I fucked my best friends boyfriend – Part 2

For those of you who don’t know this story, here’s the link to part 1:

https://redd.it/48h8h4

So, my housemates and I just finished having some drinks and yes, sex came into the conversation.

We talked about what turns us on etc etc and I brought up the topic “If you could fuck anyone you know, who would it be?” By this point, we’ve had quite a few drinks. My other housemate, Julia, said she’d love to sleep with some guy who lives back in her home town and Nicole said she’d love to fuck a guy on her course who she flirts with now and again (He’s been mentioned in the past about how hot he is). I asked her would she ever do anything about it if he came onto her and she said, “it would be tempting because he is very sexy, but I wouldn’t.” I asked her if Paul said it was ok, would you then? To which she replied “Abso-fucking-lutely.” Then it was my turn. I was umming and ahhing for a while before admitting that I found Paul attractive. Julia AND Nicole teased me after saying it. I think it was brushed aside because of the amount of drinks we had.
Nicole then mentioned something new: “Well, first he tells me that he thinks you have great tits, then he’s dreaming about fucking you.”
We laughed and I asked when he said that I have great tits, and It was because of a photo Nicole had taken during a Christmas party from last year where I was wearing a revealing dress. This of course set me off.

The conversation continued on. Julia then says “Well, to be fair, from your stories and description of Paul in bed, along with some very loud and enthusiastic audio from you, Nicole, I’d say that’s a fair choice.” Nicole went red and got the giggles, then did the whole “I’m not that loud” thing and we continued to tease.
After a bit of teasing, we got onto the topic of watching porn. I have on occasion, but Nicole and Julia have not. Nicole and Paul were brought up again.
We asked if they’d ever taken photos or filmed themselves fucking, and Nicole said they had filmed in the past, but nothing recently. We asked if the video still existed, but it was recorded on an old laptop.

By this point, I felt comfortable asking the following question: “Would you ever film the two of you fucking so we could see?” Nicole went red again and said she wouldn’t. I could tell that she wasn’t totally uncomfortable with the conversation, so I continued to playfully probe.
I teased her by saying, “For all we know, you could just be playing really loud porn. We want some visual proof.” Nicole then said, “Well it’s all very well for you two, but what do I get out of this?”
We came up with pretty lame ideas such as “doing the dishes for a month.”
It had now become a matter of just begging and pleading (still lots of giggling and joking around) and then I finished with this: “I love hearing you two fucking from another room. I’m not afraid to admit that I’ve masturbated listening to you a few times.” Which surprisingly got a huge laugh.
Without dragging out more pleading and rationalizing why she should, she said ok, but only if Paul consents to it too.
We asked when we could see it and she said, “Maybe tomorrow. I’ll see how I’m feeling about it then.”

So there you have it. I’m hoping that she goes through with it and share the experience on here again. I’m still feeling guilty about what happened, but if I can get some sort of sexual experience with Nicole and Paul, it might make me feel a little easier about the whole thing. I have enjoyed telling my experience because it was so much fucking fun. I just hope I can get rid of the guilt thing…

Thanks to everyone who gave me advice from the previous topic.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/48jn7w/i_fucked_my_best_friends_boyfriend_part_2

19 comments

  2. Probe about a threesome. It gets you a chance again with Paul, lets you explore that a girl knows how to please a girl, and it gets you a chance again with Paul

  5. lol guarantee this guy is going to be thinking “dammit that was a hot night but now this girl refuses to just pretend like it never happened”

  6. I hope you can get over the guilt and that everything works out. It sounds like you’ve had an amazing time, and great chemistry with each of your friends! Rooting for you.

  7. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  8. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  9. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  10. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  11. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  12. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  13. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  14. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  15. No room for guilt here. You’re both adult human beings, decided to do what you did. Enjoyed it, as far as I understand. Arranging a threesome would be best option, but I know that’s not easy, because requires strict declaration from each person ;) But as I understand, you’re on quite good way – everybody seems to be openminded, maybe you just have to wait a little time to the right moment…

  18. Ask them to let you film for it them since they are going to show you anyway might as well let you see the live show!!!

Comments are closed.