College story: The girl my roommate and I turned into our insatiable friend with benefits [MFM]

Some of the stories I posted over the last couple of years are gone forever from reddit, so I figured I would come back and start posting some old ones to make sure they aren’t lost. Honestly, I was hesitant to post this particular story again. I caught some flack the first time around from some people crying that it’s fake, which got old. I’ve always been one of the people pushing for people to only post real stories to this sub, so I guess I was extra sensitive to it. It’s 100% real. It happened. I will leave it at that. I know there were also a lot of fans of this story and many people messaged me asking me to repost it, so here it is. I will post new stories as well when I have a chance. Hope you enjoy:

***Like I’ve said in previous posts. I figured it would be fun to go back to my promiscuous (man-whore) days and recall some of the stories from back then. I’m generally considered a good-looking guy (used to model, 6’3”, dark hair, blue eyes, swimmers build, workout regularly), so that enabled me to have quite a fun sex life. These stories are 100% true and not embellished in any way. I think that a straight honest story even if not as exciting at times is a bigger turn on, so that is what I will continue to try to give.***

My senior year of college I was roommates with a friend of mine, Eric. Eric was a pretty cool guy. I met him our freshman year through some mutual friends. We enjoyed some of the same music and enjoyed chasing girls when we were single. We didn’t live together until our senior year. It was one of those things that just made sense for both of us at the time and worked out. We lived in a pretty average two-bedroom apartment, you know, the kind that just about everyone lives in at some point in college. It wasn’t much, but we made it our own and we both really enjoyed hanging out there. We had parties occasionally, but didn’t like the attention and drama it drew from neighbors and police so we tried to make it a once per semester thing. 

Eric had a girlfriend for most of our sophomore and junior years, but they broke up which is part of the reason we ended up getting a place together. He was a pretty good-looking guy, tall, light brown hair, and athletic. He was funny too, so that didn’t hurt when trying to pick up girls. After being tied down for so long he was excited about living the single life again. In the first month or so we were living there we both had quite a few girls coming and going. 

One night I got home from the gym and there was a girl sitting at the dining table with Eric with schoolwork strewn about. She was cute. She had kind of short blonde hair, was about 5’3”, in decent shape, fairly big ass (not in a bad way), and kind of looked like a more average Michelle Williams in the face. She didn’t wear much makeup and dressed somewhat conservatively. I immediately thought, well obviously Eric isn’t trying to hook up with this girl. It’s not that she was unattractive, she was cute. She seemed quite innocent too. Eric typically went for girls with fake tans and caked on makeup, which is not my type but that usually worked out well, because we didn’t typically go after the same girls. I said hello and headed to my bedroom. She was there for about another hour and after she left I headed out to the living area to talk to Eric. 

I started teasing him a little bit and said, “so, looks like you are going after a different type these days.” He laughed and said, “Shut up dude. She is a girl from my class. We are doing a group project together, so that’s why she was over here. It’s crazy she grew up super conservative and religious. She told me that she started drinking last year at the end of her freshman year though.” She definitely had a conservative uptight vibe about her. Some of this is hindsight, but I still picked up on it even in that first 30 second interaction. Eric joked that she needs to drink more, because she bored him to tears.

A couple of more times over the next couple of weeks I came home and Ashley (the group project girl) was there working on the project with Eric. One of those times I blurted out to her that she should come to the party we were having in a couple of weeks. I did this without running it by Eric first, but I thought it would be funny. He looked at me like “what the fuck” for a split second, but then said, “yeah you should come.” She responded, “oh cool. Yeah, I might be able to make it.” I left it at that and headed to my bedroom. After she left Eric came into my room and started laughing. He said, “Dude what the fuck are you doing inviting that girl?” I laughed and said, “Sorry, I thought it would be funny to put you in an awkward situation.” He just laughed and said, “I really don’t care if she comes. It will be interesting to see what she’s like when she drinks. Who knows if she will actually show up anyways.” 

Fast forward to the night of the party and it’s around 11pm and our apartment is getting pretty packed. Ashley shows up with a girlfriend and Eric greets them and shows them where the drinks are etc. I bump into her here and there throughout the night and she was getting noticeably tipsy. She started seeming a little more outgoing. She would stop me and say, “Hey I know you!” and start a conversation with me for a couple of minutes. At some point, I noticed her friend wasn’t around anymore. I assumed she left. I noticed Ashley start hanging around Eric more after that. The party started winding down around 2am and the last five or six people started funneling out. I hadn’t seen Eric in probably 45 minutes, but I didn’t think much of it. His door was closed, so I assumed he either went in there and passed out or was possibly in there with a girl. 

I woke up pretty late the next day. Eric was already up and watching TV on the couch. I walked into the kitchen and started making some eggs and coffee. I was hungover and wasn’t much in the mood for conversation. Eric walked into the kitchen and had a weird grin on his face. I said, “What is your deal?” He laughed and responded, “I fucked Ashley last night.” I felt like my hangover was instantly gone or at least I didn’t notice it anymore now that I had this shocking news. I said, “Wait…what?” He laughed and said, “Yeah, seriously I did.” I looked puzzled. He went on, “Once she got tipsy and her friend left she started talking to me and it was like the filter was off for her. She started talking about how she had only had sex with one guy. It was this guy she dated all of freshman year and that she really missed it a lot and she always thinks about ‘experimenting.’ After I heard that I got pretty turned on and started flirting with her. The rest is history.” So, the girl that he was fucking behind that closed door was Ashley. I couldn’t believe it. I said, “How was it?” He responded, “It was a little weird, but hot. You could tell she hadn’t had sex much. She kept asking me if certain things felt good and she was just genuinely curious about different things.” I said, “huh, well cool.” 

I was curious to see how this developed over the rest of the semester. Over the next month or so Ashley would come over once a week to work on the group project and afterwards they would go in Eric’s room and have sex. They would really go at it too. I could hear her moaning if I was in the kitchen or living area with the TV off. She would pop up occasionally on weekends also, but they mainly just went back to his bedroom to have sex. I asked him if they were dating or what the situation was. He vehemently denied they were dating. He said she didn’t even seem like she wanted to date at all. He didn’t want to either. He said that he honestly thinks she just wants someone to have sex with and experiment with. He said their sex over that month had gotten progressively wilder and that she was always asking to try new things. He said he fucked her in the ass for the first time, which was her first time, the last time she came over. He said, “It’s like I flipped this switch in her and now she is this wild sex maniac. She mentioned last time that she wants us to watch porn together.” 

I really couldn’t believe that this girl turned out to be THIS girl. It was funny to me, but I had known girls in the past that seemed like they hadn’t ever thought about sex before and turned out to be major freaks. She just really seemed like someone who had been repressed and decided to break loose a little and ended up finding out she was reallllly into sex. 

About another month goes by and her visits to the apartment were fairly frequent, usually a couple to a few times a week. She would typically stay about an hour or two and then leave. He said their sex for the most part got wilder and wilder and they would play a game where they would have to copy what was happening in the porn scene they were watching. One day he said to me, “Okay, I’m going to bring something up and please feel free to shoot it down. She brought up the idea of you watching us have sex. She said she thought it would be really hot and would turn her on. I know it might be weird for you, so definitely no pressure. It isn’t going to do much for me either way.” I didn’t really know what to think. If he had asked me to fuck her with him I would have said yes, no doubt, but just watching wasn’t as exciting. I mean don’t get me wrong watching people have sex is a turn on, but I also thought it might be slightly awkward since he was my friend and I’m sitting there watching not really involved. I was also curious to see this girl naked and watch her have sex, because I never originally envisioned her to be someone that would do something like that. The thought of seeing her in that light was turning me on. I told him, “Yeah I’ll do it.” 

The next time she came over Eric made sure I was there. He told her he had talked about it with me and that I was cool with it. She was acting really shy. I’m sure this was one of those things that sounded easier to do in her head, but now that she was in the situation she was freezing up a little. I sat down on one couch and Eric and Ashley were sitting on the other that met it at a 90 degree angle. We started talking a little, but it was obvious we all knew what was about to happen. I guess he figured he needed to push things along, so he started kissing her and slid her shirt off over her head. She just kind of closed her eyes and went with it. He pretty quickly took her bra off and started playing with her nipples, which instantly got hard. I was getting pretty turned on. I had to adjust myself a little as my cock started to get semi-hard. He was sucking on her nipples when she started unbuttoning her pants and pulled them down and off her legs. He moved his hand down and moved her panties to the side as he slid his finger in her perfectly shaved pussy. I was rock hard at this point. He eventually managed to start fucking her with three fingers and she had her legs spread wide and was moaning loudly. 

He stood up and took his shirt off and dropped his pants and underwear. She sat on the edge of the couch cushion and started sucking his cock. He was pretty big, about the same size as me (8 inches). I was getting really turned on watching this seemingly innocent girl suck dick pretty much completely naked right in front of me. I had kind of removed the fact that Eric was my friend from my mind. It just kind of felt like I was watching a live porn. 

She continued to blow him for another few minutes and then Eric turned her around on the couch cushion and she grabbed the top of the back of the couch as he pulled her panties off. She was bent over waiting for him to enter her. Her ass looked really nice, like way nicer than I imagined it would. It looked nice in clothes, but it jumped up a few notches once I saw her naked. I wasn’t sure what they expected, but that was the point when I decided, fuck it, I’m going to jackoff. He slid his cock inside her pussy from behind and started pounding her. I pulled my pants and underwear down to my thighs, so I could have my cock out. I was rock hard and I started slowly stroking it as I heard her moaning and screaming. They stayed in that position for a few minutes and I think Eric realized she couldn’t really see me, which somewhat defeated the purpose, because she was turned on by someone watching. Therefore, she might want to actually see that person. 

He grabbed a blanket that was on the back of the couch and laid it on the floor in the middle of the living area. He laid her on her back on the floor and he got between her legs as she wrapped them around him. He started slowly sliding his cock in and out of her. She turned her head towards me and watched as I continued to stroke my cock. When she started watching me her moans got louder and louder. She would only take her eyes off me for seconds here and there. His pace picked up and she started screaming and after a few moments shook as she had an orgasm. I kept thinking at some point she might motion for me to get involved, but I didn’t want to overstep any bounds. 

He flipped her over and had her on all fours again. He jumped up and ran to his bedroom. He came back with lube. I guess anal was a regular thing for them now that she was really into. He spread some on his cock and her ass, before very slowly pushing his cock inside her. She let out slight screams of pain. He eventually worked his way in and got to a fairly steady pace of sliding in and out of her ass. Watching this was majorly turning me on. She had a great ass and just watching her being so dirty and wild right in front of me had me extremely hard. I was jealous. I wanted to be inside her ass like that. I picked up the pace as I stroked my cock. She turned her head to the side and continued to look at me as he fucked her ass. His pace picked up and he was going quickly in and out of her. After a few minutes he started moaning and slowing down, so it was pretty obvious he was cumming. He was filling her ass with his cum and slowly pulled out and as he pulled out he gave his cock a stroke and shot one last stream of cum on her ass. 

Once I could tell he was cumming I really picked up the pace, because I didn’t want to be left there without having gotten off. I was getting close as he pulled out of her. Her eyes were focused on me and she crawled over about a foot closer to me and then sat back on her legs. It seemed like she was inviting me to cum on her. About twenty seconds later I felt it coming on, so I stood up and stepped towards her. Then I started shooting my cum all over her face and tits. She started moaning and reached down and was rubbing her pussy as my cum splashed on her skin. She sat there covered in sweat with my cum all over her and his cum likely running out of her ass and I just couldn’t get my head around the fact that this was the girl I met a couple of months back that seemed so reserved. Eric and Ashley headed to his bedroom to wash up and Ashley left not too long after. 

This story is getting long, so I will try to condense some of it. Over the next month or so it turned into her fucking me and Eric. Eric was cool with it and was not emotionally attached to her at all. At that point, we hadn’t really fucked her at the same time though. She came over sometimes when just he was home or when just I was home and then have sex and leave. If both of us were home sometimes she would have sex with one of us and then thirty minutes or so later she would be in the other bedroom having sex with the other one. This girl had gone from being with only one guy ever to being absolutely without sexual bounds with the two of us. It was a major turn on. It wouldn’t have been as much of a turn on if she was just your average promiscuous girl that was hooking up with a ton of guys, but she was our “wild girl” who wasn’t like that before so it was this extra dirty feeling. 

Probably the most memorable time we had with her was the first time we fucked her at the same time. The hooking up with both of us thing had been going on for a couple of months. She came over one Saturday around 2pm. Eric wasn’t home, but I was so we went in my bedroom and had sex. Eric got home from work about an hour after she got there. After we had sex we went and sat on the couch and watched TV for about thirty minutes and then Eric took her in his bedroom and fucked her. 

Normally at this point she would leave, but for whatever reason that day she decided to stick around. We watched the end of a college football game and then started watching a movie. I am sitting on one couch and Ashley is sitting beside me. Eric is sitting on the other. We are about an hour into the movie and Ashley who had her head resting on my lap just pulls my shorts down and starts sucking my cock. Of course, I had no problem with this. I’m just sitting back and she is going at it for probably close to ten minutes slowly and casually when Eric, who had been occasionally glancing over at what was going on, stands up and walks over towards us. She was on her knees on the couch cushion and leaning over into my lap, so her ass was kind of in the air. She had on short athletic shorts. Eric walked over and pulled them down. She started sucking harder when she felt his hands on her. He started fingering her pussy from behind. 

He grabbed her legs and turned her more towards him, but still to where she could continue sucking me. He pulled his pants down and slid his cock in her pussy from behind. This is the first time she had two cocks in her at once. She would take my cock out of her mouth occasionally and scream with pleasure. He was fucking her hard. I could hear his cock slamming in and out of her as her soaking wet pussy made gushing sloppy sounds. 

After a while we laid a blanket down and moved to the floor. She got on all fours on the floor and I positioned myself behind her. I started fucking her pussy from behind as she took Eric’s cock in her mouth. We got into a medium paced rhythm on each end of her. It felt like we had so much power over her and she would pretty much do whatever we wanted. 

We grabbed her and flipped her over onto her back and spun her around. Eric entered her pussy and I positioned my cock against her lips before she opened her mouth and took it deep into her throat. We stayed in this position for about ten minutes before Eric started picking up his pace signaling that he was about to cum. He was thrusting in and out of her furiously and then slowed his pace as he pumped her pussy full of his cum. She didn’t miss a beat and kept sucking intensely on my cock. I really wanted to keep fucking her even though Eric had finished, but didn’t really want to put my cock in his cum. Just one of those things that kind of weirded me out, so I jumped up and grabbed some lube from the other room. 

I turned her back over onto all fours and lubed up her ass and my cock. I slowly worked my cock into her ass. Her ass looked and felt amazing gripped tight around me. Eric was sitting on the floor leaning up against the couch catching his breath and watching as I fucked her. I started picking up the pace and thrust my cock in and out of her ass as my balls began to slap against her cum soaked pussy. Eventually I was slamming hard in and out of her ass. I wasn’t quite fucking her as hard as I could, but I was fucking her about as hard as she could take it in her ass. After a while I began losing control and tensed up as my warm cum began to shoot out in streams into her ass. After my last stream shot out I just sat still with my cock still inside of her for a few moments savoring the feeling. I slowly pulled my cock out of her and squeezed a last few drops of cum out of my cock and onto her ass. 

I sat back and leaned against the couch just like Eric was. Ashley turned over and lay on her back and looked up at the ceiling. It was weird, she still looked so innocent to me. I looked up and the movie credits were beginning to roll. I looked out the window and the sun was beginning to set. After a few minutes, Ashley spoke up and said she needed to go soon, because she had dinner plans with her sister. I thought about how her sister would probably have a heart attack if she knew what she had been doing all day. 

Ashley continued to come over a couple of days a week until Eric and I graduated and moved out of the apartment. While we lived there we kept up the same routine of each fucking her on our own and occasionally we fucked her together. Once we moved out we each continued to hook up with her, but the double-teaming stopped except for a couple of times. I moved away eventually and Ashley ended up getting a boyfriend that I think she is still with (Update since the first time I posted this story. I actually talked to her a few months back. She ended up marrying the guy she started dating right after we all stopped hooking up). She swore up and down that we were the only two guys she was having sex with, so as far as I know we were the only two people to ever really see that side of her. I guess you can chalk it up to someone breaking out of their shell and experimenting in college and taking it a little overboard. 

***Also, if you are a female and live near me you should send me a message. Might be a long shot, but would be cool/interesting to have sex with someone that enjoys my stories and then becomes a story haha***
 

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/641tlv/college_story_the_girl_my_roommate_and_i_turned