Cheating on my boyfriend by sucking 2 guys [FMM]

So I've always been a horny person but never considered myself super slutty. I had my share of hookups and I'd done some kinky stuff but I wasn't nearly as slutty as some of the girls I'd seen at parties and stuff. About me – 5"10', tanned, D cups, long brown hair, athletic body. I've always got attention from boys and I admit I'm a huge flirt and a tease most of the time, but if never cheated before. I started dating a guy named Ben the summer after high school. He was the 5th guy is ever been with and I figured it'd just be a summer fling hook up type of thing but we got really close and started dating towards the end of summer. Our colleges were a few hours apart which made it hard and left me really horny no matter how much I masturbated haha, it just wasn't the same. We tried to see each other every other weekend but as Christmas break of freshman year guy closer we saw each other less and less with bad weather and conflicting finals schedules.

So I got close with some girls in my dorm hall and we pretty regularly went to the baseball house parties. They were huge parties at this house off campus where a lot of baseball players lived with a few nearby apartments. So I got to know the baseball guys really well and my friends had hooked up a lot with some of them over freshman year. I was a super tease and guys were always trying to get in my pants but even in my drunkest nights I resisted any temptation and trust me there was A LOT of it. I never cheated until…..

They had a huge party after finals week. It'd been a month since I saw Ben and I hadn't been partying much and I knew this would be the last party before we all went home. Maybe in the back of my head I knew I might do something because I shaved myself totally smooth, put on a sexy dark purple dress that my boobs looked great in, put on my favorite heels and went out with a few girls from the dorm. I felt really sexy!!

As soon as I walked in I felt totally sexy. I'm sure it wasn't, but it felt like a movie with everyone's heads turning to gawk and stare at me. I was used to lots of attention but whether it was my outfit or my heels making me even taller, it felt like the boys were all checking me out. Someone handed me a drink and after making my rounds we all started dancing in the dance floor/ basement. Like I said, I'd never cheated but I'd always dance and sometimes let guys get too touchy-feely. The furthest a guy has got was grinding against me while grabbing my tits then sliding his hand down to my crotch but when he would start kissing my neck I'd reluctantly stop him and just keep grinding.

So I'm dancing and drinking, feeling buzzed and then a little drunk. I danced and flirted with a few guys throughout the night and must have felt at least 10 guys grab my butt cheeks in the dance floor. Occasionally is check my phone and see missed calls from Ben but I just kept partying.

So the night starts winding down and my roommate comes up to me and whispers that she's bringing a guy back and asks me to stay out of the room for awhile so they can hook up. I stood outside and made some phone calls but couldn't find a place to hang out. Jack and Jason were smoking cigarettes nearby and started chatting with me. I knew them enough to joke around with them and stuff, they were both seniors and lived together so after some chit chat they told me I could hang out at their apartment for awhile.

So I take off my heels and walk with then to their place. Total bro house hahaha, beer cans, naked posters, beer pong table, etc. totally NOT my boyfriend lol. So we sit in the living room watching TV, drinking a little bit and we are all drunk. Things are really flirty and honestly I LOVED the attention I was getting. I went to the bathroom to take off my bra and get more comfy and I remember them both commenting on how I had the best tits on campus and I was actually flattered. They both knew I had a boyfriend but didn't care. The conversation got more sexual and they teased me about letting them see my underwear. I stood up off the couch in between then and pulled up my dress to show them my light blue thong. What I didn't expect was Jason to slap my ass. I got instantly horny but just let out a giggle and sat back down. Minutes went by and I was telling them about missing my boyfriend and specifically sex. Jason was like "I bet you miss your hair pulled don't you?" And reached up into my hair and gave it a tug. Instinctively I let out a soft moan and there was an awkward silence. Then Jack broke the silence and said "let's do that again" while laughing and tugging my hair a little tougher. I just but my lip in silence and in sure they could both tell I loved it.

My phone rang and it was Ben but I put it on silent and out the phone in my purse. Jason reached over and pulled at my top jokingly acting like he was gonna pull my tits out. I laughed and stopped him. "Oh cmon Jess, we akready saw your thong, just let us see your tits for a minute." "And what do I get to see!? Let me see some dick and maybe you can see them." I said it jokingly but they both looked at each other and stood up in front of me and started undoing their belts. As long as I just look and don't touch, it's not really cheating right!?!

"You first" Jason said. I rolled my eyes and pulled the top of my dress down. My tits popped out and I used my hands as a bra for my D cups. They looked like kids at Christmas hahah and they both just stared before Jason was like "Damn… Nice fucking tits!!" He moved to squeeze them and I pulled away… "Hey! No touching… Plus it's my turn to see a little something. Lose the pants?" They looked at each other and pulled down their jeans, then their boxers around their ankles. When their dicks flopped out I just lost my mind and was totally horny. Jason was about 9 inches, veiny, totally shaved with huge balls. Jack was maybe 7 inches but thicker and had stubble. Two really nice, hung, gorgeous cocks.

It felt like I lost control of my body. I'm sure I stared at them kicking my lips or with my mouth hanging open but I just dropped right to my knees and grabbed them with each hand. Bens dick was like 5 inches but these felt so gigantic in my hands. I just looked up at them and gently played with them for a few minutes. Jason looked down at me and said "why don't you give it a kiss" and a million things ran through my head as I inched my lips towards his monster cock… Will Ben find out? Should I tell him? Are we done? How can I do this!? Before I could think it all through my lips wheeler wrapped around his dick and I was halfway deep. Then I looked up at Jack and switched to sucking him for a moment.

They both kicked off their boxers and sat on the couch. His legs spread, I crawled to Jason's dick and licked from the base to his head a few times, totally entranced by his huge dick. Definitely way bigger than Ben. "Go deep" he said and I slowly inched his cock deeper down my throat. I made it about 6 inches before gagging and pulling off. "Fuck yea, I love that" he said while I blinked tears out of my eyes. "Hey, my turn!" Said Jack so I repeated the same thing with him until I slightly gagged. I looked up at Jason with a big smile. "You like these dicks? I think you can go deeper than that." He stood up in front of me with his dick right at my lips. It was over whelming how big it was. "Open up and let's see if you can deepthroat." I opened up and looked up at him as he slid it deeeeeep down my throat slowly. I could feel myself wanting to gag but I suppressed it until he was almost balls deep when I couldn't stop anymore. My stomach clenched and I gagged loudly while closing my eyes but I felt his hand in my hair pulling me towards him. Then I felt it… His balls press against my chin. He held me there for a minute and I grabbed onto his hips tight.

He pulled out quickly and left me gasping. I could feel warm drool running down my neck and over my tits. I felt guilty but it made me even hornier knowing how wrong it was. I sat back collecting myself while Jason watched me and Jack player with himself on the couch. I stood up and slid off my dress kinda shaking my head with a smile. I looked down and saw drool over my tits and laughs with a "oh lord." Jason squeezed my tits and massaged the spit into my skin which felt amazing. Then he sat back on the couch beside jack. "Jess, I love those fucking tits." "You're so romantic" I quipped back and we all laughed. I crawled over to jack in nothing but my panties and started working his cock with my mouth, bobbing my head icon his dick while running my tongue along the underside. It was much slower and sensual than Jason and I got in a good rhythm using my hand to stroke while I sucked. Jack just softly moaned the whole time while Jason kept making comments. "Talk about dick sucking lips." "Look at those D cups bouncing around" "what a fuckin body." Etc. It turned me on that they found me so sexy and were obviously enjoying my oral skills hahah. It was also sexy seeing the other guy with my peripherals and knowing he couldn't wait until his turn. At some point I tied my hair back and jack was gently using my ponytail to guide me up and down his shaft while Jason stroked beside us. I could feel jack throbbing in my mouth and I looked up and asked if he was gonna cum. He nodded and put his hands behind his head and started moaning. He looked so sexy sitting back shirtless with his eyes closed and I could tell he was about to cum. I wrapped my lips around his head and stroked faster with my left hand on his balls. I felt them tighten and he unloaded in my mouth a surprising amount which I swallowed every drop. When I pulled away and swallowed again he let out a deep sigh and said "that was amazing. Thank you" then got up to grab us some water.

Jason sat their stroking and said now it was his turn. We made some chit chat while I drank some water and cleaned my mouth out from jacks load and then o moved over between Jason's legs and started slurping. Up and down, up and down. Jason was holding my ponytail rougher and saying things like "swallow my big fucking divk girl" "oh yea show me what you got" etc. he yankee my head up and looked at me. "Suck my balls." I positioned my head lower and stroked his cock while kissing then licking every inch of his balls. I remember them tasting salty and they were the biggest balls I'd ever seen so I paid them lots of attention. I heard my phone buzzing in my purse and thought of Ben which gave me a rush. Then Jason said "wanna eat my ass too?" I thought about all the tunes Ben brought it up and how I told him there was no chance. But Jason lifted his legs and all of a sudden I was eating man ass. As soon as I started, I felt his cock throb in my hand. I ate ass for a minute then wrapped my lips back around his dick waiting for him to cum. He pushed me off of him and grabbed his cock, stroking faster until he sprayed a HUGE load all over me. I stuck my tongue out and closed my eyes and it seemed like an endless cumshot. I felt it on my face and my tits. There was so much I started laughing hahah and when I opened my eyes he was slouched back breathing heavy. I looked around for tissues but he sighed and said "leave it there fur now, I need to take in this view." We laughed and I sat there with his load on my face and tits. Jack watched from the kitchen while drinking his water the whole time. He laughed and walked by, agreeing that I wore cum well hahah then said thank you and headed to bed after a few minutes.

I wasn't sure what to do… I guess get dressed and leave? While talking I got up to get my stuff. "Where you going?" Jason said. I told him I guess I'd be going back to my dorm since it was like 330. "Don't you want your turn?" I didn't understand what he meant for a minute and I totally wasn't expecting it so I was caught off guard. "Oh! You mean… Definitely!" I was sooooo wet. I sat my ass down in the couch and threw my thong across the room with a huge smile on my face then spread my legs as wide as I could. He laughed at how eager I was, made a joke again about the jizz on my face and started eating me. Not sensual and no fire okay needed lol I was more than ready to go. It only took him a few minutes of sucking my clit with 2 fingers inside me before I was ready to burst. He slid a finger in my ass and it was all over… Super hard orgasm that lasted FOREVER!! I just collapsed on his couch, sweaty and naked. He gave my ass a slap and we both laughed and then chatted a few minutes before I got my things, washed up, got dressed and made my walk of shame back to the dorms. Just a super amazing night!!

Ps – I did hook up with Jason a bunch more times the next semester while me and Ben were on "break" and it was awesome!! Feel free to PM me or comment or whatever, I've never posted here but I thought one of my most memorable experiences would be appreciated!!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3ze4c4/cheating_on_my_boyfriend_by_sucking_2_guys_fmm

77 comments

  4. Maybe in PM but I’m not promising that!! I’m not a choir girl but I also don’t want my tits in such a public place!

  7. Great story. Always nice to hear from the girls point of view. Love to hear more and see more. Thanks for the story

  12. Thanks for the hot story! Would love to hear stories about you and Jason. Oh and mos def add me to the list of people who want to have a peek at the campus’ best looking boobs.

  22. It’s not often I get frustrated at a gonewildstory, but come the hell on. Cheating is the one thing that just… It gets me. Ever since that story in here about the dude who watched his dream girl get fucked because size matters I just… If the shoe was reversed, would you really think it was all that hot? If you’re gonna go and suck two dudes dicks, at least tell the guy and just break up with him. It sounds like it wasn’t working very well anyway /rant

  25. You realize you’ve probably just jumped on a sinking karma ship with that right? I’ll ride it down with you comrade!

  27. I really felt like that needed to be said though. I don’t know if you read the story I was talking about, but I never thought a cuckold porn story would change *my life*

  29. Is it the one where the guy had the title that said size does matter and the douchebag was banging all of her roommates at the same time?

  31. Moral of the story, fellas, your girl will fuck someone else whenever she feels like it. She might be fucking someone else right now. She’ll be kissy faced and all smiles when she sees you, but those lips may have just sucked two other dicks.

  34. Well he did find out over that Christmas break. This all actually happened a couple years ago and Ben is long gone now. So I told him but spared some if the dirtier details and we went on a "break" and basically saw each other sparingly over the spring semester and hooked up and stuff but it just kinda fizzled out.

  35. I mean I definitely felt bad about it afte the fact and during the whole situation I was thinking about him quite a few times. But I was just too incredibly horny and couldn’t control myself which is obviously no excuse but I’m just being honest with how I felt!! And it wasn’t like I had a perfect marriage or something – I was dating a guy for a few months who I never saw and sexually left me a little less satisfied

  36. Great story u/throwawayfor_jess. I hope you are going to share some more of your adventures.

  37. seriously and this girl acts like she is the hottest shit… those 2 dudes probably tried to fuck 50 other girls that night. I fucked a girl one time and found out a few days later she had a boyfriend…she thought she was hot shit and her personality was so ugly. she then told me she broke up with him and then I found out she was lying, then she actually broke up with him and told me she was single now. I said "do you expect me to get with you after I know you are a cheater" girls man…real women know that they want and aren’t afraid to break up with a dude in case they hurt his feelings or something.

  39. Well it wasn’t working!! Don’t get in your head that I was in a perfect relationship or anything. He was a nice guy who I dated for a few months and I barely saw and he was a little sexually disappointing for me. It’s def no excuse to cheat and it was definitely wrong but considering this subreddit I was focusing more on how horny and turned on I was instead of the ins and outs of my relationship. I know it’s messed up that it turned me on but I’m just being honest s out my feelings about it!!

  44. Exactly. My thing is she can be a rock solid 11/10, but if you’re personality is shitty, and you do shitty things, I don’t wanna go near you. I just can’t stand cheaters. If you’re gonna bang Someone else, just end the goddamn relationship. It’s not that hard.

  45. If it wasn’t working why didn’t you just end it? You said so in the text. If he was disappointing you so bad, then why stay with him? He can be sweet all he wants to, but a successful emotional relationship needs a successful *physical* side too. This whole story is awfully fucking weird, and quite frankly you’re a terrible person.

  46. I do like some of the stories on here except for cheating stories. I’m not here to bash you. If my boyfriend cheated on me and especially if he went and bragged how hot it was it would break my heart.

  48. It physically changed me as a person. It’s nuts. I just… I was here to fap and then my soul got crushed. Felt so bad for the guy

  49. I understand that it can be difficult in the moment and while I do have my moral qualms, I wasn’t in the situation and so, I can’t say that I wouldn’t have done similarly in a similar situation. That being said, I imagine I would be deeply troubled afterwards. You mentioned you and Ben were on a break during the second semester. Is there a reason you didn’t completely break up with him? EDIT: I just thought of another question. If you found yourself in a similar situation again down the road, do you think you’d cheat again? To be more clear, do you think this first time makes it easier to cheat down the road or more difficult?

  50. That was a great story – very sexy. Did you ever circle back for Jack? BTW don’t let the haters get you down. You handled the situation just fine. You broke up with Ben without making a big dramatic confession and left him with his dignity in tact.

  51. It was a mistake for me to get in a relationship with someone so soon who I knew was gonna be so far away basically for four years. So I told him I cheated but spared the details and he said he had almost cheated with a girl in his dorm but never did. I told him we should split but he wanted to keep talking and see what happened. I can’t say for sure I wouldn’t cheat but I don’t expect to be in the same situation again. I wouldn’t cheat on someone I loved but I didn’t have those feelings for Ben

  52. Because I was young and naive and liked spending time with him. The sex was fun at first but it became clear he wasn’t really what I was looking for. We should have never dated period. I will lose zero sleep though over your opinions, take care!

  54. I know how it feels to lose control, and to feel so wrong, and so right at the same time. Great story!

  55. > If the shoe was reversed, would you really think it was all that hot? There are plenty of highly upvoted stories of the reverse situation. You’re in a porn lit subreddit, fuck off with this moralizing bullshit. This isn’t /r/relationships

  56. Oh look. A white knight. And a self proclaimed feminist! Oh goody. I’ll grab the popcorn.

  58. Wow, all the hurt boys come out of the woodwork every time there’s a "cheat" story. Get over it, she didn’t cheat on you and this subreddit isn’t about making people feel guilty about their life choices. Plenty of people cheat, for lots of different reasons. I’ve cheated. Sure it wasn’t the best thing I’ve ever done but fuck it was one hot night! Enjoy the story for what it is and take your vindication somewhere else. Go bitch on /r/relationships or some bullshit if you need to get it off your chest. /u/throwawayfor_jess, that was fucking hot! Thanks for the great story! Hope you contribute again soon!

  59. Thanks!! I’m glad you enjoyed it. I was pretty shocked at how many PMs and comments were angry ones lol just given the subreddit. But don’t worry they don’t phase me, I’m just glad most people are taking it for what it is – a hott memory of mine!!

  60. Didn’t think this was a subreddit for ethical debates. Some people get turned on by cheating. Is cheating wrong? Yes, but there are worse things to find ‘hot’

  63. Oh man. The people in defense of this girl keep rolling in. Please, anything else? I still have popcorn left.

  64. I mean obviously I agree with you, but this isn’t really the subreddit to be judging other people for their bad choices. If you don’t like stories about cheating, don’t read them, there are tons that pop up here, are you going to read them all and be disappointed when you do?

  70. Every time I see all the angry commentators, I figure they’re just upset because they can’t get laid. That and they’re probably 15 and still trying to understand their penis. I’m glad you’re not phased! I hope you continue to contribute! :)

  71. So sexy! I love reading about a girl who can take on two cocks. I can’t wait to share this with my hubby ??? ~chile

  72. Two comments on the post and nothing but down votes… Pussypass denied =p

  74. "that happened". Honey, I’m sure your fiction will play well…….someplace, while you eat yourself, literally, to death. :) It must get cold in your parents trailer in the winter.

  77. How could you possibly know if someone is poor? And why do you think it is appropriate to make fun of someone who is at a financial disadvantage?

Comments are closed.