our shorts around our ankles when my wife walks out.

She had changed out of her cute little sundress into something much more…adult. Starting at her feet: she wore thigh high black fishnet stockings. Those were strapped to a tiny, black, lace teddy. The teddy started at her waist and ended, slightly cupped, just below her breasts. Her perky, hard, round nipples stuck out from her teddy and were the first things my eyes went to. Her hair was curled and framed her face, laying delicately on her shoulders. She looked seductive and elegant, her attitude and her outfit perfectly fit the mood and the room.

She hadn’t bothered with panties. The open area of porcelain, white skin between the end of her stockings and the starting of her teddy was…hypnotic. She moved coyly into the room.

She told the two of us to take off the rest of our clothes and move over to the sofa. Once we were there, she knelt between the two of us, grabbed both of our cocks, and shook them – as if she were trying them out. I could see her look at his cock intently. It was already firm and bulging, and looked massive in her delicate hands. Then she looked at mine – that same small hand grasping at the base – and devoured it straight into her mouth – never letting go of her grip on his cock all the while.

Once I was at full throb – she knows how to get me going – she moved over to him. She completely let go of my cock and centered herself between his legs. She rested her elbows on his knees, started low on his balls and slowly worked her way up to the tip of his cock, then she started going as deeply as she could; opening her mouth wide to fit his girth into her throat. His eyes rolled back in his head and the way he was enjoying it was…hot for everyone.

After a few minutes of this, she pulled her head up – streams of saliva connecting her mouth back to his cock. She wiped her mouth and walked over to the bed and beckoned us to join. For her, I knew, this was the main event. The hottest part of the fantasy for her was to feel two pairs of hands on her body, two tongues moistening her skin, two stone hard erections brushing up against her, and that’s what we gave her.

We each took a side and rubber her, felt her, tongued her – from head to toe. I could feel her writing underneath our fingertips as we slipped off her stockings and pulled the teddy up over her head.

With her now fully exposed, I moved up to her head and neck, kissing her in the places only I would know were perfect. Rugby, being the perceptive man he was proving to be, took the opportunity to put his head between her legs. This drove her insane. As he licked her between her legs, I slowly rubbed her chest, her neck, her ears. We did this until she had her first orgasm of the night. After which she begged ‘Somebody fuck me’ Rugby was happy to oblige.

He went to slide on a condom and she flipped into a doggy style position and put me in her mouth.As I felt her tongue circling my cock, I watched him climb up onto the bed and line up behind her. Her small muscular outline was enveloped by his mass. I’ll always remember the sound it made when she moaned from his penetration with my dick filling her mouth. Through her lips and tongue, I could feel each time he pumped; how he started gentle and slowly became more intense and rhythmic. As they were both getting into the motion of it, I stepped away to enjoy the view.

By the time I had sat on the couch, he had pinned her to the bed. He was giving it to her hard, and had his face buried in her hair. Her moans were muffled as she gasped into the mattress. When she finally looked up, I saw the look on her face that I see when she’s having a long orgasm: her eyes rolled up, a little sweat coming from her temples, her lips peeled back and her teeth showing. A loss of control of anything but pure enjoyment. ‘Roll over’ she whispered.

He rolled over onto his back and she rode him in reverse cowgirl. She was resting her palms on his tree trunk legs and grinding herself into him as deep as hard as she could. She was facing me, and I could see she was staring at my cock as I lightly stroked it. I could see her smile a little bit as she bounced up and down.

She lifted herself off his cock and sat on his face – one of her favorite moves, and placed his cock in her mouth while stuffing her pussy into his mouth.

She moved back over his cock and turned around, planted her arms into his barrel chest and really went to town.

This was one of my favorite parts of the night. I like to watch my wife’s pussy stretch. She plays with dildos for me all the time. This was that, but better. As she slowly lowered herself onto his chest, and he wrapped his big arms around her tiny frame, I could see his tightly constricted balls – trying hard not to cum yet – and his thick, engorged cock, and above that her tiny, shaved, pussy completely stretched. Riding him down the hilt, then pulling up to the tip. Back down to the hilt, up to the tip. All of this happening in a thick stream of pure white cream that had come from her first orgasm. I watched this, soaking in every detail of the motion, until she gave her next command. ‘Come fuck me too’

Truth be told, this part of the night did not go as perfectly as hoped. We’re not into anal, but in discussing what we’d do, my wife had said she wanted to try two cocks in her pussy. She stopped grinding on him and bent over to expose herself as much as she could.

I tried to find a way to line up behind her, which was a bit awkward. I got myself slipped inside her, and she very much enjoyed the feeling of that (and I did as well), but it was pretty much impossible to get any motion going so we stopped pretty quickly. She might just be too small for any type of DP.

She rolled off him and told him to take off the condom and get on his knees. He did as he was told. She flipped over to her back and put herself underneath his crotch. She tongued his balls and stroked his cock. As she did this she spread her legs and let me enter into her, at this point, red messy pussy. She was so filled with pussy juice and cream that I nearly cummed on penetration and had to pull out to regain myself. I diligently went back to work, but at this point Rugby was about to burst (she is great at licking balls and stroking. I can’t contain myself either)

Seeing this, she told him she wanted him to cum on her (I think that almost made him pop) but I knew how she wanted it. I laid on my back, she climbed on top of me in reverse cowgirl. She laid back on top of me, I curled my legs over hers, slid my cock inside of her, and she put her hands behind my head, I slowly rubbed on her clit and moved myself inside her. ‘Climb on top and jerk off.’ was her last command.

Rugby did just that. He sat just above her waist and leaned over, sandwiching her between our two big bodies. Above the sound of our heaving breath, I could hear the squish as he tugged on his cock.

Finally with the long pause and climactic roar of a man who can’t hold it in any more, he reared up tall over her and let loose. He shot several ropes of cum that splashed everywhere. There was cum on her stomach, cum over her breast, on her neck, on her chin, in her hair, some had landed on my shoulder, and some on the bed. The man was a fountain.

He rolled off, heaving. I slid out from underneath and we all lay on the bed exhausted. After a minute or two, Rugby went off to the bathroom and turned on the shower. I looked at my wife, covered with thick white cum.

I asked her if she had enjoyed herself. She nodded yes, I asked how many times, she said 3. I told her she wasn’t quite done yet. She smiled.

I spread her legs once more, slid my fingers between her lips, and tasted all that sex. Then I moved quickly to penetrate her.

As I fucked her, I watched the beads of cum slowly bounce and move around her body and slide off onto the bed. As we got more and more into it, I leaned in closer and closer. I neared climax. I could feel the sweat and the cum and the sex squished between us. I kissed her deeply, connecting everything. I gave an animalistic growl and she dug her claws deep into my back, as she orgasmed once again, I dropped a heavy, heavy load of cum deep inside her.

Having heard the climax I’m guessing, Rugby waited an appropriate time after to come back out. He was still naked, clean, but you could see the red throbbing that showed the use of his cock. I definitely watched him as he sneaked a few extra peaks at my wife as she laid on the bed, cum dripping off and out of her heaving, glistening body. He had earned his keep of looks.

My wife sat up in bed, gave us both a smile and ran off for a shower. Rugby asked if he’d done well (of course) and said he’d enjoyed it. We were kind of at a ‘what now?’ stage – but I told him we’d probably go to bed and perceptive Rugby took the hint, he got dressed and headed out.

And that’s the story of our first time trying ‘The Fantasy List’

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/74lzxn/mfm_our_first_time_marking_one_of_the_fantasies