If I ever were to achieve anal orgasm with just a small butt plug… this is how it would happen.
I step into the bathroom to get ready for bed. As I’m brushing my teeth, I consider how to wind down, a movie, House rerun, and then I had an idea. I had an awful terrible idea.
I retrieved my small jeweled butt plug from the dresser and headed back to the bathroom to hunt down that bottle of Astroglide I put somewhere.
Found it. I realize I’m still brushing my teeth. I turn off autopilot and rinse and spit. I wash my hands and slide down my leggings. Standing at the sink, I lube up the butt plug.
Reaching around, I rub the lube against my soft little asshole. Slowly slipping the tip of my finger in and out. It’s been a long time since I’ve done this. I focus on breathing as I bring the cold, wet tip of the plug up against my tight hole. Adjusting to get that perfect angle, I slowly insert the toy in my ass. It burns as the toy stretches me out.