Posted 3 of our successful conquest but as most things in life, it's not all good and along the way, we had a couple failures, this being the one we remember most. So it was about two years ago, we had a couple 3 ways under our belt and CL was our go to spot at times. The month was October, so we decided to post a Halloween theme ad, a few hours pass and we get a hit from a fairly sexy first timer, she responded with shy witch in the subject. She was drinking at her place and stumble across our ad, wanting to live out this fantasy, and get DP. I was in bed already, fairly early at 10pm on a Sunday. But we messaged enough to get an invite over, she was a good 30mins from us, but sent pics and voice verified. Anyways, she wanted some Jack Daniels, and for us to be there soon. I pick up my buddy and we head out, now this was the first time a woman had offered to host. We were very nervous at this time, not knowing what to expect, since we heard of robberies and at times murders from online meet ups. We get there, and we noticed an ok area, and her apartment, it seemed safe, but we still had our reservations. She comes out to meet us, my buddy going first, as I parked, we had discussed if who would scout the actual room and give clear, me being in the car in case we needed a quick get away. I know, super paranoid, young and still inexperienced to the online hook ups. He gave the clear, and I went in, we talked and that's when I remember I had forgotten the Jack, kick in the ass for that. We keep talking and she mentions, that there's a liquor right next to the apartments, dumbass us, both of us go, buy the Jack, when she messages us that she is no longer interested. Ugh!!! We tried calling her and knocking, to no success. We kicked ourselves so hard that night and at times still remember the one who got away, even thou we more than made up for it. Too describe her, she was about 5'3 nice moderately fit body, upper 30s, wearing a short skirt, fuck me boots, and a blouse, white girl with autumn hair.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3rzbs6/tag_teaming_mmf_our_failures_the_witch_that_got