To be clear this is a true story happened some years ago the summer after I graduated HS. Names have been changed.
Ok so when we left off I had gotten half of a hand job and given Sarah her first orgasm ever via the sneaky fingers. After the paddle boat session Sarah left pretty fast but told me to expect a text tomorrow then she gave me a long kiss and rubbed my still semi-hard dick through my swim trunks. The party progressed and high schoolers did what all high schoolers do when mixed with copious amounts of alcohol. Shit got real and several inebriated girls got naked and ran around. Several girl guy pairs made it back to the lake house where no doubt hymens were by maimed. I had a chance to get with this sexy hot girl that I had fucked before but I decided not to. Nothing that happened at the lake house stayed at the lake house. I did not want Sarah to know I had fucked some girl right after she told me she wanted me be her first. Nope huh uh no way. I wanted that virgin pussy and I wasn’t gonna fuck this up. Party ended with me getting completely smashed and laughing at some girl in the bathroom that had gotten wasted thrown up all over the bathroom and was laying with her shorts around he ankles. Pretty funny shit then I passed out.
The next day I woke up with a purpose. Got home explained to my parents where I had been and that yes I was safe lol. Then I mowed the lawn and started my work out. In the middle of my run I got a text from Sarah. “Hey Mr Amazing fingers lol how are you today?” I replied, “good, in the middle of running what are you up too?” Then said, “oh ok well I don’t want to mess up your run I’m just here at my dads lake house with Lacey been on the lake all morning.” I thought fuck why is Lacey there.” But then another text came through.” It was a picture of them topless in a jacuzzi with bubbles. And a text that said, “I told her about last night and she is curious about those magical fingers too”. I thought, Omg! Omg! Omg! Then another text came through faster than I could reply and it said, “I don’t want to mess up your wo just thought I’d let you know what you’re missing. Shit shit shit I quickly turned around and ran what had to be close to an Olympic level mile time back to my parents house. I texted her on the way, “heading to my house now stay right there don’t move lol, I gotta shower but I’ll be there soon” She replied, “don’t shower I wanna see you all sweaty and we are in the bath anyways haha dork”.
I threw on a shirt and jumped into my car and sped off to the lake. (Note this is a different lake house than the party the night before) It was only a ten minute drive but the whole time I was thinking how it was gonna go down.
Sarah was this stuck up cheerleader that was a grade below me. She was about 5’3″ maybe 110lbs with size B titties. Her hair was cute in a pixie cut and her ass was small but it would bounce and juggle in a swimsuit. It was oh so smack-able and I had gotten a good feel the night before and was looking forward to getting even better aquatinted with it. From the night before I also knew that her pussy was bare with a small landing strip. I never saw it the night before because it was dark but I fingered the shit out of it.
Lacey was a different story all together. Once again I knew her from way back but I never even payed her a second thought. She had two sisters that were years older than me and comprised a lot of my childhood spank bank memories. Those sisters were fine as hell. She was kinda the odd ball of the fam because she was chubby. Her other sisters were like cocaine thin so I don’t know what her parents were feeding her haha. She was also blond with a big ass and big titties. She wasn’t fat just kinda chubby(not my type). She was about 5’6 maybe 150-160lbs but I’m a bad judge weight when you get past 120lbs. She was also a grade younger and I thought, “well you masturbated to her sisters all growing up might as well try it out”.
About five minutes out I get a text from Lacey who I didn’t even have a number for and it said “Hurry we are bored”. And a picture of them still in the tub making bored faces. I increased speed even more. Omg, I thought I cannot believe this is really gonna happen.
Got to the house and the door was open as Sarah had said. I went through and closed it behind me. The lake house was huge. I knew her dad was loaded but man this was nice. I heard them yell “hey we are in here” so I headed down the hall following their laughing and opened the door and there they were arms resting on the side of the jacuzzi with their chins resting on their arms. They looked really sexy. They had obviously fixed their hair and put makeup on. I pulled off my tank top kicked my flip flops off and made like I was gonna pull my shorts off but stops and looked at them. Sarah looked at me and traced my body with her eyes and nodded mischievously! So I slipped them off and the started getting into the tub while the girls were cat calling me and chanting “take it off, take it off”. I heard the girls giggling and Sarah said to Lacey “I told you he looked fucking good.” I replied, “well you guys look like a playboy shoot messaging me dirty pics while I’m running… you’re lucky I didn’t have an accident running with a boner.” They laughed some more and I could tell they had been drinking all morning. There was an empty wine bottle by on the side of the tub and two wine glasses mostly empty. From the jacuzzi there was an amazing view of the lake through these wrap around windows on 2 sides of the tub.
Once I sat down Sarah glided over to me and gave me a kiss and whispered into my ear “ugh last night you made me fucking lose my mind”. Then she turned to Lacey and said seriously “I couldn’t stop shaking all I wanted to do was leave the party so I could sit and think about how good that felt.” Lacey “laughed and shook her head.” Sarah kissed my neck and her hand wondered down to my abs and playfully starved them moving slowly further down. I turned my face to her and kissed her deeply while holding her by the neck. Then she whispered again “get Lacey to come over”. I turned my head and looked at her sitting in the other corner. Her tits were half submerged in the water and bubbles covering parts of them. While Sarah was kissing my neck and touching lower and lower on my abs I reached out one leg to Lacey ran my toes up her leg as far as I could reach almost to her pussy. My foot met her hand which had been under the water (maybe rubbing herself idk) she pulled on my leg and came over and I said, “oh hey there”. I turned and kissed her. Sarah now holding my extremely hard dick in her hand and kissing me on my neck my chest and my lips. Lacy was in front of me on her knees kissing me too and running her hand up my leg until she had my balls in her hand and sat there smiling. They were both so soft and the water was hot and felt amazing with both of them touching me. I reached out and grabbed Lacey’s tits and said “wow these are really nice they are bigger than I thought they would be.” She gave me a shy smile and said well I don’t think you have ever even looked at me so I don’t know how you would know.” I laughed feigned ignorance and said, “well you have my attention now”. Then grabbed my cock and said “I guess I do.”
Sarah was licking and bitting my ear and she kept whispering to me to do stuff to her and Lacey even though Lacey could hear her “Touch her pussy she really shy” “touch her like you touched me last night” I said “mmm that was fun omg I could not stop thinking about you, you know you caused an extremely painful blueballs situation after that.” Sarah quickened her stroking at this and tightened her grip. Sarah was still sitting to my right and Lacey was on her knees bending down so her boobs were in my face. At the exact same time I reached out with my right hand down to cup Sarah’s pussy with my right and started sliding my middle finger up her slit I also reached out to Lacey and cupped hers. Sarah inhaled deeply and smiled and Lacey was still being kinda quiet and reserved so I left her pussy and grabbed her ass and pushed her closer to me. She was now straddling my left leg and I went back to rubbing her pussy trying to find her clit. Her boobs were right in my face so I started sucking on her nipples and she let her head fall back and bit her lip. Sarah next to said “wow that really fucking hot and continued to stroke me as I slowly entered her pussy. It was warm and wet and the further I went the more audible she was getting. Lacey had one hand on my arm and one hand on my chest and started grinding into my fingers so I slipped my middle finger inside and she gasped “ugh mmm”. Sarah was learning how to rub a dick fast and she was now just rubbing the tip slowly but firmly with her left hand and with her right hand she was forcing my fingers further into her.
This continued all three of us making pleased sounds and rubbing and touching I would kiss one of them for a while then switch to the other. I thought I was doing pretty good I mean I was 18 and had never even dreamed of this situation let alone prepared for it.
Seemed like hours of this(probably 10-15 min). By this time I was rocking Lacey back and forth with my two middle fingers (literally moving her body back and forth on my leg and she was getting close. Sarah had stopped rubbing my dick and was tensing up and had an intense look on her face. Then I stopped abruptly took my fingers out of both and they just looked stunned and Sarah was pissed. “WTF” she said. Lacey had a sad look and said “I was so close.” I said “sorry bad angle my hands cramping” lol really I just wanted to get them into a bed and I thought if I made her go again it might be over and the human dildo might get nothing again. I said let’s get some shots and take this to the bedroom they both looked at me with a mischievous grin and said “oh ok”.
Sarah showed me where the bed was and Lacey and I finished drying off while she left to raid her father’s liquor cabinet. I was starring at Lacey ass as she dried off and she asked, “do you like it? I said she was gorgeous to be nice but really she was fat. When Sarah came back she was holding a bottle whiskey and said, “look what I got” and held up a blunt.” I was thinking fuck this just keeps getting better” we sparked up the blunt and passed it and also started taking shots out of the bottle. All three of us were sitting there on the bed Indian style. I couldnt stop checking them out. Sarah with her quarter sized pink nipples that we hard as rock and her pussy slightly open and her little brown landing strip. Fuck I want to lick her so bad. And Lacey had a pillow on her lap with her large boobs and large nipples (hard also) bouncing when she coughed and laughed.
We talked and joked about how we all had gone to the same church as kids and if they could see us now hahaha. Then the blunt was done and we had each probably taken 3 shots. Everyone was smiling and grinning and waiting for someone to make a move and i broke the silence “well have you too ever hooked up?” They looked at each other and laughed and Sarah said, “no no no we like boys, we have made out before but it was just a party thing for guys cause they think it’s hot.” I said well “that is hot” and then Sarah reached over to Lacey held the back of her head and brought her in for a deep long kiss. I was instantly hard again and when they stopped kissing Sarah look over at me and whispered to Lacey. I could hear here say “well that wasn’t very difficult” while they looked at my dick.
Sarah took charge pushed me on my back, grab my cock and laid between my legs. She started giving me a blow job but I’m not sure she had ever done it before or whatever it wasn’t great but just looking at her going up and down on it was fantastic and I could checkout her ass just laying there perky and small. I waved Lacey over and she bent over and kissed me. I sucked on her large nipples until they were hard and then my hand went to her pussy and she was slippery wet. When I went inside her with my finger and she gasp into my mount and I started rubbing her clit with my thumb and working my fingers. Then Sarah stopped sucking gave me one more lick and straddled me. She looked into my eyes and said “are you ready I’ve been waiting for this dick all day” I said yeah and grabbed a condom that I had laid on the bed. She put it on me with some difficulty and then straddled me again and eased herself onto my dick. She got about halfway done and stopped with a pained look on her face. Then concentrating she rose up and back down three or four times. She was fucking tight but I kept hitting something in her. I stopped fingering Lacey and grabbed both her hip and push her down farther and snap I was in she let out a painful sound and said “ahh ok ok it’s ok your in ok now your in.” And she slowly started riding me. Her hands were on my chest and her eyes were staring down at my cock going in and out of her pussy. God she was tight I was worried the condom wasn’t going to stay on. Apparently she had gotten over the hard part or something and now she seemed to be enjoying herself. She was bouncing up and down then she was grinding on me. Omg it felt so good she started getting a tense look on her face again and bitting her lip. Then after 5 or six min she came, digging her nails into me and her pussy clamping down on my dick so tight. I smacked her ass and as she collapsed on to me then rolled her off and turned her into her stomach. I guided my dick back into her. Not sure if she knew what was gonna happen. She whimpered again and made a painful expression and said “ugh fucking big”. Which I’m not she didn’t have any frame of reference. I was a little drunk and high and i really wanted to cum so I spread her legs and started slow then when it got easier going in and out I started going faster. She started making more and more noise just like at the lake until she was really super loud. At this point I realized I had forgotten about Lacey and I looked to over and she was laying on her back watching us fuck with her hand on her pussy. Our eyes locked and I pounded Sarah’s little virgin pussy really hard and then finally I came all in a rush. As each wave of pulsing orgasm washed over me I pushed deeper and deeper into Sarah and until she abruptly cam again and started shaking. Then she reached back and pushed me off of her. It was slightly gross because there was some blood on the condom but well that’s the game. I got up threw the condom away and washed my dick off in the bathroom.
At this point I was exhausted but Lacey motioned me to come over to her and I made like I was gonna put her in doggy and she just push my head down to her bald pussy. I licked and licked starting slow and all around the lips and then I concentrated a tight pattern on her clit. She kept grabbing my hair and saying slower slower. Fuck did she not realize I just ran a fucking sex marathon on her Bestie. I was trying to finish her up quick Finally I could feel her tense up and she started to squirm then she pressed my head as hard as she could into her and came all over my face.
I got up again and washed my face and thought omg what a fucking day and it’s not even dark yet. I came back and the girls were just laying there breathing and not talking. I came back to Sarah and said “hey girl how was that” she said “ugh I think I’m fine now there for a min I thought you broke my pussy.” I laughed and said “mission accomplished.” All three of us just laid there and got under the covers and cuddled. Then we passed out.
Best Fucking Part!!
We woke up out of a daze and heard another loud noise like a bag being dropped in the living room. I looked at Sarah and she said “dads in NY” then a man and wife came into the room and looked at us three just laying under the sheets naked. There was a half smoked blunt and bottle of whisky by the bed. The man said “uhhhh hey Sarah umm your dad said we could use the lake house this weekend……then he walked out the wife just stared at us then followed him. Fucking Amazing we all got up and left in short order. Sarah said they never said a word to her dad. Success!!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/6u6o46/im_on_a_boat_mf_virgin_part_2