I dated this girl back in the day. We were each other’s first and she would always telling how big my dick was. When we had sex I always had to use really work my way in there and if I didn’t apply any pressure, her pussy would literally push me out.
Eventually we stopped dating and started seeing other people. One day we had sex and for the first time ever, my dick just slid right in. There was no resistance.
She asked me if she felt looser than normal? I asked who was bigger between me and the other guy she’d be seeing and she said “you of course.” But things were never the same.
Her tone changed. She started saying size doesn’t matter. She would always talk about him. Said he was rough and passionate. He has a nice body. Etc.
We kept fucking for a while but eventually we stopped. I always think back to that day and I wonder if she was lying to me.
I often wish I could experience that again. I find the fantasy to be quite thrilling.