How some complete strangers convinced me to fuck two of my best friends in front of them [MFF]

This is my first attempt at writing a story so hopefully I’m as literate as some of you talented people here. I’m a little scared this is going to be way long but I love tension and buildup when I read erotic stuff so I’m just trying to write how I think I’d enjoy a story.

This takes place back in freshman year of college. I’m 5”7’ and, at the time, was in extremely good shape because I was on a full ride wrestling scholarship. Winter break just started so I went back home to be with my family for the holidays. When I was in high school there was one friend group of five girls that I loved because not only where they model status good looking they were down to earth and genuinely fun to be around. They were all on the gymnastics team. I would have cut my arm off to be with any of these girls but there was one girl in particular named Peyton, that I had on a pedestal. She was five foot one, has brown hair, and current day she is an underwear model with a very large Instagram following. No I won’t link for privacy reasons sorry. Just trust me guys this girl is a 10 with no makeup on.

I talked with Peyton a bit and made sure I sat next to her in one of my high school classes. Then Sophomore year after we were very friendly I mustered every ounce of my courage and asked her to home coming. She said No. I was devastated but in true nice guy fashion I was still super accommodating and fawned over her still. She made it clear we were just friends so I licked her boots for the rest of high school thinking at some point id get a shot.

Well many moons and boyfriends later we graduated and I never got a shot; but at this point I had accepted my fate and we were best friends. To this day we are still best friends. So I’m back home for the holidays and I spend all my time at her house. My parents got divorced and hers had as well. Her mom loves me to death and treats me like the son she never had so their home was my sanctuary from my crazy house. I guess at this point I thought of her as more of a sister then a friend. One night we decide to have a little party in the basement and get the old gang together.

I invited my best guy friend and the five gymnast girls are all there. We party hard and the booze is flowing. Eventually everyone was passed out on the couch like a pile of puppies because they were so drunk. Only Me, Peyton, and her best friend Maggie were still awake. Now Maggie is an insanely beautiful blond girl that can get a little crazy sometimes. She’s one of the most open girls I’ve ever met. Peyton and Maggie were such good friends because they were on the same level in the looks department and got the same amount of attention from guys. They would walk into a bar together and suck all the oxygen out of the room. Maggie has absolutely no filter and a trucker mouth to boot.

Because I was basically treated like a gay friend in this group of girls I’ve heard it all. I know all of their sexual histories, the fucked-up things they have done or want to do. They talk about periods, dicks, taking shits, you name it. So they are talking about the guys they have been hooking up with and the conversation is turning dirty. Then they ask me if I have hooked up with any girls yet. Well in college I really broke out of my shell and found myself. I hooked up with my fair share of girls in those wonderful years but I never brought it up or talk about it with people. When I told them I was killing it at college they were shocked.

Immediately they wanted to know everything and you know girls, they always want the details. I tell them my tales and suffice to say they are seeing me in a new light. When I look back I think this is where the switch flipped. I went from being this meek A-sexual friend to suddenly becoming a viable sexual being. They all knew I wasn’t gay but thought I might be a virgin. After blowing their minds with my sex stories Maggie gets bored and grabs Peyton’s computer. She pulls up Omegle and we start talking with random people online. The girls are enjoying the entertainment of seeing all these crazy looking dicks. We are all very close so we can fit on camera and obviously, I place myself in the middle.
Suddenly Maggie turns to Peyton and out of the blue says

“is Bacon as hung as I think he is?”

“How the heck should I know?”

I have seen all these girls naked. Years up walking in on them changing by accident or going skinny dipping, nip slips, the whole nine yards. They had no problem changing in front of me. None of us are shy so at one point or another I’ve seen them all naked.

“Well how is that fair! Cause I know for a fact you have seen us butt ass naked, how the heck has he managed to sneak by all these years without any of us getting a good look at him.”

“Honestly I have no idea; you guys obviously weren’t putting in the same effort into seeing hot members of the opposite sex naked as I was.”

“No, its probably because you have a micro dick and made sure none of us saw it because you were too embarrassed.”

“Maggie, you can’t say that! I’m pretty positive Bacon doesn’t have a small dick cause I’ve seen him in a wrestling singlet, but what if he did!”

“Then you rock that shit man. Motion of the ocean!”

“Guys… I’m still here ya know. I don’t have a micro dick. You literally just said you thought I might be hung”

“Ok then how big?”

“What…?”

“How big are you?”

Meanwhile there is some twelve-year-old kid in a batman mask on Omegle watching this all happen wondering what the hell is going on so we exit out for a second. I’m drunk and not thinking strait but I’m still not sure how the words “you want to see?” managed to slip out of my mouth

“Yep it’s only fair, drop your pants.”

“What?! Ummmmm… Only if Payton says she wants to see. I’m not flashing her against her will to indulge you ya pervert.”

“dude I don’t give a shit, seen one dick you have seen them all right. Go for it”

I couldn’t do it. I chickened out and they knew that they had called my bluff. We returned to talking to people on Omegle and some guy came up who was in good shape and had a dick that must have been like ten inches long. He asked them to show their boobs so he could cum because he was close. I laughed and was about to skip but then Maggie was like wait! I looked over and she was biting her lip. All the sex talk had finally got to her and she was horny. I swear the girls took one look at each other, shrugged, and before I could blink they were completely topless. This dude basically hit the jackpot and he came in a matter of seconds. We were in hysterics and I told them that they probably gave that guy one of the sexiest memories he will ever have.

“Hell ya, we are doing the men of the world a valuable service”

“Guys… I have no problem being next to cute naked girls but if I end up on a porno somewhere on the internet I’m gonna kill you”

“Relax, stop being such a Debbie downer. These are probably the best tits you have ever seen in your life”

Neither of these girls had massive boobs. C’s at best but very cute. Maggie has very small pink nipples and Peyton is Italian so her nipples are a little more tan and brown sugar beautiful. To be fair they are both beyond perky. At this point I still wasn’t even thinking anything sexual because it’s just seared into my brain that these girls are just friends and they are off limits. That doesn’t stop me from looking and admiring though. I decided to poke fun at them because they were saying I had a micro dick earlier.

“Girl please, I’m an ass man so your little boobies don’t do shit for me”

Maggie punched me in the arm and Peyton covered her boobs with her hands then pretended to whisper to them and told them not to listen to the mean man and they were just perfect.

Back to Omegle and the girls positioned the camera so you couldn’t see they were topless anymore. Now you would think the sexual tension was high but this still wasn’t an unfathomable situation so at no point did I think anything was going to happen. I had already tried my luck with these girls for years and never made any headway. I literally didn’t think it was even possible.

Now here is where things take a big turn. Apparently, we all wanted alcohol poisoning that night so we decided to play an Omegle drinking game. Take a shot every time you saw a dick. Well we quickly realized that we wouldn’t last three minutes doing that so the whiskey was quickly replaced with shots of beer. They ended up flashing four or five more guys and even teasingly tried pulling off my pants to join them in the flashing fun at one point. I still had this huge mental block and didn’t let them do it but they did manage to get my shirt off. I’m really proud of my body because of the insane number of hours a week I spend training. I cut a lot of weight to wrestle so my body fat was under 7% and I had the abs to show for it. Felt nice to show off a little bit and hear my friends tell me how good I was looking.

Eventually we matched with a couple who looked to be in their late twenties and immediately we could tell that these people probably had money. They were sitting on their bed so we could see the rest of the bedroom and it was massive. Very modern contemporary and well put together. The room may have looked good but this couple was gorgeous. They looked like they were straight out of GQ magazine. They were both wearing nice clothes and it was light outside their windows so they were obviously in another country. We literally thought they couldn’t be real so we asked them to wave and give each other a high five to make sure they were real and this wasn’t a recording or something. They obliged and immediately Maggie unloaded a barrage of questions. Where are you? How old are you? What are you doing here? Are you guys dating?

They ended up telling us they were a couple from Australia but didn’t want to give to many details away over the internet. They complimented us and said that we were all very beautiful and asked if I was dating one of the girls. In addition, they tell us that they have been having a boring period in the bedroom and were online looking for other couples to have cyber-sex with. At this point Peyton asks them to turn on their mic because she wants to hear their accents and as soon as the girls hear this guy talk they are drooling over him. We deliver the bad news that we aren’t dating but they are confused and ask why because it looks like we are all naked then.

We had no idea how to explain our weird relationship to them so we just told them that we were very open friends.

“You girls are so beautiful. If you lower the camera a bit so I can see more of you then my wife will join you and take her shirt off as well.”

I immediately volunteered them and moved the camera down without even asking. I’ve seen nothing but dicks and off limits boobs all night. This woman is gorgeous and has some amazing looking DD boobs that I would kill someone to see. Not only that but she has emerald green eyes, brown hair, and freckles. I was enamored. Luckily the girls didn’t mind and seemed to enjoy the attractive foreign man ogling their young peppy bodies. He went behind his wife and slowly started to take off her shirt then bra. Everything that I was hoping for and more. At this point I’m starting to get hard watching this guy fondle his wife’s tight body. Shortly after that the girls go in for the kill.

“Ok now you have seen us so we want to see what you’re working with. Take your clothes off”

Jesus, I might be gay cause even I want to see what this guy’s dick looks like. He slowly takes off his pants and its super apparent he is hard as a rock. They switch roles and this time his wife slowly puts her hand into his boxers and strokes him a few times then slides them off to reveal an average size uncut dick. I can see it in the girls faces now. They are flushed and breathing heavier than a pair of panting dogs. Our webcam friends start really getting into it and passionately kiss while pulling the rest of their clothes off. They are both shaved clean and start to masturbate each other while watching us. Peyton is starting to squeeze her legs together and Maggie isn’t even trying to hide it anymore and is touching herself through her shorts.

I’ve got like a half ass fear boner now. What the hell is going on? Is this actually happening right now? Should I leave?

“Alright girls we are completely naked now, I want you both to turn around so I can see your asses and then very slowly pull your pants off and peel your underwear down”

They both immediately turn and give me a funny look

“What the heck are you looking at me for! You don’t need my permission. Do you want me to leave?”

“No! I don’t want you to miss out on this, that girl is so hot…. Ok this is a one-time thing and we are never speaking a word about this ever ok? I swear to god if you tell anyone about this I’ll kill you”

“Aye ayeee captain. My lips are sealed”

Both girls stood up and took their shorts off then pointed their asses towards the camera and slowly peeled off their tiny thongs. Now I’ve seen both girls naked before but nothing like this. They are both gymnasts so their asses are incredible and now their glistening pussies are right in front of me. Maggie is wearing a black thong and she is so wet that when she takes it off I literally see a string of her pussy juices that ends up getting stuck to the inside of her leg.

Maggie leans over and starts to kiss Peyton. This isn’t the first time I’ve seen them kiss either because they used to make out with each other at bars and stuff, probably for attention. But this was so much more intimate and sexual. I didn’t even know where to look. I was so overstimulated it’s a miracle I didn’t pass out. Little did I know that things were just starting. Suddenly the wife spoke up and it had been a while since she had said anything because her husband had been taking the lead.

“You’re the only one who isn’t naked now and I want to see you take off your clothes so bad”

I start to protest thinking that this will be taking things too far with the girls but they immediately cut me off.

“Stop being such a pussy, no one cares if your dick is small or looks weird!”

Peyton holds up my arms as Maggie unbuttons my pants then kneels down and pulls my boxer briefs down. My dick springs out of my boxers and nearly hits her right in the face.

“WOO DUDE! Jesus, nearly took my eye out! Your fucking dick is big dude…!?!”

“Dang bacon what the hell. Why is it always the most unlikely guys that are packing?”

“Im not massive at all, little above average I guess. I’m not even fully hard yet”

“how big is it?”

“7 inches”

“Maggie is he trying to fuck with us? I don’t care how close to average that is my pussy won’t take all that”

“girls can you help him out? I want to see his dick nice and hard”

Peyton reaches right down and starts fluffing me. I completely freeze up. The girl I used to have the biggest crush on in high school is standing there naked grabbing my dick right now. It feels so amazing and so wrong at the same time. I’m just too dam nervous. I can’t get all the way hard.

“alright let’s see who is the best at giving blowjobs. Whoever can deep throat the farthest wins”

“well I already know who is gonna win this contest… Maggie has no gag reflex; she is a monster”

“Show me! I’ll go first”

The wife starts sucking and gets a little over half of her husband’s dick into her mouth. Peyton immediately gets onto her knees and says she has dibs on going first cause I’m not completely hard yet. Maggie complains and says its cheating but eventually agrees. She takes my dick in her mouth and there is nothing that can hold me back at this point. I immediately get throbbing hard from the wetness in her mouth. Payton makes a good effort and gets three fourths of my length before giving up and continues to suck for a bit to make sure I’m rock solid for Maggie. They are getting super competitive. If I wasn’t completely trashed at this point I know I would have insta-cum right into her mouth.

They switch and now its Maggie’s turn. She immediately takes me right to the hilt no problem. I slide down her throat with what seems like little effort and to prove her point she grabs my hips and starts thrusting them back and forth so I’m just fucking her face. The other girls actually clapped. While Maggie was making me weak in the knees our internet friends started to have sex while Peyton is watching and fingering herself. Maggie finishes and takes a mini victory lap.

I can’t take it anymore so I grab Peyton and push her down into doggy. She is so wet but so tight so it takes some coaxing to get in. Finally, I manage to get my head in and make my way into her. She has the tightest pussy I’ve ever been in and after entering her I find out she has the shallowest one as well. I’m close to half way in and run right into her cervix. She lets out a little squeak and grabs my leg. I pull out a bit then continue with small thrusts. I can’t believe I’m fucking my best friend right now. I wasn’t even looking at what the couple online were doing anymore. She lasted about 20 thrusts before orgasming. Her pussy literally got so tight she pushed my dick out of her body. I tried getting back inside but she was too tight and sensitive.

I was still raring to go so I was pretty disappointed. Maggie had been watching and immediately ran up and yelled “put me in coach”, then jumped into my arms. We laid down, she got on top, then guided me inside of her. This was a much better fit. She shimmied down on my dick until the entire thing was buried inside her then started grinding. Maggie was much more vocal and immediately started moaning loudly and talking dirty telling me to fuck her harder. We fucked like that for a while and at this point Peyton had recovered and was feeling a little left out. I took her by the hand and guided her over then grabbed her hips and pulled her onto my face. Both girls came within the next 5 minutes.

Girl on top really doesn’t do anything for me and Peyton was down for the count again so I flipped Maggie onto her stomach and entered her from behind. I could get good thrusts in and out now and started pounding hard. I was starting to get close to finishing and started grunting more. I told them I was getting close so Peyton came over and told me to absolutely not cum in Maggie and to pull out early so she could finish me in her mouth.

That was all I needed to hear and immediately pulled out. Peyton took my dick in her mouth and I felt my dick get so hard I thought it was going to pop and my balls got tighter and tighter until finally there was no holding back and I unloaded rope after rope of cum into her mouth. She swallowed then continued to suck my dick until I was completely soft and still twitching. After taking a second to catch our breath we went back to the computer to see if our buddies were still there. They were and thanked us saying it was one of the sexiest nights of their lives then logged off. We went to bed and talked about it the next morning to clear the air and make sure no one was uncomfortable but everyone said they had a great time. Other than that, we have never even mentioned it. I’m sure it will never happen again but it will forever remain one of my fondest memories.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5ak5sn/how_some_complete_strangers_convinced_me_to_fuck