This was back when I was 19 and in college. I had a best friend Jim, and we spent most of our time hanging out. One of us would get our hands on a bottle of booze, and we would stay up all night drinking and playing video games. Basically, your typical nerds. We knew we were geeks and we didn't really care; we were having the time of our lives in college staying up late, eating pizza three times a day, drinking lots of liquor, and trying to meet girls. We weren't so good at that last part, though. Both of us were virgins when we got to college and didn't really know much about flirting, dating, or sex. We both eventually met some understanding girls and got the first time out of the way, though. We also decided to make a "secret society" after reading about Skulls and Crossbones because we thought it was cool. We never wound up doing anything with it but for a while we thought it was really bad ass that we started a secret club, even if it only had two members and never did anything. Like I said, nerds. However, we had a few things going for us. For one, we were both in decent shape. We didn't work out or anything, but we were both tall and blessed with fast metabolisms so the pizza and laziness hadn't done any damage yet. We also both happened to be really good at talking to people. Jim had actually studied social engineering through a book or a website or something. So nerds, yes, but not your stereotypical "neckbeards".
One night we were sitting around Jim's dorm doing our usual routine — drinking and playing video games. The only difference was that Jim's friend, Diane, was hanging out with us. She had started hanging out with Jim recently and I suspected that she was the one who had taken his virginity a couple weeks before (he later confirmed this). At the time, however, he denied it because she had a boyfriend. Still, she would come hang out into the early hours of the morning just watching movies with us or occasionally trying her hand at Wii Tennis. She wasn't someone who would turn heads on the street, but she wasn't unattractive, either. Probably about 5'7", 120 lbs. with dirty blonde hair in a pixie cut and small breasts.
I've always been one who liked to try and get people to open up and talk about sex. I don't know why, just something about it turns me on. It's like they were strangers a couple hours ago, but now they're divulging these secrets to me about very intimate parts of their lives. Maybe it's a power thing; I don't know. So I started prodding her in front of Jim, and I found out that she was very open sexually. She admitted to liking hentai (something that, despite my nerdy tendencies, never really did anything for me). We stayed on that topic of conversation for a little while, and then I decided to push it a little bit further. I said, "Since you're in to the Asian-style porn stuff, that must mean that you like bukkake, right?" She laughed and gave a noncommittal answer, but made it clear that she knew exactly what I was talking about. I filed that one away for later.
Later that night Jim and I mentioned something about our "secret club". Wanting to add to the mystique of it all, I made a big scene of shutting him up since "Diane is right here." She took the bait and immediately started asking what we were talking about, and I played along, telling her she should forget we said anything and that we're not allowed to talk about it. She of course wouldn't let it go, and after another hour of playing coy and a couple more rounds of drinks, I decided to take the lead. I explained to her, "Listen, Jim and I are in a secret society on campus. We're really not supposed to talk about it to other people. We can both get kicked out if we do. However, there is a way we can talk with outsiders about it. They have to be initiated, and even then they aren't part of the society, but they're at least allowed to talk about it with us." Jim played along and confirmed everything I said. So, of course, she asks how to get initiated. At that point I went for broke, looked her in the eyes, and said, "You have to suck both of our dicks." She giggled a little bit and tried to play it off, but she was interested. After some more "You've got to be kidding"s and another round of drinks, we finally told her it was now or never. She both of us in the eyes, then got up and walked back to Jim's bedroom.
We both followed, and she was already taking off her shirt by the time we got in there. "You're supposed to take your bra off, too," I said, figuring I couldn't strike out at this point. She said that she wouldn't go that far, which I thought was funny, but everyone has their limits, so he bra stayed on. Jim was a little nervous so I broke the ice and pulled my cock out through my fly. At this point I was already semi-hard, and she immediately started sucking on me. It took me no time at all to get completely erect. She sucked my cock for about a minute, then turned to Jim who had taken his dick out of his pants by now, too. She did a pretty good job of stroking the person who wasn't being sucked, and switching off every 30 minutes or so. Part way in to it, I remembered our talk about bukkake earlier, and how she seemed low key into it. So while she was sucking me and jerking off Jim, I said, "To finish the initiation, you have to let us both cum on your face. Those are the rules." I was expecting her to fake opposition since that seemed to be here MO, but she moaned approval, then pulled her mouth off of my dick and started jerking us both at the same time. She squeezed a little bit tighter and started jerking faster; I could tell she was going for the finish now. Jim and I were a little awkward since we had never seen each other's junk, but I was really hoping we could both finish at the same time. I looked at him and raised my eyebrows, silently asking if he was ready. He nodded and we both turned our attention to the eager woman on her knees in front of us.
It didn't take long — she obviously knew how to handle a cock — before I was feeling the edge approaching. I think Jim was still nervous and caught up in his own head, but I didn't care; I had no problem being the first to cum. I warned her and she closed her eyes and turned her head a little towards me. I usually dribble, not shoot, except when I'm really turned on. I was pretty damn turned on so I figured the first shot would have some force behind it, and I was right. I shot up and hit her on the cheek and continued up to her closed eye. I took a step forward since I figured the rest would ooze out, and sure enough, I started dribbling cum down her nose and the right side of her face. This apparently was enough to set Jim off and he started shooting on the left half of her face. Unlike me, he could actually shoot, so all of his strands of cum hit her face with some force. By the time we were both done, she had pretty impressive coverage on both halves of her face. She actually stuck out her tongue and tasted a little bit, which turned me on almost enough to be ready to go again, but then she cleaned the rest off with a towel. Afterwards we all sat down and Jim and I let her in on a few of the plans of this secret society. Of course, none of the plans actually came to fruition, but she didn't have to know that.
The best part was that we repeated this scene probably 5 or 6 more times over the course of a month. We told her that since she wasn't fully initiated, she had to go through that each time she wanted to talk about the society. She wasn't stupid and I'm sure she knew what was up, but it gave her an excuse to act a little slutty without having to feel like she was just allowing guys to cum on her face for nothing. Plus, I really think that she liked having her face covered in cum. We talked a couple times about going further, but never acted on it; I had only slept with one other girl and honestly I was nervous about having a threesome, and I think Jim was starting to have feelings for her. After about a month she started saying she wanted "full membership" so she didn't have to repeat that process every time. Jim and I both knew that it couldn't last forever, so we made her a full member right at the same time that we realized our secret club didn't actually do anything and it fizzled out. Jim and Diane actually ended up dating — something I warned Jim about, since she was cheating on her boyfriend the entire time we were fooling around with her. But he was blinded by her and wholeheartedly believed that she wouldn't cheat on him the same way. They were actually pretty happy dating for 6 months or so before she started acting really suspiciously. I told Jim that she was probably running around behind his back, which he didn't take kindly to, but eventually he caught her in the act and they cut it off.
It was a fun month, though.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3ui83n/initiating_her_in_to_our_club_mfm
Did she ever take her bra off?
Nope. She always maintained that that was "too far."
This is wrong.
Love this