Some of you might remember me. I posted under a different ironman name up until recently. I deleted my account, because it got hacked. Some of the stories I posted over the last couple of years are gone forever from reddit, so I figured I would come back and start posting some old ones to make sure they aren't lost. I will post new stories as well when I have a chance. (New stories will come I promise). Here is an old one. Hope you enjoy:
Like I've said in previous posts. I figured it would be fun to go back to my promiscuous (man-whore) days and recall some of the stories from back then. I'm generally considered a really good-looking guy (used to model, 6’3”, dark hair, blue eyes, swimmers build, workout regularly), so that enabled me to have quite a fun sex life. These stories are 100% true and not embellished in any way. I think that a straight honest story even if not as exciting at times is a bigger turn on, so that is what I will continue to try to give.
This story involves a girl from one of my previous stories. You can check that out here https://redd.it/3p5z96 To recap a little here is an intro taken from the other story that will tell you about Anna: “I had been friends with this girl Anna for about 3 years, but we never had any kind of romantic/sexual relationship at all. I originally met her through a girl my friend was hooking up with. Through hanging out with mutual friends we became friends. She was a really funny girl and had a twisted sense of humor, so I always really enjoyed hanging around her. Our relationship was weird, because everyone always thought we were dating whenever they would meet us since we got along so well. We had never even come close to hooking up at any point though. It just never felt right and we just enjoyed being silly with each other way more and sort of in an unspoken way didn’t want to complicate things. I had definitely fantasized from time to time about having sex with Anna though. She was an attractive girl, about 5’5” brown hair, skinny/athletic, B cup tits, perky ass and she looks kind of like Lizzy Caplan. When she was in her late teens she went through a really promiscuous phase from what she told me and slept with quite a few guys. That was a few years before I knew her, but she said she decided that wasn’t the lifestyle she wanted. She was a college graduate now and had a good job at a bank so I guess she decided she needed to mature.”
As I said at the end of that story Anna and I started dating not long after the threesome with her friend happened (from that story). We dated for about a year and had a pretty great sex life. We were both very open minded and sexual people, so it resulted in a lot of fun. We had been dating for about eight months when this story happened.
Throughout the course of us dating Anna would always joke that I owed her since I got to have a threesome with her and her friend. I would joke back and say that we weren’t dating back then, so I didn’t owe her anything. I said that she was the one that decided to join in and that I didn’t ask her to. The joking was all in good fun, but she would say that she should get to hookup with one of my friends and me. This was always said in a joking manner, but I kind of knew she would be into it. Like I said, she was very open sexually and she had made it clear before that being with more than one guy was a turn on for her.
We talked very openly about our sexual pasts also. It was kind of hard not to since we already did when we were friends. Once we were in a relationship we pretty much knew everything the other had done. We talked before about what sexual experiences from the past turned us on the most. She told me that her biggest turn on was one time when she gave a guy a blowjob at a party and then about twenty minutes later went home and had sex with her “friend with benefits.” She said that it turned her on like crazy knowing that she had hooked up with them both so close together. I know this will sound selfish, but I never knew exactly how I felt about having my girlfriend hookup with another guy. I’ve had mff threesomes with girls I’ve dated, so it seems that I should be cool with mfm but it wasn’t that cut and dried in my head. I think it was more of a control issue than anything for me. I like to be in control and I thought maybe I would lose a little bit of control by allowing another guy into the equation. It didn’t bother me to be the other guy being added to a couple, but as part of the couple it was a weird thought for me. It may seem like I was splitting hairs, but it made sense to me. Like I said, these conversations always happened in a teasing sort of way and she never pressed the issue. It was something I always kept in the back of mind as a possibility if the correct situation ever arose though.
So, fast-forward to eight months into our relationship. My friend from college Mike was coming into town. We were pretty close my junior year and hung out pretty much every day. He was a really fun guy to hangout with and was always the life of the party. He was a big athletic guy, about 6’2” muscular, brown hair, girls loved him, and he played baseball for the school. We were opposites in many ways, but we found common ground in our love for women. Our mission every weekend was to try to drag girls home from the college bars and get as drunk as possible. He was a year older than me, so he graduated after my junior year and got a job in another state. I was pretty disappointed that he was moving away, but the job offer was great so I couldn’t blame him. Going out to bars wasn’t quite as fun without him, but I survived.
It had been a few years since I finished undergrad and I was now living out of state as well. I was closer to where Mike was living though, so Mike would come in town and visit about once every six months or so. He would normally stay with me and we’d just hangout, party, and try to pull girls the whole time he was there. Once I started dating Anna we still partied when he came in town, but obviously I wasn’t trying to pull girls with him.
He and Anna met initially when Anna and I were just friends. We were all in a big group hanging out and Mike mentioned to me that he thought my friend Anna was hot. At the time I told him he should go for it, but nothing ended up happening. He met another girl that night that he was trying to chase, so he was distracted.
By the next time Mike came into town Anna and I had been dating for about two months. He was surprised that we were dating and would joke with me that he should have gone after her that night. We all hung out together and had a good time. Anna would joke with him and say things like, “you bringing any girls home tonight stud?” She knew his reputation, as a bit of a ladies man and thought it was funny to tease him. She would try to find girls for him to hook up with and he actually hooked up with the girl Molly, from my first story about Anna, one time when he visited.
When he came to visit the next time Anna and I were eight months into our relationship. He was staying for four days this time. The first couple of days were fun and wild as always. The third night Mike, Anna, a couple of other friends, and I went out to a bar. We had a good night and got drunk and all that good stuff. The three of us got back to my apartment and talked for a bit and then headed to bed.
Anna and I got up about thirty minutes after lying down, because she was hungry and I wanted some water. We got out of bed, Anna in her panties and a tank top and me in my boxer-briefs. We were in the kitchen for a minute and I started kissing her and grabbing her ass. I felt too drunk to have sex before, but after lying down for thirty minutes I was feeling a little friskier.
We were making out and I had two handfuls of her ass when Mike walked around the corner in his boxer-briefs. She was facing away from him, so he got a perfect view of my hands all over her ass. He just started laughing and said, “whhhooaaa, so sorry to interrupt.” He didn’t give a shit though. Like I said, he was not shy and we had seen each other do far worse with girls in the past. He walked into the kitchen to get a glass of water and slapped Anna’s ass with the back of his hand on the way by and teasing her said, “Owww!” We all laughed, even Anna, and Anna said, “Mike I am going to kick your ass.” Mike said, “don’t tease me.” Anna laughed and said, “whatever.” When Mike walked back by us Anna slapped his ass with the back of her hand. Mike responded, “I like it!” and walked back into the guest bedroom.
Anna and I went back to bed and had sex. She was always into sex, but she seemed especially into it that night. She was going crazy and seemed extremely turned on. I thought about it and wondered if it was because of the interaction she had with Mike in the kitchen. I almost asked her, but didn’t want to put her in a weird position where she thought I was jealous or something. Strangely, I wasn’t jealous about their interaction at all. It was kind of hot seeing another guy flirt with her. I didn’t feel a loss of control, because I knew Mike. It was a turn on to me that he finds my girlfriend attractive just like I do. As I was falling asleep that night I started toying with the idea of fulfilling Anna’s request to pay her back by having a mfm threesome. By the next morning I had pretty much decided that I wasn’t going to instigate anything too heavily, but if something happened I definitely wouldn’t stop it.
It was Mike’s last night in town, so we were going out to eat at a pretty nice restaurant and a cocktail bar afterwards. It was just Mike, Anna, our friend Greg, and I. Throughout the night I felt like Mike was being flirtatious with Anna, but I think it might have all been in my head because of the night before. When I really thought about it he was always a little flirtatious with girls in general. That’s just the way he was. We stayed at the bar until closing time and then headed home.
By the time we got to the apartment I was fairly determined to make this happen somehow. We were all pretty drunk, but not drunk enough to make decisions we would regret or anything. I felt pretty comfortable with whatever was going to happen. I knew Mike would go along with it if I told him, but I really wanted it to happen more naturally than that. When we walked in Mike headed to the balcony to make a phone call. I didn’t really know what I was going to do, but I figured I would just wing it.
Anna walked into the living room and turned on the TV. I went to the kitchen to get a glass of water. Anna walked into the kitchen where we were talked for a minute. I leaned in and gave her a kiss. We started kissing more until we were making out. Anna had on a skirt and I placed one of my hands on her ass. I slid her skirt up a little to where half of my hand was on her skirt and the other half was on her panties. She looked at me and said my name kind of like, “mike is right there on the balcony.” I just smiled and she didn’t show any resistance after that.
By the time Mike walked in her skirt was completely pulled up over her ass. We were still making out and both of my hands were groping her ass. When Mike walked in and noticed us in the kitchen he said another, “whhooa don’t mind me” and laughed. He walked through the living room and said, “I’ll just head to my room, no worries” and laughed again. As he was walking through Anna clenched me tighter and kissed me harder. It seemed like she was turned on knowing he was walking through and looking at her ass. As he walked by I shot him a look as if to tell him to come here. He stopped and kind of looked at me and mouthed, “really?” I kissed on the side of her neck and nodded yes at him.
It was tense for a moment, because Anna was facing away from him and couldn’t see what was going on. I was afraid she might be startled or freaked out if he came up behind her. I had a slight moment of panic as I started wondering if maybe I misread everything and she wouldn’t be cool with something like this. Mike walked up behind her and grabbed her ass with one of his hands. She immediately knew it wasn’t my hand, because one of mine was on the side of her face and the other was on her side. She instantly tensed up a little and just looked at me sort of wide eyed like, “is this cool?” I just looked back at her and kissed her deep and hard. She knew everything was cool after that.
Mike continued fondling her ass and eventually slid her panties to the side. He started rubbing her pussy from behind with his fingers and then slid one of them in. She let out a moan and said, “oh fuck.” I kissed down her neck as he continued to finger her from behind. I lifted her shirt up over her head and undid her bra. I teased and licked her nipples. Mike reached around with his free hand and rubbed one of her tits and caressed her nipple with his fingers. I was really turned on by everything that was happening and was having no regrets.
We walked her over to the couch and I sat down and I told Mike to sit beside me. I dropped my pants and underwear and Anna dropped to her knees and licked up the side of my cock. Mike started undoing his pants and dropped them and his underwear as she was taking my cock in her mouth. His cock was out in the open now and rock hard. He was a little smaller than me (I’m 8 inches), but still big (7 inches or so). She took his cock in her hand and stroked it as she sucked mine quickly up and down.
After a few moments she switched and engulfed Mike’s cock with her mouth. She was now stroking mine with her hand and she started moaning as she sucked his cock. She seemed so turned on sucking another’s guy’s cock while I was sitting there watching. She released his cock from her mouth gasping for air with drool running down her chin. She licked down his cock and started licking and sucking on his balls as she continued to stroke my cock. After a few minutes of sucking his cock she got up and straddled him. My girlfriend was about to take another guy’s cock inside of her and I was extremely turned on. He positioned his cock up against her pussy and she slid down on it. She started bouncing up and down on it wildly. He grabbed her ass and slammed her up and down on his cock. I was sitting there just watching for a few minutes wanting to take it all in. She motioned for me to stand up, so I stood up on the couch and she turned her head to the side and took my cock in her mouth. I’ve never felt a girl suck so intensely on my cock. I could tell she was more turned on than she has ever been. This was the first time she had ever had two cocks in her at the same time and I could tell she loved it.
After a while the couch wasn’t too comfortable, so we headed to my bedroom. Anna got on the bed and immediately got on all fours. I positioned myself behind her and slid my cock in her pussy. Mike got on the other side of her and she took his cock in her mouth. We started pounding her from both ends. We got in a perfect rhythm for a while where he was slamming his cock in and out of her mouth making her gag slightly as his cock hit the back of her throat just as my hips slammed into her ass. She was moaning and screaming as much as she could with his cock in her mouth. I started fingering her ass while I was fucking her from behind. I had no idea if anal would be in play at all that night. She liked anal and liked having her ass played with, but we had only successfully had anal sex maybe five or six times. My size was a problem and it would often be too painful for her, but when she was drunk she was better able to handle it and enjoy it. She began moaning even louder when I started fingering her ass. I could tell that she was turned on enough that she was up for anything.
After a few minutes I swapped out with Mike and Anna started sucking my cock again. Mike got behind her and started licking her pussy from behind. She pushed back hard against his face and rubbed her clit. She lowered her hips slightly, making it clear she wanted him to lick her ass. He started licking her asshole as he rubbed her clit. She was going crazy and eventually began shaking and came. He got up behind her and slid his cock in her pussy from behind. He was fucking her nice and slow and fingering her ass as he did it. She was slowly taking my cock in and out of her mouth.
I reached in the drawer of the table beside the bed and tossed him some lube. He started spreading it on her asshole and then slid his cock out of her pussy and pressed it against her ass. The head of his cock slid in and she let out a moan of pleasure. She had my cock in her hand as this was happening. He slid in further and she let out an, “oh god!” He started slowly moving back and forth in and out of her ass. She took my cock back in her mouth and he picked up the pace. He eventually was going pretty hard in and out of her. I guess the combination of being drunk, his cock being a little smaller than mine, and being really turned on increased her pain tolerance. Mike started losing control and began letting out loud moans as he started shooting his load in Anna’s ass. She took my cock out of her mouth and moaned loudly as he did this.
She continued sucking my cock and I’m sure his cum was running out of her ass, but I couldn’t see. Mike just lay there on the bed behind her watching us. I could only hold out for another minute or so and I started shooting streams of cum into her mouth. She fell back onto the bed with a huge smile on her face. She said, “holy shit.” She breathed heavily some more and started to say something, but stopped. She looked a little embarrassed and a little in shock. Mike stood up a few moments later, squeezed her hand, and said he’d see us in the morning and headed to bed.
We passed out pretty quickly after that and didn’t really talk about what happened. When we woke up the next morning she asked if I was cool with everything that happened. I told her I was and I asked her if she was cool with it? She blushed a little and said she was and that she had a really good time. She thanked me for doing that and said, “now you don’t owe me anymore” and laughed.
I wondered if I would wake up the next day and be pissed or jealous, but I wasn’t at all. I just saw it as hot sex and a really pleasing experience for my girlfriend. I didn’t feel in any way that she “liked” Mike now or anything like that. We dated for about four more months, but never had another mfm threesome. It was one of those things that just needed to happen naturally with the right person. By the time Mike came in town next we weren’t together anymore or it probably would have happened again I would think.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3xelae/im_back_threesome_with_a_girl_from_a_previous
What happened between you two? Did she ever hook up with Mike again?