College Threesome Pt.2 [MFF]

Pt.1 [HERE](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5l2swd/college_threesome_mff/)

After the first threesome with Cheryl and Jen, we all mutually agreed that this was a fun thing and we would play it out. I’m not going to say we had a three-way relationship or anything because the truth of it is that Jen and I were the couple and Cheryl was simply a sex toy for us. Mind you she was a fun person to spend time with, but as far as the rest goes she was merely a tool we were using. We tried not hide that from her. We didn’t advertise it either…. Maybe we should have… We made a lot of mistakes through all of this, but it all worked out in the end.

Part of this mutual agreement was that both Jen and I could have fun with Cheryl. The rule was that we have to tell the other and stop if one of us wasn’t comfortable. It was a basic “open” relationship where it was only open to Cheryl.

On that note, Cheryl and I had matching schedules due to our program. Jen, on the other hand, worked the typical Monday to Friday 9-5 shift. This meant Cheryl and I had a lot of 1-on-1 time together while Jen was working.

As a result of this extra time together, our relationship grew much faster than Jen’s did with her. Cheryl made a point of flirting with me and being sexual at every opportunity she could.

In class she was always rubbing my legs and would grab a quick squeeze of my cock when no one was looking. On the days she wore skirts, I knew she would wait until the perfect moment to catch me looking so she could show me she wasn’t wearing panties.

On one particular day Cheryl told me to meet her at a study room. Our school had study rooms which were just small meeting rooms. I excused myself from class and went to the study room. I knocked on the locked door and heard Cheryl answer “whose there?”. I said my name and the door opened. Cheryl was standing there totally naked. She wanted a quickie before going back to class. I could tell she was working on herself before I got there, so it didn’t take much to finish her off. It was a true to definition quickie. Back to class within 10 minutes and no one was the wiser.

Cheryl made a habit out of finding excuses to leave the class. According to records, her and I were volunteers for a lot of programs in our school. We didn’t actually volunteer though.

One Saturday night Jen and I were staying in. We had a busy week and just wanted to chill. As per our agreement I was telling Jen about what happened between Cheryl and I that week. In this case it wasn’t too much. Cheryl gave me a blow job in the students lounge. We were the only people in there so we cuddled up on the couch and put on a movie. Cheryl snuck underneath the blanket and went to town.

I think Jen was getting horny just thinking about it, so she asked me if Cheryl was still in town. I knew where she was going with this, so I wrote an ICQ message to Cheryl who answered immediately. This was the conversation:

Me: Hey, are you around?

Cheryl: Yup, what’s up?

Me: Movies and pillow fort, you interested?

Cheryl: See you in 30.

Like clockwork, Cheryl arrived in 30 minutes. Our local pizza shop is in my building and they take longer than that. She was in a rush.

As soon as she arrived, we went to the local blockbuster and got a couple of movies. Once back to the apartment, Cheryl and Jen began planning for our pillow fort. We had arranged the couch cushions as a massive mattress on the floor and then they hung blankets all around to give it the feeling of a tent.

I cracked some beers for us, then we laid back in our fort and began the movie. Somehow, and I can’t imagine how, we got distracted. We got onto the topic of massages and how we were overdue for one.

Jen and Cheryl said they would give me one. So I laid face down and they rubbed my back for several minutes. It felt great. Then we decided to switch to Jen. Same thing, we rubbed her for a few minutes. Everything was G rated at this point.

Then it was Cheryl’s turn. Jen and I had been wearing shorts and tank tops, so it was easy for us. Cheryl on the other hand was wearing jeans and a sweater. I offered her another pair of shorts and a t-shirt, but she said that she didn’t need it. She said as long as we were okay with nudity she would just get naked.

I think she was comfortable being nude in front of me, but her and Jen hadn’t become that comfortable yet so they were still in the asking phase of that.

Of course Jen and I had no objection to her getting nude. Cheryl stripped away her clothes then planted herself face down. Like the previous massages, one person worked the back while the other worked the legs. I took Cheryl’s legs.

At first I sat to the side of her legs, but this was a little awkward on my back, so I moved between her legs. She had to open the slightly for me to sit down. I could see her freshly shaven pussy from where I was. She kept pushing her hips up in what I can only describe as her way of giving me a better show.

I worked my way from her feet up to her firm little tanned ass. I rubbed every square inch of her before finally rubbing the inside of her thighs. I was as close to her hot mound as I could get without touching it. I could see her pussy glistening as she was getting wet, but I didn’t want to touch too early. Teasing is always fun.

Before I could get too carried away, Jen asks to switch and for Cheryl to roll onto her back. I now get to rub her tits. Her tan was so dark that her nipples seemed almost white. Cheryl was a fitness model so this dark tan was part of her look. It was exceptionally noticeable next to the pale white of both Jen and I.

Cheryl laid on her back. I laid to her side and began softly rubbing my hands over her breasts, stopping just long enough to give each nipple a roll between my thumb and index finger. Jen was kneeling between Cheryl’s legs and rubbing her upper thighs.

Cheryl pulled me in and began aggressively kissing me. I forgot how rough she was while kissing. I normally didn’t kiss her when we were fooling around. She jammed her mouth into mine. Her tongue was as far in my mouth as a tongue ever has been. Then she started to moan slightly. Our lips were touching, but just enough that I could feel her hot breath on my face. I looked down and Jen was putting her tongue inside of Cheryl’s pussy the same way Cheryl was just putting her tongue in my mouth.

I pulled off Jen’s clothes and then took my own off. I laid back down beside Cheryl and watched Jen work. Cheryl reached down and grabbed my cock firmly with her hand. She whispered “bring it here” and vaguely pointing to her mouth. I moved my body up until my cock was at her mouth level. She began ramming my cock down her throat again. In our little daily meet-ups she was practicing deep throat, but wasn’t anywhere near capable. Instead she went as deep as she could. I could feel my cock hitting off the back of her throat. She didn’t need to be that aggressive, but I wasn’t complaining.

I could see that Jen was having a great time licking Cheryl’s pussy. I got up to switch with her and she was still going strong. She had three fingers inside of Cheryl at this time. Cheryl seemed to really be enjoying it.

I decided to lick Jen’s pussy from behind while she was on all fours licking Cheryl. I crawled behind Jen and noticed a long string of grool dripping from her pussy. I changed my plan and immediately went inside of her. Jen wasn’t expecting it, and I think the shock got her extra worked up. She let out a moan and briefly stopped eating out Cheryl to tell me to go hard. I pounded her pussy from behind. I could see her pussy lips gripping my cock as I pulled out. I put a finger in her ass and before I got to the second knuckle she was tensing up. I knew she was in the process of finishing, and like always after the first initial tensing up she began quickly and violently contracting.

She went back to eating out Cheryl. I went back to getting my dick sucked by Cheryl. Cheryl seemed to really like the taste of Jen. She didn’t take long before she switched places with Jen, taking on the giver role.

I couldn’t resist, so like I did with Jen, I went behind Cheryl and went straight in. I felt her tighten up at first, but she eventually loosened as I continued to fuck her tight pussy from behind. I knew I had to try a finger in her ass as well. I was surprised when I was able to get it in so quickly. I guess Jen being a sloppy eater got it lubed up nicely for me.

I continued fucking her while fingering her tight little ass. I could feel my cock through a thin piece of skin that separated her anal and vaginal openings. I reached in with a second finger and basically grabbed my cock through the skin. It didn’t take long before she got close. Like Jen, I could tell by the way her pussy was flexing. Unlike Jen, Cheryl is a squirter. She didn’t do this regularly, but she did in every threesome. In this case she squirted every time I pushed into her. Our pillow mattress was soaked.

Once Cheryl was done, but girls laid side-by-side. They looked at me and told me to do whatever I wanted. This time I decided to go with the two on top of each other. Jen was on the bottom laying on her back. Cheryl was laying on top of her with her back on Jen’s stomach. I took my time slowly fucking Cheryl before moving to Jen. I switched a few times before I couldn’t hold it any longer. I came hard, collapsing under my own weight. My arms turned to Jello and I nearly missed headbutting Cheryl as I fell.

Once again Cheryl spent the night. The next morning I woke up first and was in the shower. I left the door open and was joined by Cheryl. Jen came in quickly after her which ultimately made the tiny shower too crowded. No big deal, I knew I wasn’t going to be left out so I gave them some space and got out. I dried off while they continued to shower. I peeked in every chance I had and could see them attempting to contort themselves in multiple ways to lick and finger each other.

Jokingly I stuck my cock around the side of the shower curtain. Fortunately I was immediately met with a tongue. I didn’t know whose it was, but it began licking my shaft from the balls to the tip. Then I felt a second mouth. This one began sucking. It was gentler than Cheryl so I knew it was Jen. I pulled the shower curtain open and watched them both taking turns sucking my cock. I honestly didn’t take long at all too finish. Cheryl was the lucky one whose mouth I finished in. Within seconds of finishing, the girls went back to each other. They got out of the tub and went into the bedroom.

They got into the “69” position and it was like I wasn’t even there. Except for the fact that I was taking turns fingering their pussies. Jen said she was close so Cheryl kept licking. Jen was on top so she asked me to fuck her. I pushed in and like before it wasn’t more than a few thrusts before I could feel Jen’s pussy tightening the way it does when she finished. As soon as she finished I pulled out and as my dick fell out of Jen, it landed right on Cheryl’s face. She made use of it and began sucking.

The girls switched places so Cheryl was now on top. Same as before I began fucking her from behind while Jen licked her pussy from the bottom. Once again, it didn’t take long before Cheryl unloaded another creamy orgasm all over my legs. Jen was the willing participant who got it on her face. Once Cheryl finished, she began kissing Jen’s face which basically meant she was tasting herself.

Jen got up to go clean off and I kept fucking Cheryl. Jen returned just in time for me to finish. She knelt beside Cheryl and I pulled out just in time to aim it at Jen’s face. She tried to contain it with her mouth, but I was too quick. She got a decent amount on her forehead and eyebrow.

That was a great evening and next morning, but in the words of the late Billy May’s, “but wait, there’s more”.

Our threesomes went on for the rest of the semester. Each time uniquely hot. However, I am going to skip ahead to when it all ended.

There were several factors. In hindsight bad decisions were made and misinterpretations happened. As I explained, Jen and I had a bit of an agreement when it came to Cheryl. The three of us were acting like a happy little throuple. We even began going on dates together and even going out with friends as a group. While Cheryl was technically single, everyone knew that she was with us. That was her call so that there were no hard feelings from her having to reject people who would undoubtedly hit on her. She was a gorgeous blonde fitness model after all. She got a lot of attention and I was the lucky guy she gave her attention to.

As I mentioned, Cheryl and I would always find excuses to get out of class and get sexual. On this one day she invited me to meet her at the park so we could suntan. I’m a burner so I went to the park just to hang with her.

When I got there it didn’t take me long to pick her out. The hot blonde in a skimpy pink bikini. I made my way over and Cheryl had a nice romantic lunch packed. Bottle of wine, some cheeses, and fresh fruit.

We had a snack, then laid on the towel. I was facing her and she regularly adjusted her bikini bottom. Her adjustment was just to lift it from her skin and then put it back down. Each time she did that I could see her beautiful mound. I think she was doing that on purpose.

After some more “tanning” and talking, she tells me she just got a brazilian wax and asked me to touch it. I began running my finger on her skin along the edge of her bikini. It was perfectly smooth. I kept rubbing until I finally slipped a finger underneath her bikini bottom. I quickly rubbed her clit before stopping in case anybody was watching.

We both got a little excited with that and had to get out of there. We rushed back to my apartment. Jen was at work. Cheryl and I didn’t waste any time, we got naked and began fucking. No foreplay, just hard and sweaty sex. I could taste the salt off of her lips from sweating in the sun.

We switched to doggystyle. Cheryl reminded me of when I fingered her ass and rubbed my own cock at the same time. She wanted me to do that again. This time she wasn’t as lubed up as before, so I got a bottle of the silicone lube from my drawer and lubed up my fingers and her ass. I pushed one finger in first. It felt tighter than before. Still, I went in deep and could once again feel my cock through the skin separating her pussy and ass. After a few minutes I added a second finger and began trying to grip my cock like I did before. Cheryl was going nuts. I had never heard her moan like that before.

Cheryl asked if I wanted to fuck her ass. Hell yeah I did. Jen and I had tried it a couple of times, but none were really successful. I had done it with previous girlfriends, but none in a long time. None with someone as hot as Cheryl.

I put more lube on my cock then slowly slid it inside of Cheryl’s ass. At first she couldn’t take more than the head. I figured this would be another fail. Unlike other failed attempts, Cheryl pushed back onto it. Her thought was that the further it goes in, the easier it will become. Not sure if she was right because she definitely made sure to tell me that it hurt her. I offered to stop, but she really wanted me to fuck her ass.

Her ass was so tight that I had to fight finishing. We rolled over and I was on the bottom, Cheryl straddled over me and placed my cock in her ass. She rode up and down slowly. I was in the perfect position to finger her pussy now. Like fingering her ass, I felt my cock through the skin. I thought that was fucking hot so I grabbed one of Jen’s dildos and put that into Cheryl’s pussy.

The back end of the dildo was against my stomach. My cock was in her ass. As she rode up and down on my cock, the dildo went in and out of her pussy.

Cheryl finished in seconds and the moment I knew she was finishing I couldn’t hold it any longer. We came at the same time. She came all over my chest and stomach while I came inside of her tight little ass.

Once Cheryl left I thought about that whole situation. It seemed like Cheryl was stepping up the emotions. Everything about it seemed far more emotional than our usual hookups. I figured I was reading into it too far, so I let it go.

The next day we repeated our adventure, anal and all. It went like this for the better part of that week. Then on that weekend Jen and Cheryl had plans to hang out. Cheryl cancelled and then called me up asking to do something. She asked me very specifically to not tell Jen. I thought that was weird but wanted to see what this was all about. Cheryl hasn’t disappointed in the past. I knew I would eventually tell Jen anyway.

Well, I met Cheryl at a pub near my place. She was dressed up more classy than her usual self. A little too over dressed considering we were at a little dive pub that we loved. I sat down a little confused, and that’s when Cheryl began opening up.

She told me that she developed feelings for me. She explained how much she cared for both Jen and I, but her feelings for me had grown too strong. She basically wanted to know if there was a chance I would leave Jen and be with her.

In my expected response, I asked what was wrong with the current situation. I was hoping to keep things going for as long as possible. I was determined to in fact.

Cheryl tells me that she wants to spend time with me and that Jen is just second to that. She explains her clear difference in feelings. At this point I was wrongfully humoring her instead of just putting an end to it. Again, this is one of those bad decisions I mentioned previously.

Cheryl tells me that if it were up to her, Jen would be out of the picture and it would be just as two. She said because of that she has become almost resentful or envious of Jen.

I have to say that up until this point I think I had developed feelings as well but just never realized it. I knew this was the inevitable end because I loved Jen and didn’t want to be with anyone else more than her. Still, knowing that I did find it hard to say that to Cheryl. Instead I stumbled around with my words until I eventually gave her a vague answer that definitely gave her more hope than I should have. I think Cheryl left that night thinking I was going to break up with Jen.

The next day Cheryl calls me again. This time she was remorseful for putting me on the spot like that. I was kind of relieved because I didn’t need to let her down and the threesomes would continue.

She asked me to meet her at the park. This time she was waiting for me in her car. I got into her car and we had more incredible sex. Once we were done, she asks if I made my decision yet. Knowing I lead her on the first time, I tell her that I like the way things are now and that I love Jen.

Cheryl continued inviting me out for another couple of weeks. Each time having mind blowing sex before checking if I changed my mind. Cheryl had basically written Jen off at this point, so I knew I couldn’t keep it up much longer myself.

Each day I explained to Cheryl that I love Jen. Then on the final day I was balls deep in Cheryl when my cellphone rang. It was Jen, and Cheryl answered it. She was not making her noises secret, and I could tell she was attempting to make Jen jealous. I knew Jen wouldn’t be jealous, but that still wasn’t cool. Being the guy that I was, I grabbed the phone and told Jen I would call her back. I angry fucked Cheryl until I finished, then left.

I told Jen that night that I think Cheryl is jealous of her and it is getting weird. We agreed to stop having sex with Cheryl. The next day Cheryl called and invited me out, and I had to tell her straight up that it was over. I couldn’t say just enough to keep fucking her any longer.

Cheryl was upset and hung up on me. She called me back and apologized and begged me to give her another chance. She even said she would do whatever it takes to get over her feelings and go back to the way it was. The worst part of all of this is that she left it on the voicemail that Jen and I shared. Jen was the first to hear it.

Once Jen listened, she replayed them all for me. I figured Jen would be pissed. I was vague with her about the details of why I think feelings were in the way, so I thought this would come off like I was lying.

Instead Jen tells me that she feels terrible. She felt terrible that we used Cheryl as a sex toy without any concern for her feelings. She felt sad for the state Cheryl was in. Together we decided that we needed to give Cheryl time to get over this. We cut contact at that point.

I have spoken to her a few times over the years that have passed. We are in the same field, albeit a different one from the program we took in college, so we were bound to cross paths. Jen and Cheryl have not crossed paths from what I know.

Our meetups since then involved an awkward hug and ending with Cheryl being a little too flirty. It made me feel like she never moved on, but I think the reality is that she is just a flirty person. Maybe one day it will happen again. Until then I just have my memories, and great ones they were.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5m1rps/college_threesome_pt2_mff