[First FMM] How I ended up with a cock in my ass and another in my mouth. ;)

This is the first story I’m posting after getting turned on to this sub by a special redditor ;) So let me know what you think!

This is the story of my first MMF threesome…it took place last November when Evan, Josh, and I were all 20. I’m a really short bisexual brunette, but a softball player too so I’m pretty toned throughout. I’m also a bit of a freak sexually, and that was common knowledge for Evan and Josh even before this. They’re two good friends of mine, and each other’s roommates at the time of the story. I met them freshman year and we’ve been drinking/watching football buddies ever since. This particular night was rainy and I should have known that getting wet on the walk over was a sign of things to come. Let’s begin… ;)

I walk across the street in awkward steps, holding an umbrella and trying to avoid puddles as I come up to Josh’s apartment. He buzzes me in and I take the elevator up to the third floor apartment where Josh greets me and lets me into his apartment.

“Hey Maddie, what’s up?” Evan calls out from the couch, already with a beer in hand.

“Hey Evan. Nothing much, just trying to stay dry haha. You?” I take off my boots and rain jacket to reveal a simple green V-neck tee and black leggings. Josh hands me a beer and we join Evan on the couch.

“Nothing much either. Just killing the J-Man here in Madden,” Evan laughs as we sit down. I look at the TV and see that Evan and Josh are just finishing a video game, with Evan winning 38-14.

“Shut the fuck up Evan,” Josh hollers back, “Try running something other than Y-Stick and see how many first downs you get.” I sit back and chuckle to myself, drinking my beer as they play out the rest of the game. This is normal banter between them and it’s pretty entertaining to me. The clever insults guys will throw on each other during video games never cease to be amusing.

“Goddamn, this cornerback is just having a wank on field during the play, what kinda bullshit is that??” Josh groans as Evan takes the ball sixty yards for a touchdown on the final of the game. They both set the controllers and Evan smirks, flipping off Josh as he turns off the console.

“Sooo Maddie, I bet this is exactly how you wanted to spend your Friday night,” Evan laughs, sitting back and taking a swig of beer as the guys take notice of me again.

“Yeah I just thought I’d drop by and show off my skills,” I say sarcastically, knowing I’m god-awful at sports video games.

“Haha yeah I bet,” Josh laughs, “But no Conner (my FWB at the time) tonight? That makes us 0-2 tonight…Evan got turned down by Natalie too,” he says, sticking his tongue out at Evan.

I chuckle softly and look at Evan. Natalie’s a curvy blonde that Evan’s been chasing for a while and apparently she had plans for the night that didn’t include him. Conner was out of town for the weekend and after a busy week I was just looking for a chill night with a couple fun dudes.

The three of us go through two rounds of beers together while watching Sportscenter and just chitchatting about the week and such. Josh, naturally the most talkative of the three, carries the conversation while Evan and I add in occasionally, mostly teasing Josh about his lackluster grades and new gym routine that has been very much hyped up by him, but is yet to show any real results.

“Josh, what’s in your groundbreaking protein shake this week?” I say, sticking my tongue out playfully at him. Being a college softball player, I’ve teased him a lot about his athletic shortcomings and how I’ll always be tougher than him, but secretly, I’ve always thought he has a fantastic body. His arms and legs are slim, but very toned, and the few times I’ve seen him without a shirt I’ve been quite impressed by his abs. Now wearing jeans and a t-shirt, my eyes linger on his body a few times as we talk.

Eventually the conversation lulls and we start a third round of beers. I’m feeling just a small buzz and a little warmth on the inside as I relax on the couch. Our chitchat picks up again and now I’m gazing a little longer on Evan. Must be the alcohol getting me hot. Evan’s considerably bigger than Josh; he played tight end in high school football so he’s got a bigger build but can still move gracefully. I’d only know because I may have been checking him out when we played basketball together once. Heheh.

“So Evan…” I say light-heartedly, “Got turned down by Natalie, huh? What’s the sorority queen up to tonight?”

Evan jokingly pouts at me, knowing I like to be in the know on all his girl affairs. “It’s Dad’s Weekend at Tri-Delt. So I didn’t get shot down,” he says, turning to Josh. “It’d be pretty fuckin’ weird if I was there.”

I shrug and am about to speak when Josh cuts in. “Okay whatever. But Maddie, we were discussing this before…how would you rate Nat out of ten?” he asks, knowing I’m bi and a frequent admirer of sorority girls, especially the ones in yoga pants.

“Hmmm…” I look at Evan and Josh and laugh a little. “I’d put her at an 8… cute face, not much butt, but a great rack.” Evan nods in agreement and Josh shakes his head.

“She’s like a low 7, let’s be real,” Josh says. “Maddie just says 8 ‘cause they’re both freaks haha.”

“Woah what does that mean?” I say back, jokingly acting like I’m going to smack him.

“Just kidding haha,” Josh laughs, flinching a little. “Natalie low key gets passed around though…and loves to take it up the butt,” he continues, looking at Evan as he teases him about his crush.

I turn and look at Evan to see that he’s blush a little and has no response. Feeling the need to help a friend, and also feeling a bit intoxicated I blurt out, “Hey I love anal, lots of girls do.” I immediately turn red as I look to Evan and Josh and see them with wide eyes.

“Wait, wait hold up,” Josh says, clearly surprised by my admission that I love having my ass fucked. What do you mean, you love anal?”

I bite my lip, racking my brain to find a way out of this conversation. But subconsciously, I don’t want a way out. Being a bit of an exhibitionist and someone who just likes to talk about sex, part of me secretly wants to carry this on. I nervously look to Josh and Evan again and take a sip of beer. “It just feels really good,” I say, “What else do I need to explain?”

Josh shrugs and looks at me. “I mean nothing…just surprised me is all.” I sense a bit of nervousness in voice and wonder what he’s thinking. Is he turned on? He must be a little. I look to Evan and see the same expression on his face. Are they imagining what I’m like with a cock deep in my ass? With that thought, my fantasies immediately start churning and I think of the two guys taking turns on my ass. I think of how hot it would be for them to go back to their rooms tonight and jack off to me, and my tight ass.

“Do you do it often?” Josh asks with a little grin, now clearly trying to milk what he can out of the conversation.

“It’s not like a regular thing, but I do it occasionally,” I respond, now helplessly imagining what it’d be like to have Josh in my ass.

“Gotcha gotcha. I’ve never done it, but I would think it’d be painful for a tiny girl like you.”

Evan chimes in, “Well that’s why you lube up for it.” I turn and look at Evan. Now restless and feeling really warm, my mind is going crazy with fantasies of Evan and Josh. I gaze over their bodies, realizing that they’re probably noticing but too turned on to care.

“Yeah it takes a little prep but it’s not bad,” I say.

“Would you do it right now?” Josh asks, “I mean if it only takes a little prep, could you do it now if you wanted it.”

I feel my mouth drop open a bit as I look at Josh, feeling his ultra-curious stare on me. There’s no doubt now that he wants it. He wants my ass tonight. I pause for a second, feeling the wetness in my crotch and realizing how bad I want it too. “Yeah I suppose,” I say a bit softly, “Why do you ask?” I bite my lip and look at him, trying to give my best sex eyes.

“Oh I mean…I-I was just curious,” Josh says, trying to hold back some obvious excitement. “You uh…know, if you did want it we could go back to my bedroom. But that’d be a little awkward for Evan,” he says, trying to match my seductive tone while glancing over to Evan, who seems completely perplexed by what is unfolding.

Evan starts, “Oh um-“

But I interrupt, “Well if you’re behind me, then Evan could just go in front.” I check out the two guys for their reactions, already hot and bothered myself. They seem to be communicating with their eyes, sending rapid messages, trying to reach an agreement on what to do.

“Yeah I think we could make that work,” Evan says, sitting back with a smug grin. “Give Josh his first anal, it’d be a big milestone for him,” he chuckles.

Normally Josh would have a pillow to throw at Evan for that remark, but he’s far too excited to start anything like that with what’s unfolding. “So we wanna move back to the bedroom then,” he says with his wide eyes bouncing between Evan and I.

“Yeah let’s do it,” I say excitedly, popping up from the couch. My heart is pounding so fast now. Am I really about to get double-teamed by two of my best friends? When I stand up, I feel just how wet my panties are. Oh yes, and this is going to be fucking amazing.

The two guys get up with me, and Josh leads us back to his bedroom. Apparently his bed is more suited for what’s about to go down; I’m not sure how, but nothing is sticking in my mind right now because I’m so excited.

We all get into the bedroom and stand there awkwardly for a few seconds. I’m sure all three of us are wondering of something like this gets started. I bite my lip and then remember I need the anal lube from my purse. “Oh I gotta get my lube, one sec,” I say hurrying out to my purse and then back in with a small bottle.

“What are you guys waiting for?” I ask with a silly grin upon returning and seeing them both with all their clothes on still. “Get naked!” Josh takes off his shirt and starts undoing his pants while smiling at me. I come over and lay a kiss on him while he’s dropping his pants. My one hand rests on my shoulder and my other finds his cock as our kisses get heavy fast. “Mmm nice cock,” I say softly to Josh while stroking it gently and rubbing his balls. God he’s already so hard, and big!! Holy shit hehe.

“Yeah and you’ve got a nice ass,” Josh chuckles, “Are you getting naked too or do I have to bust right through those leggings?” He gives my butt a firm squeeze and step back now noticing Evan is naked too and stroking his thick cock for me.

I giggle and bend over, removing my leggings and black thong at once to reveal my smooth shaven pussy. I peek at the guys while my removing my top and bra and giggle. They could’ve told me they’d never seen a girl’s pussy before and I would’ve believed them.

“Okay you guys ready to have at me?” I ask with a little wink, getting on all fours on the bed and rubbing some lube on my tight, puckery asshole.

“I need some of that too?” Josh asks, getting up on the bed behind me.

“Mhmm, lather up,” I laugh, handing the bottle back and turning my attention to Evan. He comes to the side of the bed and I take his cock in my hand, stroking it and then licked up from the bottom of his ballsack to the tip of his throbbing head.

“Oh god, Maddie,” he groans, and I look up at him seductively, pumping his shaft gently and swirling my tongue around the top of his dick.

“Ok I’m good,” Josh says from behind me. I spread my ass a bit further and nod to him that I’m ready. Hope he likes the view.

Without another word, Josh presses his cock to my ass and begins sliding it in. “Mmmmmmmm,” I moan loudly, feeling my ass stretch and his hard cock begin to push in and out of me.

I take a quick glance back and then turn to Evan and take him in my mouth again. “God you’re so fucking tight,” Josh mutters as I press my lips around the cock in front of me and begin to suck deep, taking as much as I can. I work up and down Evan’s cock as Josh begins to fuck me harder, making me moan and gasp heavily.

“Ahhhhhh fuck yes,” I cry out, smacking my lips together as I come off of Evan for a moment. I look up to him and see so much lust and horniness. “Evan, just fuck my face,” I giggle, bringing a hand down to rub my clit now. “It’s too hard to do both haha.”

Evan just smiles and brushes a hair off my cheek before taking hold of the back of my head. I’m rubbing my clit faster now as having Josh in my ass is getting me unbelievably wet. “Unnnnnng fuuuck.” I hear Josh moaning louder now as Evan begins thrusting into my mouth. I take all of Evan’s cock, but not without it hitting the back of throat and not without my eyes welling up. I’m such a fucking whore, I think. Only a huge slut would enjoy taking two cocks and furiously finger her pussy at the same time.

Josh is fucking my ass even harder now, must be getting close already. It’s a little harder than I’d like now, but for his first time I’m impressed. After all, I would be giving him some directions if I weren’t gagging on another cock.

The moans and groans of the guys are getting me so hot as I’m having all three holes pleasured now. I can only imagine what they’re thinking right now.

Josh slides a finger along my slit as he pounds my ass. I can feel his cock tightening inside me as he thrusts into my ass. The sensation of both our fingers and his cock is nearly overwhelming and I’m letting out a mix of gasps, moans, and tiny whimpers on to Evan’s throbbing dick.

“Mmm Maddie you’re incredible,” Evan says, slowing down a bit, letting me run my tongue up and down his cock as it enters my mouth. I glance up at him and smile best I can, turned on even more by seeing how much he’s enjoying this.

“Oh fuck I’m gonna cum!” Josh suddenly exclaims as I feel his cock ready to explode now.

“Shoot in my ass,” I say quickly, pulling off of Evan to turn back to him.

Not a second later, Josh moans, “Holy shit, Maddie! Oh fuuuuck yessss…” I can feel his legs trembling against mine as he puts a big load deep in my ass. I put my head down for a second, panting as he pulls his thick wet cock out of my ass.

“Was that good?” I ask him, turning back and spanking myself playfully as I admire his cock and flushed-red, post-orgasm face.

“Ohhh yes,” he chuckles breathlessly; giving my butt a few spanks himself. “Now I think you’ve got another guy to finish off.”

I smirk and take Evan’s cock back in my hand, stroking it quickly and bringing my tongue under to lick the bottom of his cock and his balls. Josh stays behind me and keeps fingering my pussy, making me squirm and moan as I get Evan closer and closer to orgasm.

“Ohhh Maddie I’m so close,” Evan says, biting his lip and thrusting his hips out towards me.

I jerk him off even faster and rub my free hand on his abs, begging to him, “Cum for Evan…oh god I want it so bad.” I feel his cock aching to cum now and take it in my mouth again, sucking him off quickly and sloppily until he is ready to finish.

“Mmmmm I’m gonna cum,” he says heavily before shooting one, two, three thick shots of cum down my throat. I moan loudly as his cock twitches in my mouth and swallow every drop of cum I can before letting his cock slide out of me.

“Holy fuck you guys cum a lot,” I laugh, rolling over rubbing my face with Josh still fingering me. “Mmmmmmmm you guys gonna make me cum now too?”

Josh smiles and fingers me harder; bringing his tongue down to tease my clit too while Evans takes my full breasts in his hands. “Mmmm just like that,” I whisper, closing my eyes and gripping the bed sheets as I feel myself getting close now. My clit throbs and my breathing grows very heavy as I squirm more, arching my hips up as immense pleasure shoots through them.

“Oh fuck I’m so close!” I cry out, jerking my hips now as warm pussy juice coats Josh’s fingers and my hard nipples poke out, begging to be pleased by Evan.

“Ohhhhhh fuckfuckfuckfuck fuuuuuuck!” I gasp her air as my entire body trembles from a leg-shaking orgasm. I squeeze my right tit with one hand and bring the other down to my clit as waves of pleasure shoot from my pussy lips. “Oh my fucking god…you guys are incredible,” I say as I finish, panting heavily and running my hands up and down my tight body.

Evan smiles and gives both my boobs a kiss. “No you are incredible,” he laughs.

“Yeah that was seriously the hottest thing ever,” Josh chimes in, slipping his clothes back on now.

“Where ya goin?” I ask him, still lying on the bed and tasting my girlcum with my legs spread wide.

“I just remembered I’m late to meet some guys,” he says, clearly looking disappointed he can’t stay.

“Wowww look at you,” Evan laughs, getting up now to put his clothes on too.

I chuckle and stand up, slowly slipping my bra and panties, and then leggings and t-shirt back on. “Well I’ll see you then. Try not to fuck any asses on the way there.”

That’s all folks! Hope you loved reading it half as much as I enjoyed writing it.

-xoxo Maddie

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3n5p16/first_fmm_how_i_ended_up_with_a_cock_in_my_ass