Background: This story took place 5 years ago. I’m a long-time lurker to this thread and decided to give this a whirl myself. This is one of my favorite sexual encounters and was sparked by seeing an old Facebook photo from that night.
In 2010 I was a senior in college where I spent 25 hours a week as a “practice” player for a major Division 1 women’s soccer program. (I would participate in training sessions with the girls when they were short-handed due to injuries, illness, etc…) I used to be decent at soccer and this was a great way to stay in shape and hang out with extremely fit college girls every day. :)
This is my story of how I met Sarah who was a former player at this university. She was training with the team for 4 months during her off-season with a women’s professional team in the United States, while her girlfriend was training with a national team in Europe for the Women’s World Cup.
Sarah: 5,7′ inches, 125 lbs, green eyes, shoulder-length brown hair, 6 pack-abs, and extremely toned arms. She had perky B-cup tits with muscular legs and a firm ass. She is extremely outgoing, confident, and when she drinks all of those qualities are amplified.
Me: 5’8 155lbs, buzz hair cut with a soccer players build (low body fat percentage, strong legs, toned arms but not body builder size). I’m an above average looking guy that has never had problems getting girls.
STORY BEGINS:
The training sessions were every morning at 6 a.m., 5-days a week. She was focused on staying in shape during the professional off-season, and I was usually focused on sweating out the hangover from the night before. Our interaction was pretty limited in the beginning as there were 23 other girls on the team I was trying to have sex with and she was just another hot soccer girl. As you can imagine, at 7 a.m., there isn’t a lot of happy/cheery faces before, or during, a 90 grueling training session. Interactions are limited to water breaks, and on-field interaction. I should note that I found Sarah extremely attractive, but as mentioned before– there were 23 other 18-21 year old girls in peak athletic condition that (in my mind) I was undressing every day with my eyes. She didn’t “stand out” more than any of the others as I probably would have had sex with 20/23 of them.
After about a month of seeing, and playing alongside, Sarah we started to converse more and more before/after the training sessions. We shared many similar interests, and she was surprisingly eager to drink beers (which was my only priority as a college senior). I knew she didn’t really have friends/family in town so I casually invited her to join my friends and I on our weekly (Thursday-Saturday night) drinking expeditions. At this point there hadn’t even been a hint of sexual tension, or conversation. Just two people looking to drink beers and take a break from her professional training. She became a regular amongst our group of friends and I began to learn more and more about her.
During conversation at a dive-bar one evening she opened up to me that she actually had a girlfriend who played for the same team as her. (This is extremely common in women’s professional soccer) Her girlfriend was currently training with her native (not USA) national team in preparations for the Women’s World Cup, which was why she came back to the University to train alone. She began to tell me how tough long distance relationships were, and she casually mentioned that she was also into guys and had dated men in the past. Again– at no point was this conversation sexual, just two friend drinking beers discussion life. After a couple more beers she started to share that her current girlfriend was about to play in a friendly match over-seas and that she ALWAYS sent her a series of naked pictures before kick-off for good-luck. She casually excused herself to the restroom where she presumably took some naked pictures. I kind of laughed it off, because i’m drunk and Sarah is super cool and it sounds like something I would ask one of my girlfriends to do. Our night ends with both of us going our separate ways.
Fast forward to a couple of weeks later on a Thursday night– I am at my apartment drinking Jameson with some of my buddies playing Call of Duty for Xbox 360. Sarah begins texting me telling me that she is done with her training sessions for the day and eager to join us for Thirsty Thursdays. I knew that her girlfriend had played a game that day and I asked if she had sent her usual “pre-game pictures”. My phone immediately buzzed back with a picture of Sarah in the mirror wearing only a soccer jersey pulled down jussssst far enough to cover up her pussy with the caption “good luck”. (our text exchanges as follows)
Sarah: “good luck”.
Me: WHOA! did you mean to send that to me?
S: no. ; )
Me: wow, she is one extremely lucky girl, i would love to see what you’re hiding under that jersey.
S: LOL– in you’re dreams. I’m sure you have plenty of girls that you could ask to send you naked pictures right now
my thoughts: (i’ve been drinking Jameson all afternoon and am feeling good. What is the worst that can happen here?
Me: …but none of them are “lesbians”. You don’t have anything to worry about since you aren’t into boys anyways.
S: You’re right, but I still think you’re pretty cute. Maybe you will get lucky someday. My gf is coming to town next week to visit and I can’t wait for you to meet her.
Me: oh god, I won’t see you for at least two days while you lock yourselves in your bedroom and scissor LOL (we had many drunken conversations about the effectiveness of scissoring, but wasn’t worthy to be mentioned in this post)
S: I HOPE SO! I haven’t gotten off in 3 months… :(
Me: OMG, i couldn’t go three days without getting off! You poor soul, I will pray for you.
S: I know, i’m extremely horny and her game already started. I sent her some really hot pictures earlier and she promised to score a goal.
S: Picture message of Sarah completely naked taking an over the shoulder selfie in the mirror. All I can see is her firm, naked ass in the mirror while she covers her boobs with her other hand.
*my thoughts* i’m buzzed and this is fucking awesome. I might actually get to fuck her tonight… how weird. None of this was out of the norm because we had grown pretty close and we were both extremely open people. I don’t think either of us felt uneasy about sexual conversations because she was a “lesbian” and I was a college bachelor trying to smash everything that walked.
Me: She is so fucking lucky. Your ass is perfect and I would worship that thing.
S: your turn
Me: what do you mean?
S: take your clothes off and send me a picture NOW!
Me: *sprinting to the bathroom to take a picture* I sent a picture of me shirtless with one hand covering up my extremely average penis (6 inches, decent girth)
S: yummy… too bad i’m only into pussy or I would love to see what you’re hiding ;)
Me: maybe I can change your mind for one night?
S: Ha! I haven’t been with a guy for 4 years! I wouldn’t know what to do with it. Plus, my gf comes to town next week and I wouldn’t be able to keep it a secret from her. i’m not saying I wouldn’t be interested in letting you see more of me… but not while I have a GF.
That was about the extent of our sexual conversation. I wasn’t super concerned about pressing my luck because I had a FWB I knew I could bang that night. Sarah and I began planning to meet at a bar to “pregame” for the evening along with another 6-8 people we regularly drank with.
Fast forward 4 hours to 10 p.m. when we all met up for beers. Sarah was wearing a blue and white striped tank top with painted on jeans. Her perky B cup tits filled out her tight tank top perfectly, while her ass and legs couldn’t of looked sexier in those tight jeans. I was pretty buzzed by this point and made it a point to immediately text her (because we are in a group of friends) to let her know how sexy she was. I saw her check her phone and she just looked up and winked at me. Our night progressed to heavy drinking as we were celebrating another friend being in town. We were pounding 16 ounce Bud Lights and taking more Fireball shots than anyone needed to be on a Thursday. We begin jumping from bar to bar, and at this point Sarah hasn’t really given me much attention. So I start texting my FWB thinking that “I at least need to have sex with someone tonight, and while it was fun to flirt with Sarah that ships has probably sailed”
We get to the next ‘club’ where everyone is dancing and having a good time. I’m trying to convince my FWB through text to pick me up at 2 a.m. (when the bars close) when suddenly my phone lights up. It’s a message from Sarah:
Sarah: You are looking sexy as hell tonight, and don’t make it weird around our friends but I think i’m going home with you!
Me: *immediately looking around to see where the fuck she is, fully expecting to see her and our other friends pointing and laughing at me*
Sarah: (Picture message of her in the women’s restroom pulling her shirt down to reveal perfect B cup tits with erect nipples.)
Sarah: (Picture message of her with jeans pulled down revealing her bare pussy and a finger over her lips making the “shhh” gesture) Caption: guess what color panties i’m wearing?
By this point i’m semi-erect in the middle of a bar trying to look at these pictures without anyone else catching on.
Me: Jesus Christ you are beautiful. Are you messing with me? No panties?!?!? I thought you had a GF?
Sarah: Why don’t you find out for yourself?
At this point, she meets me next to the bar (where i’m discreetly still looking at the naked pictures of her) and give me a big hug. She is a little bit drunk at this point and grabs my ass while playfully asking “Who ya texting?” I said “You have got to be fucking kidding me, that is the hottest thing i’ve ever seen. I can’t believe you’re not wearing panties” She says, “Why don’t you find out for yourself?” It’s at this point that she grabs my hand and puts an ice cube in my fingers. In the middle of a club she begins to put my hand down her pants (with ice cube). She is making the most insanely sexy eye contact this entire time while I discover that she really isn’t wearing any underwear. As soon as my hands and ice cube make contact with her bare pussy lips she pulls my hand out to make sure we don’t get kicked out of the club. She then takes my hand, and ice cube, and proceeds to eat the fucking ice cube from my fingers. I am literally about to burst in my pants at this point and quickly realize “holy shit, this girl is a fucking freak and I am going to smash her brains out tonight” At this point I have got to figure out the fastest way to get her back into my bedroom and I immediately begin making plans to take her home right now. We fooled around (touching over clothes, light kissing) on the dance floor for a couple of minutes before I started making an exit strategy.
We made up some bullshit excuse to our friends that she needed a ride home to FaceTime with her girlfriend and I was going to be the nice guy to take her home. We hopped into my car and drove straight to my apartment. The whole way home she is talking about how she can’t wait to do this and how she wanted to fuck me the second she saw me walk into the bar that night. She is lightly stroking my cock over my shorts the whole way home while I play with her exposed nipples. This never escalated because i was somewhat buzzed and trying not to get pulled over ( I know… poor decisions in college)
We get back to my apartment and I immediately go to the restroom because i’ve been drinking all night and have to pee. I finish up in the restroom and walk into my bedroom and lay my eyes on one of the fittest/sexiest bodies I have ever seen. Sarah had wasted no time getting naked while I was going pee. The lights were on and in front of me stood Sarah and her 6 pack abs, shaved pussy, and tribal tattoo on her rib cage. It took everything in my power not to cum instantly. I don’t think either of us said a word. We began making out passionately and within 30 seconds I was straddling her on my bed, both of us completely naked. I reach my hand down and fill her extremely wet pussy with two fingers. She lets out tons of soft moans and begins nibbling on my ear begging me to keep going. I am fully erect and straddling her in missionary position while she strokes my cock and I am gently fucking her soaking wet pussy with two fingers. I can tell that her tight pussy hasn’t had a penis in it for a very long time. She is literally holding onto my back and whimpering at this point for me to keep going because she is about to cum. I put her left nipple in my mouth and start sucking, while stroking her clit. Within 30 seconds she is raking my back with her fingernails as her body gushes into orgasm all over my bed. Her body was shaking and my hand was filled with her pussy juices and cum. I have never experienced such an intense orgasm in my life… I literally just laid there with a shit eating grin on my face.
I climbed off of her, still fully erect, and told her that I had never seen a more intense orgasm in my life. While catching her breathe she told me that it had been way too long since she had cummed and not to be too proud of myself because that was the horniest she had ever been. We laid there for 5-10 minutes as she caught her breathe. She was still lightly stroking my cock as I played with her nipples and teased her inner thighs. I remember being in awe of her body and how fit she was. After all, she was a professional soccer player and most of the sorority sluts I was banging only hit the gym to keep the beer weight off.
*Drunken college boy moment* I take this time to tell her that I wanted to lick her pussy better than her gf, or any other girl could. She laughed and said that she doesn’t mind having her pussy eaten, but she would prefer my fingers or cock, because she has never gotten off from oral. I take this as a direct challenge to my ego and immediately bury my face in- between her legs. The first couple of licks I could taste her cum and she was still soaking wet as my face became covered in her cum and juices. I wish that this section of the story was a redemption story for all the men who thought they could eat pussy better than girls… but its not. After 10 minutes I could tell that while she didn’t hate my oral skills, she just wasn’t super into oral in general.
I licked my way up from her pussy to her mouth and began making out with her as she tasted her own juices. She begins feverishly jerking my cock at this point and says that she really wants my dick inside of her. I don’t waste a single second… I pull a condom out and she stops me while i’m taking the wrapper off to say she wants it without it, and that she is on the pill. I almost cummed (again) on the spot. I am standing off the bed at this point as she scoots over to the edge of the bed and begins to guide my cock in her throbbing pussy missionary style. The second I entered her pussy she let out a gasp and fell back on the bed. She told me to take it easy as it had been 4 years since she had a penis inside her. I took the first 15-20 strokes extremely slow, working my hard cock into her extremely tight pussy little by little. After 30 seconds I was fully inside her and could feel her lips suffocating my cock. I began pounding her missionary after a couple of minutes as she covered her face with a pillow to muffle her screams and moans. She came one more time from the missionary as her legs began to quiver and her hips arched in a way to let me know she needed me deeper inside her. She told me that she couldn’t take much more as her pussy was already getting sore from being pounded so hard (apparently this is what happens when you don’t have a penis inside you for 4 years). She asked what my favorite position was, to which I replied “doggy style”. She immediately got on all fours in front of me and slid her tight pussy lips and ass towards my fully erect cock. She reached her hand between her legs and guided me back inside of her. At this point I am in heaven, I’m staring directly at her tight asshole while her pussy lips are stretched to the max around my cock. I start to work my thumb over her asshole and gently press against it. This sends her into ecstasy as she begins begging me to fuck her harder and faster. I oblige and she starts begging me to cum inside of her… saying things like ” i need your cum inside of me, and i love how warm it feels”. I could feel that it was time to cum and even though i was a drunk/dumb college kid i knew better than to bust inside of her. I pulled out right as i was about to cum and shot 5 or 6 ropes all over her asshole and lower back. We both collapsed into the bed and laid there while we collected our breathe.
By this time it was 1 or 2 a.m and we were both sufficiently drunk and just passed out on each other. I woke up the next morning with her naked body cuddling all over me and i took another couple of minutes to admire her body. I had somewhere to be at 8 a.m. so i woke up up and told her i needed to take her to her car which was Downtown. We made small talk the whole way home about how unexpected that night was and how hot it was. I wish there was some crazy ending to this story, but there wasn’t. I dropped her off at Starbucks and said goodbye. I got home around 11 a.m. from my appointment to a text message from Sarah. It was a picture of her swollen pussy with the caption “i’m so sore”.
We never hooked up again, and things were never weird between us. In fact, her gf came to town that next week and we all went out for dinner and drinks a couple of times. Over the next couple of weeks she would send the occasional naked picture, or flirty text, but it never escalated again. She told me one night that it was some of the best sex she had ever had, but really cared for her gf and that was going to be the end of it.
*my final thoughts* holy shit these take a lot of work to write, i sat down an hour ago and didn’t know where this would take me. This is 100% true story and one of the crazier stories of my life. Sarah and I still talked occasionally for a couple of months until she moved back to the town in which she plays professionally. We are still friends on Facebook and seeing her picture prompted me to write this story. Coincidentally, she is actually married to a man now and has a kid. I’d like to think that i converted her back to the cock… :)
Thanks for reading and i’d love any feedback/comments you might have!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/4jhbr9/first_time_post_my_first_time_with_a_bisexual
Why was a lesbian on birth control?