Obviously, I kept dating Sarah and there was playful banter with Beth but we kept it from crossing the line for obvious reasons. Sarah and I stayed in one night while Beth went out with a new guy. I was making margaritas and they were going down fast while we watched a Cubs game. Around 11, Beth makes it back to the house with her date. He was a goofball that Beth’s sister had brought over to the house that she knew from the dorm. He had no ability to play it cool that he was heading back to the bedroom with Beth to fuck. He was like a goofy kid at Christmas. We hear a little noise but nothing big and they come back out about 30 minutes later. Beth came out in just tshirt and shorts and they acted awkward as hell. Sarah and I asked random questions until he finally left. Beth didn’t say much at first but we could tell that the date was terrible. After a few margaritas, Beth started ripping on the guy pretty bad. From his dick size to how fast he popped to everything. I almost felt sorry for the guy, but he was a goofball. As usual, Beth started crying when she got drunk about how she can’t find a guy and the guys that she can find aren’t able to get her off. Sarah told her that it sounded like time to get her toy, head to bed and sleep off the whole night. Beth starts yelling about how embarrassing it is having to get off with vibrators. Sarah cuts to the chase and just tells her that she can’t fuck me that night if that’s her game. Beth got quiet so I think she hit a nerve.
Beth gets quiet and just sits on the couch with her 4th or 5th margarita. Sarah and I are cleaning up but there’s a lot of groping as we’ve sorta forgotten about Beth. I sit her up on the kitchen counter and we are making out pretty good until I notice that Sarah is distracted. I look over and Beth is turned around on the sofa watching us and pulling on her nipples under her shirt. Sarah starts grinning and tells me to take off her bra and play with her tits. No sooner than her bra hits the floor and Sarah starts laughing a little but hiding her face. I look over my shoulder and Beth is laid back a little where she can still see us but she has her whole palm rubbing her pussy on the outside of her panties. Eyes closed, just like you would imagine. Sarah and I are making out a little but mostly putting on a show and laughing. Sarah pokes me in the ribs and I look over to see Beth with her hips up off the couch, cumming and trying to not make too much noise. We laugh and she comes down from her high so we pull apart I start heading to the bedroom but Sarah tells Beth that she hopes she feels better now. Beth knew that she’d been caught but seemed only slightly embarrassed.
Sarah came in the bedroom and started pulling off her shorts, but seemed to have a devilish grin on her face. She bends over the bed and I know what her look means. She tells me to fuck her as hard as I can so she can put on a show. Having watched Beth, been drinking all night and now looking at Sarah’s ass bent over, I was definitely ready to fuck. I went straight to long stroking her and she seemed to be running away a little but mostly enjoying herself. We go at it a few minutes before she starts screaming out how hard and deep that I’m fucking her. Begging me to spank her big ass. You name it, she was saying it. Definitely a show. She’s done this with me when she’s horny drunk but this was mostly a show. I love dirty talk so I was as hard as ever. We keep going at it and the more she talks, the rougher I get. Sarah yells at me to fuck my whore and we hear Beth’s vibe in the next room. It sounded like an airplane so I guess it was on high. It wasn’t 30 seconds before we heard her grunting. She kept getting louder until it seemed she was overtaken by her orgasm and then we just heard her breathing really heavy. Sarah must have been turned on by our show and she came with Beth. Her pussy was a sloshing mess by this point. It was pretty obvious that Sarah’s goal had been to put on a show as she was exhausted as soon as she came. She was definitely turned on by the show as she was biting all over me and jerking my cock while she was catching her breath. Sarah finished me with her hand and then we both went to sleep laughing about Beth.
We woke up the next morning realizing that Beth needed to get laid and felt bad for making fun of her the night before. Beth was a cute girl but just lacked confidence and was pretty small with a mostly flat body. I have a story about how I hooked up Beth with a friend of mine, I may post it later if there is interest.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5enjzh/my_favorite_females_part_3
That was cruel.