My Almost Threesome (FFM)

So I waited tables through my last year of college and for a little while after graduation. Those of you who have done that know that there’s always rampant partying and rampant hooking up. My life at the time was no different.

I had just broken-up with a serious girlfriend and a few friends (all girls now that I think about it) were coming over to help me drink away the pain. One of the girls, Amy, was a regular FWB. She was 23, a server with me, short, brunette, a bit chubby, but amazing tits (like huge EEs) and she would do anything in bed (she once let me face fuck her). The other was Lacy, she was freshly 18, just graduated from HS. She was hostess at the restaurant. She was short, petite, small B-sized tits, but a cheerleader body if I’d ever seen one. We had had a quasi-sexual encounter the week before but I didn’t let it go past feeling each other up when we were drunk because I thought my GF at the time and I could patch things up.

Anyway, they had come to my apartment and we started drinking. I didn’t expect anything to happen, maybe Amy and I would fuck, but that was it. That possibility seemed even less likely when Lacy arrived and told me two other girls, Lisa and Jessie were coming too (they were not very attractive and I did not view them sexually at all).

We start chugging vodka cocktails before Lisa and Jessie arrive. When they did they insisted on us all watching Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade. It was kind of a buzz kill. When they left, I though Amy and Lacy were leaving too, but Amy said she needed to use my bathroom and Lacy said she did too. I was cleaning up dishes when I heard the shower turn on.

I stood there dumbfounded for a minute, then I heard giggling. I lived in a one-bedroom apartment at the time. The only bathroom I had was inside my bedroom. I looked over from the kitchen and saw that the door to my room was cracked. Further exploration revealed that the door to the bathroom was also slightly ajar. Having had a few, and knowing these girls were probably ok with it, I wandered into the bathroom to behold a beautiful sight- two naked girls in my shower. Amy looked at me and said “You coming in?”

I think I was in the shower before my clothes hit the floor. I looked over at Lacy and started making out with her while rubbing my hands up and down her tight, wet body lingering on her breasts and tweaking her little pink nipples. Not wanting to leave Amy out of the fun, to took one of my hands and started running it down her body, between her enormous tits down to her little shaven pussy where I inserted a finger. She moaned and grabbed my face from Lacys and stuck her tongue deep in my mouth.

By this time my other hand had found it’s way to Lacy’s slit, dipping one finger into her wetness. She was so tight, she later told me she had only had sex with one other guy. There I was, with a dick that was so hard it could cut diamonds with both hands in two different girls. Both moaning as a found their clits and started teasing them. Amy’s was hidden between her large pussy lips, but Lacy’s was swollen past her lips and she would shudder every time I gently brushed it. I moved my mouth down to Amy’s giant breast. Sucking hard on her big nipples. I alternated between each one in my mouth while I worked both hands in-between their thighs.

Amy’s hand’s found their way to my dick and started jacking me off a bit. I knew that this wouldn’t work in my tiny apartment shower, so I suggested a location change, my bed a few yards away. We turned off the water and I helped dry them both off. Amy got down on her knees and took me in her wet, hot mouth while I toweled down Lacy as we were making out. After a few minutes I felt close and had Amy stop. I was drunk and I knew I only had one good one in me so I wanted to save it.

We rolled onto the bed and that’s when Amy leaned into kiss Lacy. It did not go well and this is why this is almost a threesome. Lacy sat up and said she thought she could do it, but she can’t. She looked at me and I had to make a choice (the worst choice any man should ever have to make). I channeled my Barney Stinson and decided new is always better. I asked Amy to head to the couch. Looking back, I might have been able to swing it if I had told Amy not to try anything with Lacy and just focused on one at a time, but I was drunk and this is a true story.

Amy left to the couch and left me and Lacy naked in my bed. I pounced on her and began kissing her deeply as I rubbed the head of my cock against her wet slit. She started moaning again. I slowly started pushing my dick into her. She was sopping wet, but soooo tight! I heard her moans turn into little cries. I stopped and asked her if she was ok. She nodded and said she’d be fantasizing about this since she first saw me at the restaurant. I began pushing again until I was three-quarters of the way in and she began to gasp and moan in pleasure. I smiled and tried to work into a slow rhythm as I could tell she was really starting to enjoy it. She grabbed my head and looked me in the eye with eyes that said “it hurts so good” I could feel her building a climax. I kept it steady telling her how tight her pussy was and how good it felt on my dick.

“You’re dick is so hard!” she answered. “It feels like you’re getting so fucking deep!”

I picked up the speed. Grabbing her tiny tits and pinching the nipples. I felt her cum as she let out a guttural moan and her legs fell to the bed limp. I kept going because I was getting to the point of no return. I asked her where she wanted my cum.

“On my chest! Oh, god cum all over my tits!”

I pulled out and sprayed it on her stomach and tits, a little bit hit her chin.

We fell to the bed spent and wrapped in sweaty sheets. I few minutes later I grabbed a towel and helped her clean her self up and we fell asleep. I woke up the next morning hung-over as shit. I got out of bed and glanced in the living room. Amy had left. Lacy was laying naked in my bed. I went to take a piss and when I walked back into the bedroom Lacy was on all fours, ass facing me. She looked back and said, “I’ve never tried it this way before, can we?” My dick got hard instantly. I tried to bury my face in her snatch, but she stopped me. “I don’t think I want guys down there, you can start fucking me. I am already pretty wet.” So I obliged, and slowly tried to stick my dick in as she crouched on the bed. It went in a little easier this time. She seemed to enjoy the position more as she started moaning like a whore in heat with every thrust. I grabbed at her tight little ass as I moved in and out. She was fucking wet! I could feel her grool dripping on to the bed and rolling towards my knees. I don’t know if she came, but when I did I pulled out and sprayed on her little cheerleader ass. I watched as my cum dripped down her asshole past her pussy. Tightest pussy I’d ever felt.

That was the only time we had sex, despite our best efforts. She went to college and I moved. Amy and I fucked quite a bit more. She never held it against me. She was chill as hell. I know she would have done anything with Lacy if Lacy had chilled. Oh well.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/4q57pb/my_almost_threesome_ffm