It was the summer between high school and college when I started dating Lydia. I use “dating” in the loosest sense because while we talked quite a bit and actually went out on several dates we were never official by any stretch of the imagination. We made out but that was basically it physically for us.
Lydia had a cousin named Tiffany who was usually at Lydia’s house. She had a crappy home life so I understood why she was there. Tiffany and I were friendly. She was a cute girl with black hair, deep brown eyes, freckles, b-cup and perky breasts, and thick muscular thighs. She had been a cheerleader in high school so she was pretty fit. She wasn’t a knockout but she was attractive.
We were all hanging out at Lydia’s house one night and had watched a movie. After the movie I was heading home. There were no frills when I left, not even a kiss from Lydia or an offer to walk me to my car. I didn’t need her to it just seems like the polite thing to do when you’re “dating” someone. As I’m walking out the door Tiffany comes out behind me. She says she’s going to have a smoke and we walk to my car and start chatting. Nothing extensive just talked about the movie and joked around. I’m leaning with my back against my car when Tiffany asks me how serious I am about Lydia. Knowing it’s her cousin I’m careful with my reply.
” I like her and she’s funny. We’re kind of in that in between stage of learning about each other and being exclusive.”
“I understand that. So are you interested in anybody else?” Tiffany asked next.
I honestly wasn’t and looking back I’d never considered Tiffany in a romantic or sexual way so I just said “not really.”
Tiffany suddenly moves towards me and starts kissing me. I’m rather shocked by her boldness but as the shock wore off I gathered my wits. I kind of laughed and said “what was that about?”
Tiffany met my eyes and said “I want to fuck you.” No easing into it, no hinting or foreplay just put all her cards on the table. I considered the proposition for maybe three seconds before I pulled her to me and started kissing her again. Like I said I wasn’t exclusive with Lydia, I found Tiffany attractive, and I was slightly sexually frustrated at the time.
As our mouth explored each other I pulled my car door open and we got in the back seat. Lydia lived out in the country and I was parked pretty far down her driveway with no real light around. Unless someone walked up to the window they wouldn’t be able to see us.
Tiffany and I promptly started tearing each other’s cloths off. By that time I was pretty skilled at unhooking bras with one hand so I quickly undid hers before she slipped out of it revealing her perky little breasts. They had these tiny little nipples poised atop cream colored areolas. I hungrily sucked one into my mouth while teasing the other with my thumb and forefinger. Tiffany tossed her head back and wrapped her arms around my neck pulling me closer to her chest.
After playing with her nipples she pushed away from me and started undoing her jeans while I undid mine and pulled my jeans and boxers around my ankles. I’m now fully erect and she seems pleasantly surprised at my size. She straddles my lap with her panties still on and pulls them to the side. She takes the tip of my cock and slides it up and down her slit several times to get it wet before she starts sliding down on me. Within a few seconds I’m deep inside her drenched pussy and she starts rocking back and forth. We start making out again as she continues to fuck herself and I start thrusting up to meet her.
While this is going on it starts to click in my head that she’s been gone from inside for quite some time and that Lydia could come out and look for her. The chance of us getting caught kind of excites me so I grab Tiffany’s hips and start really bucking my hips to get deeper into her. She starts moaning loudly and reaches down to rub her clit while I use one of my hands to roughly pull her nipples. Within a few minutes she stops fucking me and gets super still with my cock fully sheathed inside her. She rubs her clit vigorously for about three seconds before her body shudders and she lets out a breathy moan. Knowing she’s cumming I stop and let her finish and I can feel her pussy contracting on me. After about 30 seconds she collapses on top of me and starts breathing hard. We sit there for a few minutes as she calms down before she disentangles herself from me.
“That was amazing.” She says as she starts looking for her cloths.
“Hell yeah it was. Why exactly did you decide you wanted to fuck me though?”
Tiffany stopped looking for her cloths and and with a smirk said, “about a year ago Lydia knew I was interested in a guy but she messed around with him anyway. I decided it was time to pay her back.”
I was obviously not expecting nor prepared for this answer. All I could say was “oh”.
“Regardless of the situation I still wanted to fuck you it was just better knowing I was getting her back.”
I took a moment to ponder over what had just happened and process it.
“Well I’m pretty sure things were going nowhere with Lydia anyway and I’m always up for a good fuck.” I said and we both laughed at that.
Lydia found out somehow and I frankly didn’t care enough to even text or call her the next day. Tiffany and I continued to fuck for several years periodically. It was never meant to be a relationship situation but I’ll never forget the night I was used for revenge.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/68eold/the_night_i_was_used_for_revenge_mf_cheating
So she didn’t let you cum that first time?