My straight guy fantasy fulfilled (m/m)

So, this guy in one of my classes who I always thought to be straight. He even seemed a little homophobic when I spoke with him turns out to be gay, although he still claims he’s straight. I saw him in class every day and I would stare at him and I mean he was hot. Anyway, I knew it would never happen because he’s straight. So throughout the semester we do group projects together and become friends. Then like months later he texts me. The texts first start off as hey we should grab a bite to eat and do something. And I’m just like okay sure? I mean I wasn’t that interested in being friends with him, but whatever. So, I kind of blow him off.

So like a week later he starts texting me again and this time these texts increasingly get very flirty. And I’m like uhhhh what is happening? But at the time I still didn’t think anything of it until I go on Tinder and I get matched with this guy and I’m like wtf? I thought he was straight. So he texts me and he’s like well, what do you think? Anyway, we end up going out for dinner and the whole night he doesn’t mention the flirty texts or Tinder. I’m too embarrassed to ask and as we’re about to part ways for the night he tells me he’s not gay, but he would like to hook up with me (if I want). In my mind, I’m like, “fuck yeah”. But I just play it cool and I’m like, yeah sure. He starts telling me he wants to experiment.

So anyway, fast forward to when we hook-up. He invites me to his apartment and at first, it’s so awkward because he’s not making the first move. And I sure as hell wasn’t going to. We talk about bullshit for like 2 hours on his couch and then I finally ask him what he wants to do. He says I don’t know I’ve only done this with girls. Then he says, if I was with a girl I would sit next to her and then he finally sits next me and I lean in for a kiss. And we start making out and he grabs me in and I get on top of him. I find this so strange because he kept saying he was straight but I could tell he was into me. So, then I unzip his pants and damn his cock is huge. I get on my knees and just go at it. He says to take it to the bedroom and we get on the bed and I’ve never had this much sexual chemistry with someone. We’re making out and then I’m straddling him. Then I suck his cock some more and it’s so big. I ‘ve been with 2 other guys and I’ve never seen one that big. When my jaw couldn’t take it anymore. I go back to his mouth. He’s the best kisser and his beard smells fucking amazing. It’s soft. He kisses my neck and I can’t help grabbing his velvety hair. His tongue was going in all the right places.

He starts fingering me and asks me if I like it. And I’m moaning, yes. So then he tells me to turn around and he eats me out. His tongue is in my ass and it feels so fucking good. I ask him if he was lube and he says no. So, I use some lotion he has for lube because I was just too horny at this point. Luckily, he had condoms though. So I get on top and his huge dick takes a while to get in my ass. It finally goes in and he turns me on my stomach and he just fucks the shit out of me. After we finish I spend the night in his bed and we’re cuddling and he’s like all over me all night. Rubbing my back and ass. The next morning I wake up and I see him awake so I just grab him and we start making out again.

For the next few weeks after we continue to see each other and have sex in random places (car, my place, his place again). Every time after sex the next day I would always smell like his cologne and whatever fragrance is on his beard (he did show me some moisturizer in his bathroom called Tea Tree Oil or something so maybe it's that? That stuff smells sexy as hell.

But now it’s been awhile since I’ve seen him and I still crave him so much. I’ve asked him to hang out, but I don’t think he gets the hint that I want to fuck him. And I don’t want to be that “guy” and just ask him.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/360q24/my_straight_guy_fantasy_fulfilled_mm