First orgy that ended with a broken dick. You’ve been warned (MFMFMF)

For the first time ever I have managed to get together with a girl who seems to be just as sexually explorative as myself. To be honest it's a breath of fresh air. No more "trying to figure out the best way to bring it up" kind of stuff. Just full on "I like this" what about you. No judgment, other than a bit of laughing when I showed up in my man thong… and lots of communication.

So after our first time having a MFF which I fucked up massively and only fucked the other girl (yes our swinging stories end in disaster more often than not but it doesn't stop us) we decided to try to start swapping with other couples. The first time was a bit of a big bust. We met this couple on CL and they seemed pretty cool. We got to the club and my girl (let's call her Gerty cause it makes me laugh) decides that to calm her nerves she was going to drink and ended up throwing up all over the place. We ended the night with no sex and laughing in the parking lot of a swingers club just the two of us. Probably one of my favourite times in our relationship.

So we decided a round two was in order. We got the same couple and went back to the club like a month later. We pre drank and moderated ourselves this time and while we where at the swingers club met friends of theirs who used to own the place. Coles notes the conversation, the couple we showed up with (We’ll call them Cornelius and Carolina) and their couple friend (Beatrice and Bob) split me and Gerty up to flirt and start convo. The conversation I had with Carolina and Beatrice was basically all about Carolina's wedding plans and everything other than that she would not respond too. It became really clear that Carolina was not into the life style. Cornelius, Bob and Gerty however where laughing and having a really good time.

I'm just going to take this time to describe every one in more details. My girl Gerty is probably one of the hottest girls I've dated. 5'6", dark hair and features, late 20s and nice breast 34D. She works out religiously and is FUCKEN SEXY as hell. She is lazered down there and smooth like a babies ass. BEST ass I've ever been able to touch without a restraining order/pissed off bouncer.

Carolina is about 5'8" blond hair, blue eyes early 30s. Cute girl with lots of sexy curves and MASSIVE really nice natural boobs. Think 36DD.

Beatrice is 5'9", mid to late 40s with big fake tits. Really hot for her age and a really nice pussy.

Cornelius is like a taller version of Johnny Depp with a longer face. Mid 30s and good physic. Pretty decent size dick on himself at 7"

Bob is like mid 50s in decent shape, grey hair with a bit of a belly on him. Not really well endowed 5" max.

I'm 6'3" late 20s, thin build. I get called TDH a lot and have a 7" uncut cock to my name.

Ok so we end the conversation and move to the back room. Because Bob and Beatrice used to own the club we get the VIP room. We go up and all get undressed. We start with playing with each others partners. It's me and Carolina, Gerty and Bob, Cornelius and Beatrice. Lots of kissing and rubbing. I'm going to town on Carolinas tits cause they are massive. Just flicking the nipples with my tongue and sucking on them really hard. They are pretty much perfect. I slowly make my way down her stomach and start rubbing her clit. The entire time she is quiet and pretty much starfishes hard. Fuck it I think, I'm going to eat her out till she screams. I make my ways down and replace my finger with the tip of my tongue. Lightly I tease it and I get a twitch. I'm going to make you cum hard is all that is going through my mind. I tickle it for a good 30 seconds before I can feel the heat coming off of her pussy. I slowly descend further and start using the tip of my tongue to grab and rub her labia. She is starting to moan at this point. Fuck yeah. I slowly start to prod deeper into her folds with my tongue mixing my spit with her flowing juices. I move my thumb up and start to play with her clit and move in further with my tongue.

As I'm doing this I look up to get a view of what is going on and all the girls at this time are being eaten out by the men. It's a pretty hot scene. Lots of moaning. Gerty has bob right between her thighs. He's going to town and she is moaning like she does. I kind of have a thing for older guys with younger girls so this is getting me rock hard. I can feel my thick cock pressing up against the giant bed we are all sharing. I position myself so that my cock starts to touch Carolinas leg. It's like free advertising… that shit is hard and wouldn't mind a little priming. She gets the hint and reaches down and grabs my throbbing member. It's kind of nice but she's being a bit rough. My cock being uncircumcised needs a bit of TLC or lube and she just doesn't seem to get that. I truck on forwards and keep eating her out as deep as I can while thumbing her clit. Clearly it's driving her wild. As she's destroying my cock with her grip and lack of lube I decided to distract her with a one two clit lick and finger blast. With my tongue still deep her in I put a finger in and start fingering her soaking wet pussy as I continue to prod her with my tongue. Her hand instantly let's go of my cock and grabs my hand and pulls it away. I continue to eat her out and laugh saying "Too much?" No response. I keep eating her out and she is moaning like a nun discovering a detachable shower head. I figure at this point that I can now proceed. WRONG. I put my finger into her slit and immediately get it pulled away.

I look over and see Gerty now sucking on Bobs little dick. I feel bad for the guy for having such a small member, especially when me and Cornelius are at full attention with a pair of nice 7” cocks. As I’m looking I see Bob close his eyes and say “I’m going to cum” Gerty just picks up the pace like a trooper and Bob let’s out a couple of moans. I see a small amount of cum dribble down her chin. That old dude just came in my girls mouth. I instantly get harder.

I keep eating Carolina out for 30 seconds and at that point came to the conclusion that this was not her thing to be shared with a lot of people. My girl on the other hand loves eating out other girls. I get up on my knees and look at her and motion for her to take my place. Bob is now going to town eating her out so she taps him on his head and says “I want to eat that pussy” he smiles and let’s her go. Carolina is still causing friction burn on my cock which at this point is just getting softer with every stroke. Gerty smiles at me all coy like and moves over to position herself doggy style with her head between Carolinas legs. She goes down on her taking big laps like a dog finding a bowl of water after a week in the desert. Nice long big licks. She looks up and makes eye contact with me as she is eating out this woman. Bob looks at me and asks “Do you mind if I fuck her.” My mind is racing at this point. I always wanted to watch an older guy fuck my girl. This was my chance.

“For sure, just make it as rough as you can, she loves that” is my response. He smiles and reaches over for a condom. He put’s it on and positions his little cock between Gerty’s beautiful love slits. He rubs it up and down getting it ready for his modest load. Gerty is still looking at me as she is pushing her tongue further and further into Carolinas cunt. Bob all of a sudden pushes in and Gerty let’s out a moan with the word “FUCK”. Bob starts to pump nice and slowly… not really big pumps but there isn’t really much travel necessary. His facial expression is one of pure joy. Here this mid 50s guy is fucking a incredibly hot late 20s girl in front of her man while she eats out another girl. I’m loving every moment of this. I only wish that he was not wearing a condom so that he could fill her up… I’ve always dreamed of shoving my hard cock into my girl after it’s been filled with another man’s cum. I feel a new hand on my cock. It’s Beatrice. Cornelius was over with his hard cock in Carolinas mouth and she was sucking him. He did have a nice cock and of course she seemed to be more confortable with him in her mouth. Beatrice looks me in the eye and says “that is a nice cock.” “Thanks I made it myself” I threw back at her. She sticks her tongue in my mouth and all I can think about was how many cocks she’s sucked on already. “Fuck it…” I think and I start making out with her furiously. I’m going to start a new paragraph now as this is where shit gets bad.

So here is the situation. Bob is fucking my girl Gerty, Gerty is eating out Carolina with the fury of a thousand suns, Carolina is sucking on Cornelius’s hard cock, and me and Beatrice are off alone making out like high school kids. Like I said for a 40 year old she was really hot. I thought she would have had this sex thing down at this point but boy was I wrong. She’s being incredibly aggressive with my cock at this point, which is harder than most times. As she pulls it with no lube it starts to hurt and then in one fluid motion she pulls down really hard and I feel a fucken ripping sensation. As I’ve done this before I knew it in that instant that the fucken cougar ripped my frenulum. For those who don’t know a frenulum is the piece of skin that connects the foreskin to the tip of the penis. My eyes go wide and I pull her hand off my cock. I look at her and ask “Where is the bathroom I have to piss.” At this point I know that my cock is about 15 seconds away from realizing it has a fucken split in it and start gushing blood like a slasher movie. I grab a towel wrap it around my waste and b-line it to the washroom. Din’t want to ruin every ones night.

I get in the washroom and sit on the toilet. I’m fucken pissed. I now have a broken dick and it’s bleeding every where. I pull back the skin to see WTF happened and how deep it is. I start wiping away blood with toilet paper and see how deep the cut is. It’s ALL THE WAY DOWN. I’m more pissed. I have that rage-y almost going to cry thing going on. Get your shit together man. I go to the entrance to the fucking area where there is a desk. I asked them for rubbing alcohol. I need to decontaminate this cock like it’s going out of style. Back to the washroom. I pull back the foreskin and bath that shit in alcohol. I challenge any one to give that a try and not to scream. I’m looking at myself in the mirror. A broken man with a broken dick holding the biggest scream possible in as his cock screams in pain. I say to myself “pain or lose the dick.” I should probably point out there still was a bit of consumption of alcohol so reasoning was not kicking in at this point. Disinfected… check. Let’s wrap this up. I grab a bunch of toilet paper and wrap that shit up. I take a condom and put it over it. Time to quarantine.

20 minutes after I left the orgy I return. Fuck I need an excuse. I site on the sex chair in the corner and watch. What’s wrong Beatrice asks. “I had a long day forgot to eat and think I ate too much” I say. “You guys keep going I’m going to relax here.” Beatrice looks at me and says “You sure you don’t want to fuck me” as she climbs onto my lap. “I don’t think you’ll think it’s sexy if I throw up on you” I reply. “She gives me a kiss and says “ok but you owe me” and throws me a wink. If only you fucken knew is all that comes to my mind.

So I sit there and I watch Cornelius fucking Carolina while Gerty gets fucked by Bob while eating out Beatrice. I was turned on and in pain all at the same time. I want to have a hard on. I wanted to wait for Bob to be done and go remind Gerty what a real sized cock feels like. I wanted to bend Beatrice over and fuck her till she came all over my cock. So much things I wanted to do as I sat in the chair thinking about my now broken cock. I also was a big fan of the impromptu cuckolding that was happening. As I was thinking about that Bob starts to close his eyes and moan. I know he is shooting his load into my girl… all be it into a condom. They finish up and Gerty comes over to me. She says “I’m sorry you’re not feeling well” as she gives me a kiss. I can almost taste the cum on her lips still. I lean into her and whisper into her ear what happened. Her eyes are go wide and she lips “No was” back to me. I nod to her and in that instant Bob interrupts us.

“We should get together again” he chimes to us. Give me your number. We exchange numbers and he leaves. Carolina and Cornelius are still going at it on the bed. I’m watching him slam his member in and out of Carolina. “Why didn’t you fuck him?” I ask Gerty. “I don’t think Carolina would handle it well”

We go downstairs and start to get dressed. I open the towel and reveal the blood stains dripping down on the inside. Gerty looks at me and gives me another kiss. “Ok enough of that I can taste the cum” I toss back at her. She looks down in discuss. “I can’t believe I let him fuck me” She says… that just gets me turned on more. A week later we are home and I get a text.

Hey there it’s Bob. Had a great time last week. We should get together soon. Beatrice has been wanting to fuck you all week.

FIN

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3rnju7/first_orgy_that_ended_with_a_broken_dick_youve