A made up story written like a GW post. Hope you like.
It was my girlfriend’s birthday and she is such a big fan of party games. I decided to make this one a special birthday. We invited some of our friends over for a house party. The booze was flowing and the music was loud. Everyone was getting suitably drunk and a game of never have I ever helped the mood go from PG13 to R. My friends know full well how sexual we are and I’ve floated the idea of involving them in our bedroom but things had never progressed beyond cheeky smiles and drunk conversations. I was determined to change that tonight.
As the night went on, I spoke to a few of the single guys and told them to hang around after things quieted down, hinting at what I had planned. As people began to peel off, couples and those who lived far away, I started to amp up the conversation. We were all drunk and had been talking about sex all night so a little horny. My girlfriend had admitted to having a threesome in Never Have I Ever and I had joked I thought she could handle more. By the end of the night, a couple of my guy friends and one of hers were still around. I whispered to her to follow me upstairs and once in our room I was all over her. It wasn’t long before she was naked and ready to be fucked. I put a blindfold on her and made her kneel down ready to suck me. Then, as she waited with her mouth open, I told her to wait a second, I would get rid of everyone and get a surprise for her. When I got downstairs the guys were waiting expectantly, eager for what they though would happen next.
We went upstairs and she was still there on the floor, waiting naked. I motioned for the guys to undress and they did. She reached to take her blindfold off but I told her to wait, not to ruin the surprise. “It’s your birthday and I know you love a game so we’re going to play guess who. You’re going to take it in turns to suck us and guess who’s who! The first two you guess you have to suck until they cum. We’ll see what happens next” I could see her smile as I explained the rules. We’d talked about this kind of thing before and she got so wet every time, it was hot to see her excited once it was happening. So one of my friends went first, then hers, then my other friend, and then me. She sucked us all to get a lay of the ground and then went round again. And again. I think she knew who I was but was saving me for last. After a few wrong answers, she guessed her friend and one of mine, I think by the noises they made and from feeling their bodies. Not one to lose at a game, she took them in turn and sucked their cocks, milking them until they came on her tits. It was weird but so hot to see them shoot over her, I was rock hard.
“What’s next?” she asked with a cheeky grin on her face. “Well, if your mouth couldn’t figure us out, maybe your pussy can”. I said this as I pulled her to her feet and bent her over the bed. The two guys who had finished got dressed and left us too it. I rubbed the head of my cock on her pussy, she was soaking wet and I slid right in. She moaned so loudly as I went in. I was slow at first and soon I was fucking her hard, forgetting there was a game and just enjoying myself. After a few minutes I came to my senses and pulled out. My friend took over immediately, going hard as soon as was inside her. I could hear her getting close so I went round and stuck my cock in her mouth. She began cumming as she sucked me and I played with her swinging tits. “Can you guess who’s fucking you?” This took her over the edge again and her squeezing down on his cock made my friend cum. He pulled out and shot over her back, it was amazing. She took me out of her mouth and asked to be fucked. I shifted round and began fucking her. I was so turned on but I didn’t want to finish yet so I went slow. My friend watched for a while but when he wasn’t getting hard again He got his stuff and left too. Soon I couldn’t hold back anymore and I quickened my pace, pushing much harder until I shot my load inside of her. She collapsed on the bed and I lay next to her. “You didn’t guess the last two, but I’m sure you’ll get it next time. Happy birthday.”
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/7rdllz/birthday_surprise_mmmmf