edit: sorry I forgot the gender tags…. I'm a guy and everybody else is a lady (except for my friends who fucked sarah, since they're guys too).
I’ve wanted to tell a story here for a while, and this one seemed like the perfect candidate. It’s fresh in my head, since this all happened two days ago.
I’ve known Sarah for a few years now. She sings in a local band that I’m friendly with, has a really crazy sex drive, and is a huge proponent of polyamory. She’s pretty much a full-fledged hippy – free love, hairy legs, and no deodorant, though she did recently shave her lady parts she that she could have more uninhibited sex (hairy pits aren’t for everybody…) Every time we see each other we swap stories about our latest crazy sexual encounters. Hers are usually more unique – mine are in respect to my open relationship with Abby (my girlfriend of seven years). Before I met Sarah, she had fucked one of my bandmates in a crazy threesome (she was saved in his phone as “Sarah 3some”), and she fucked one of my other bandmates more recently, as well as his best friend. I could never figure out if it was a turn on or not that she had fucked all of my friends, but it was certainly a turn on to to be able to talk about sex so openly with somebody who I had never actually fucked. The sexual tension has been present, but she’s turned me down before – Sarah told me that she cherished our friendship and that it was rare to have something like this, where we could just chat about this stuff. She was game to have a threesome with Abby and I, but Abby wasn’t into her, so that had never happened. Abby did, however, give me full permission to fuck Sarah if the opportunity arose.
This past Sunday was Abby’s birthday. Two of her friends came over to watch Game of Thrones, and we all got royally fucked up on whiskey and weed. I was still in my right mind (no whiskey for me), but Abby was having a great time. At the end of the night, we were all lying on our couchbed (we have two beds in our living room instead of a couch – highly recommended). My left arm was around Mackenzie (who is “totally straight”), my right arm was around Abby, and Abby was cuddling with Lacey, who is her coworker/lesbian fuckbuddy (Lacy is strictly a lesbian). They were making out periodically, which was really hot, and Mackenzie and I would check them out from time to time. Then, out of nowhere, Abby takes off her pants and puts my hands in her panties. I started rubbing her clit and she started cumming within minutes, while Lacy rubbed her right leg gently and stared into her eyes. While she was cumming, I poked Mackenzie, who was too baked to notice the new sexual showing until now, and she let out an adorable, “oh my goodness!” Abby swatted my hand away, acting somewhat disgruntled that I’d show her off like that. I was left horny. Lacy headed out shortly after, and Mackenzie and Abby fell asleep in my arms. I tried going down on Abby to wake her up, but not even my tongue could rouse her from her gentle slumbers.
Sexually frustrated and exceedingly caffeinated, I texted Sarah. She was working her shift as a bartender, and she told me to come on down, since she had some crazy orgy story to tell me. I was intrigued, so I headed down around 1am. After her shift was over and she had kicked out all the patrons, we sat down at the bar and had a drink while she cleaned up and relayed to me her latest sexual adventures. The previous night she was at a cabaret a another local hippy bar, and after the show, she ended up having an orgy with several of the members of the group (including the bar owner), amidst a group of nudists. At this point I’m incredibly turned on. Sarah reeked of sex and I was so envious of all of the titties she had licked the night before. She rolled a spliff for us to smoke. We talked about the two of us, and how she liked keeping it as friends, but would fuck Abby. I told her Abby wasn’t into it, but was into me fucking other girls and telling her about it. Sarah perked up. We swapped some other sex stories from the weekend before (which I want to tell as a different story), and around 3am, I mustered the nerve to tell Sarah that I really just wanted to see her boobs, since I had never seen them before. She was happy to oblige. She turned down the lights so street people couldn’t see in, turned around, and peeled off her top. I almost immediately leaned over the bar and started sucking on her beautiful round nipples. She moaned a bit. After a while, she started to put them away, since the sun was coming up, but I promptly walked behind the bar, pushed her against the bar and kept sucking on her nipples and feeling her upper body. She told me she was too sexually exhausted for another experience right now, but I half ignored her. After a few more choice tongue flicks, she said, “you can touch me other places too.” That was all I needed.
My left hand immediately went for her pussy. I rubbed over her clothes, and then slowly reached down her dress to rub her clit. She led me into the other room, where she stripped down completely and lay down in a booth. She told me she was witholding sex just because she’d had too much, and that she wasn’t going to suck my cock. I think she got off on denying me. I put my fingers inside her. She moaned and told me to choke her. I did. I slapped her tits, bit her neck, licked her nipples, and rubbed her inside and out until she was on the verge. She smelled like sex and her pussy felt tired, but still so tight. Her hand went down to her clit, freeing me up to touch her body more freely, and we fingered her pussy together until she came. Sarah got up, and I spanked her beautiful, round ass several times. She yelped and grinned, and we joked about how the booth would smell like pussy for the next few days. She was in clear view of the road at this point, which was a super turn on, and she bent down while she was putting her bra on and rubbed her tight bare ass against my crotch. We discussed how our next encounter would involve her dominating me. I told her my underwear was full of precum, and that I was going to go home and jerk off. She grinned some more. I walked her to her car, and bit her neck as a tease.
I got home around 6:30am, jerked off, texted Sarah that I came buckets, and started to fall asleep, just as Abby was getting up. Abby came and crawled into my bed (she had fallen asleep on couchbed), and I told her the story while I slipped my hands down her tiny panties. She smiled and shook her head jokingly. She loved it.
Keep an eye out for Part 2 ;)
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/37d7xz/polyamorous_story_swappers_part_1