Guilty Pleasures Pt. 5 – Getting with my sorority girl classmate that I hate – [M20/F20, Oral, Outercourse]

*Part four can be found [here](https://old.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/129c80d/guilty_pleasures_pt_4_finally_fucking_my_roommate/), but this chapter should work as a standalone.*

I was crashing my lips down on hers. They tasted like beer and lipstick. It was intoxicating. The smell of her rosy perfume mingled with a touch of sweat filled my nose as I pressed her against the wall of her room.

She was ripping at my shirt, practically tearing it apart as she undid the buttons. Only her thin top separated her heaving breasts from my bare chest.

I was grabbing at her thick thighs, my hand climbing up and up towards her ass. She was hooking a leg behind me, pulling me closer. I slammed a hand into the wall, trapping her between my arms.

—-

*Earlier*

She was staring at me, standing against the meeting-room wall. I was moments away from lunging at her- hell, if I didn’t know any better, I probably would have.

“Where the fuck are my slides?” I said, a hint of panic entering my voice. Damn. I couldn’t afford to lose my cool.

“I just thought that they were a little unnecessary, considering you spend like half our time repeating the same thing.” Cassie said, her voice infuriatingly calm.

“You don’t get to just delete my fucking work!” I yelled. “Cassie, what the fuck? We literally present tomorrow!”

“I’m not deleting them, we talked about this.” She rolled her eyes. She wasn’t even looking at me, she was on her fucking phone. “We agreed you needed to redo your portion, I just took out the old slides for you to make the new ones.”

My other teammates looked awkwardly at each other. They stayed silent.

“Back me up,” I said wearily. “C’mon, Matt. You just let her remove my entire part?”

“I mean- he’s right, Cassie.” Matt said timidly. “It’s kind of late to completely redo that entire part, plus it’s not even that bad. Eric just needed to redo the graphs on like one slide.”

“Thanks for your input, Matt.” Cassie said, her voice dripping with contempt. Matt opened his mouth again, but Cassie shot him a withering glance and he slumped back into his seat.

“Cassie-” I groaned.

She deigned to look up from her phone, meeting my eyes. It was infuriating how beautiful she was. Cassie was the stuff of every man’s dreams- long, perfectly styled blonde hair that fell in wavy curtains across her shoulders, big blue eyes, and a dazzling smile. On the rare occasion that she smiled, of course. She had soft, round features with rosy cheeks and a button nose. I was convinced her face was like those camouflage animals that lure prey in, tricking you into expecting a nice, sweet girl until you got too close to escape.

“First you were rewriting my shit now you’re deleting it, this is not ok. I’m doing my part the way I wrote it.”

She met my eyes, almost contemplatively. Something flashed in those blue eyes.

“Fine,” she said icily. “Go ahead.”

——

*Later*

My hand found its way to the zip of her pants and I frantically undid it, feeling the softness of her skin under my fingers as I pushed my fingers under her waistband. I could feel the lacy cloth of her panties.

She had her arms locked around my neck, wrapping me in a surprisingly strong embrace. We were still making out pressed against the wall of her room, but I started moving towards her bed, dragging her along with me. I was grabbing at her waistband and trying to tug those ridiculously tight pants down her legs.

“Fuck,” she moaned as I left her legs for a minute and squeezed her tits through her top. “Don’t fucking touch me like that.”

I did it again.

She moaned harder, diving back into my lips with hers. She was practically biting at my lips, sucking and kissing and forcing her tongue into my mouth. I managed to force her pants down her incredible ass, revealing her lacy white panties.

I wrapped my hands around her ass, taking hold of both cheeks with both hands as I stumbled back toward her bed. She was pushing her panties down, but I couldn’t see much from my position as she pressed her face into mine. It was driving me a little insane.

“Get on your knees and eat me,” She panted into my ear.

“You first, suck my dick,” I growled. She paused, then slowly sank to her knees.

—–

*Earlier*

*What I wouldn’t do to have those lips around my cock*. I thought resentfully, eyeing Cassie as she went on and on about something with her sorority with our other teammate, Becca.

I was going through the edit history of our presentation, trying to find the right version of my work to bring back. I had put in earbuds and was blasting loud music to drown out Cassie’s incessant chatter, but I kept looking back at her from over my laptop. It’s hard to take your eyes away from a girl like Cassie.

She caught me looking and shot me a glare.

“What?” She snapped.

“Nothing,” I said. “But maybe we could focus on doing the work for the presentation that’s due literally tomorrow?”

“Eric, are you coming to your house’s mixer tonight?” She asked, her voice sickly sweet. Changing the fucking subject again.

“Uhh, if I can get my work done by then. No thanks to you.” I muttered.

“You’re no fun.” Cassie said. “Loosen up and celebrate tonight, we’re pretty much done with all this shit.”

“Dude, no, we’re not,” I said. “I’ve been saying this entire time that we need to fix the last section and add in more data. You can’t just keep-”

She just rolled her eyes. I gave up, returning to my work. I resumed the music.

—-

*Later*

The music was irritatingly loud tonight, pulsing from our house speakers. I was sulking a bit in the corner, clutching a beer to my chest as I looked around. Gamma Tau was not my favorite sorority, and I wasn’t very close with the girls. Actually, that was probably putting it lightly, considering the girl I knew best from GT was Cassie and we hated each other.

It was a smaller party, with just my house and the GT girls, but there were enough of us that we were crowding up our basement. The basement was awash in trashy neon lighting and the alcohol was flowing.

I could see Cassie on the other side of the room, dancing in a small crowd with her girlfriends and some of my frat brothers. She was wearing these tight leather pants that hugged her ass and a loose white button-up shirt that was not buttoned all the way, revealing her bra inside it.

I tore my eyes away. It was time to suck it up and actually have some fun. I drifted toward the pong tables, looking for a girl to talk to.

I found one, a beautiful dark-haired girl with long legs and huge dark eyes. She was wearing a small white top and dark jeans, and a baseball cap turned backward. Her hair tumbled down in dark curls from under the cap all the way down to her ass, which I could see from a cursory glance was quite appealing.

“Hey,” I half-yelled in her ear over the music. “I’m Eric, what’s your name?”

“Bianca!” She raised her voice too, flashing me a stunning smile. She had fine, cat-like features with high cheekbones and big eyes that turned upward, framed by big dark lashes. She looked vaguely ethnic- but I couldn’t pinpoint what. Half-Asian? Probably Latina, actually.

“Nice to meet you!” I stuck my hand out a little awkwardly. She shook it, smiling wider.

“You wanna play a game with me?” I was practically shouting. I gestured at the pong table in front of us.

“Sure!”

We lined up across one of my brothers -Johnny- and some other GT girl. Bianca and her exchanged light trash-talk, yelling across the table. I shrugged at Johnny.

We ran through the big three- major, year, hometown while setting up. She was a dance major, second-year like me, from Florida.

I missed horribly, the ball flying straight over the cups. I wasn’t to be outdone, however.

“Damn,” I said as her ball sailed out of sight. “We are not good at this.”

“It’s ok, it means we get drunk faster.” She giggled. She was clearly a little tipsy.

Johnny and his girl sank both their shots, one after another. I groaned dramatically. Bianca laughed as I raised my cup to hers. We drank together, wincing at the taste of hard liquor.

“Yo, what the fuck is in this?” I yelled at Johnny.

“It’s just vodka and lemonade, bro!” He yelled back. The ratio was definitely more vodka than lemonade. This game could get dangerous. Whatever.

I managed to hit my next shot.

“Fuck, yeah!” I turned to Bianca for a high-five. She laughed and slapped my hand hard enough to hurt.

“Bianca!” A familiar voice came from behind. Shit.

I turned to see Cassie stalking toward us. She was smiling, which set off alarm bells in my head.

“What are you doing with my roommate?” Cassie yelled. Uh-oh.

“What does it look like? We’re playing pong.” I yelled back. Bianca laughed a little.

“Looks more like you’re trying to get in her pants.” Cassie said.

“Uh-” I said, fumbling my words. Damn. Why did she have to come now and mess up my rhythm?

“Did I tell you that he’s my teammate for the presentation?” She directed this at Bianca.

“Oh shit, you’re the one!” Bianca said, suddenly eyeing me differently. She looked me up and down, smiling a little. I didn’t like that. What had Cassie said about me?

“Yeah, we love Eric.” Cassie said, her voice dangerously fake. She was right next to me now. I was sandwiched between Bianca and Cassie, both of them lightly brushing against my arms. The music blared on. Johnny yelled something at me, moving his arms in a “throw” motion.

“Uh, your ball,” I said to Bianca, trying to ignore Cassie’s presence at my side.

“Let me shoot,” Cassie called, sticking her hand out for the ball.

“All yours,” Bianca said.

—-

*Later*

She was pulling my pants down, my boxers coming off. My dick sprang out. She laughed a little, licking her lips.

I was staring down at her crouched at my knees, my hard cock sticking out over her beautiful face.

“All yours,” I said, a little mockingly.

She shot me a glare, those blue eyes cutting through me. She suddenly rose to her feet. I instantly regretted saying anything.

She kissed my jaw, then my neck. I felt her hand wrap around my dick and I gasped slightly.

She was going slow, gently pumping back and forth. Her fingers felt just right, squeezing with just enough pressure. Her body was pressed against mine, heat radiating through what was left of our clothes. I reached around her and squeezed her ass again, grasping both cheeks and pulling them apart gleefully. She continued to stroke me while kissing my neck softly.

I let out a moan. I couldn’t help it. She was wrapped up in my arms, jacking me off while I groped her ass. It was like a dream come true. My fingers slid over her soft ass, slipping between her cheeks as I felt around a little. I traced around her asshole, not quite touching but getting close. It was a little bold, but I felt her breath quicken, her heart beat faster. She started jerking me a little faster as I tried to reach farther, feeling for her lower lips.

—-

*Earlier*

I was dancing drunkenly, swaying my hips and waving my arms in an incoherent rhythm while Bianca schooled my ass with her moves. She was perfectly in tune to the music, her curves rocking hypnotically. We were both wasted at this point, having drank all that was in the pong cups and then some.

Cassie came between us, shaking her hips . She wasn’t as graceful as Bianca, but her ass in those pants was still a sight to behold. The lights flashed purple and green. The shadows grew darker.

Cassie spun around, her back facing me while she danced with Bianca. The two of them held hands and moved to the music. Cassie backed up a little, bumping into me. Then she was grinding into me, her ass against my crotch.

She looked back over her shoulders at me, flashing me a glance. I didn’t know if she was mad- if I had been the one to bump into her. But she moved backward again, pushing her ass into me with more vigor.

She yelled something over the music

“What?” I slurred.

“You’re gonna do the slides I wrote!” She yelled.

It took a minute to register what the hell she was talking about.

“Are you fucking kidding?” I said into her ear. She was definitely grinding against me now, and she was pulling Bianca in closer. My dick was getting hard. I stepped back, trying to separate myself from her impossibly sexy figure.

“No, I’m fucking not!” She yelled, still dancing with Bianca. The two of them were so ridiculously hot, and the way they danced together was getting more and more suggestive.

“I’m not doing that!” I yelled back. I had some sense still left in me.

“What if I make it worth it for you?” Cassie said, bumping her ass back into me.

“What the fuck does that mean?”

—-

*Later*

She stared up at me, her blue eyes somehow defiant as she swallowed my entire length. She was grabbing my ass with one hand, the other buried between her legs. Soft, wet sounds filled her room as she continued to bob back and forth on my dick. I moaned too loudly, throwing my head back. She was incredible at sucking dick. She deep-throated me in one go, then pulled back and softly licked around my head, sending shivers up my spine.

“Fuck,” I groaned. I ran a hand through her golden hair, enjoying the feeling of having this girl on her knees.

Right as I was approaching the edge, Cassie pulled herself off me and stood up, leaving me out to dry.

“Damn,” I gasped, my dick twitching slightly at the sudden change in temperature. “Hold on-”

“Get on the fucking bed,” She said, kicking off her panties and pulling off her top.

She was fully nude, her incredible body on display. She had those big, perfect tits that hung just right, topped with round pink nipples. Her curves perfectly guided the eyes to between her legs, where she was clean-shaven. Her room was lit warmly by a couple of lamps, and her skin glowed in the dim light.

I didn’t protest, hopping up onto the bed. My dick was like iron at this point. She pounced up beside me, leaning into my side as we kissed. Her tits brushed my arms as she took hold of my erection and started pumping. I swung an arm over her shoulders, reaching downwards for her ass.

I shifted my weight, trying to push her down into the bed as I reached for between her legs. I slid two fingers into her, delighting in the wetness I found. We continued kissing roughly, breaking off a couple times to moan breathlessly as the other hit the right spot.

Just as I was about to slam her down into the bed and get ready to really fuck her, she surged upward and pushed me down. I flopped back onto her pillows, letting myself sink into her sheets.

“Stop that,” Cassie chided as she straddled me. She was perched just above my dick, and I could feel her dripping onto my abs. I grabbed her by the waist, fully prepared to get straight to it, but she swatted my hands away.

Everything was a bit of a blur at this point. I was riding high on the sensation of having a beautiful naked girl on top of me, and I was lightheaded from all the alcohol. The memories of the last hour were flashing back like an old projector.

Dancing, flashing lights, more drinks. Bianca grinding on me, then Cassie. Kissing someone- Cassie, I think. Stumbling out of the basement to our porch, where we shared a joint, which explained the scratchiness in the back of my throat. Cassie’s blue eyes catching the light of the flame. Talking, with people. Laughing. Talking, with Cassie. Arguing. Then walking through the cold streets towards the Gamma Tau house, Cassie dragging me by the hand. Bianca had dropped off somewhere. Kissing Cassie under a dark tree. Arguing, more, somehow. Staggering up the stairs, into her room.

Cassie brought me out of my haze as she turned, revealing her perfect ass. She shifted up my body, her ass creeping closer and closer to my face until it encompassed my entire vision. She dropped it right on my face, her pussy in my mouth and her pink asshole winking at me. I moaned with delight as I got to licking, and clapped both hands onto her cheeks.

She looked over her shoulder at me, pushing her ass out more and properly riding my face.

“Make me cum,” She said, as she lowered her head to my shaft.

I could have stayed like that for hours, in a sixty-nine with this girl I hated. Something in me wanted to shove her off me, to pin her down and fuck her like I fucked Jamie, but I was woozy and a little tired, and more than happy to just go along for the ride at this point.

She came on my face, pulling her lips off my cock to gasp in pleasure. I kept eating her out as the juices flooded down my chin, determined to make her come as hard as possible.

“Oh- fuck. Oh my God.” She gasped as she straightened up, grinding her ass down on my mouth even harder. But she relented eventually, lifting her ass up and slowly turning around so she was straddling me again. She kissed me deep.

“I’ll give you credit,” She breathed, biting my lower lip. Shit hurt. “I haven’t been eaten out like that in a year.”

She was shifting back, inching her pussy closer and closer to my dick. I was near dizzy with anticipation.

Her door suddenly opened.

I instinctively tried to sit up, but Cassie pushed me down. It was Bianca. She walked into the room casually, barely even giving me and her nude roommate a second glance. Her dark hair was a little messier and her face a little red but she was still gorgeous. I tried to cover myself, but Cassie slapped my hands away again.

“Don’t,” Cassie said with a touch of amusement. “She’s gonna watch. We have a deal. We can bring guys over whenever, but the other gets to watch. The guys don’t get to touch, though.”

My head was reeling a bit, but I did admit the thought of Bianca watching us turned me on. Fantasies of Bianca naked suddenly sprang into my head, along with fantasies of both Cassie and Bianca, naked and kneeling. My dick felt so hard it could burst.
“You missed him eating me out,” Cassie said casually. “He’s got a hell of a tongue.”

Bianca didn’t say anything, just smiled. Then she was unbuttoning her jeans, and I couldn’t believe my eyes. She dropped her jeans and turned to get into her bed, revealing her perfect, creamy ass clad in thick black panties.

Cassie grabbed my head and turned it towards her, slapping my cheek lightly.

“Hey, hey. Eyes on me.” She said, smiling wickedly. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw Bianca take her top off and slide under her covers.

Cassie continued where she left off, sliding her hips back and creeping closer and closer to my dick. She grabbed my wrists and pinned them down, her tits hanging over my face. She reached down with one hand and grabbed my dick, pushing it flat against my groin. She dropped her pussy on to it, not letting me inside her, but instead rubbing her clit and outer lips along my shaft. It felt heavenly, her soft, wet folds sliding up and down my dick, slicking it with her juices. But it was also infuriating, feeling her warmth and knowing I was only a twitch away from plunging into her.

She rocked back and forth, panting harder as she dragged her clit along my dick. I was getting close too, feeling her slide back and forth. I had been teased so long I was probably seconds away from bursting.

“Fuck,” I said, breaking free of her grip and grabbing her waist.

“Uh-uh.” Cassie said, stopping. She was pretty much just sitting on my dick now, completely still. “You don’t get to fuck me yet. If you try anything, I’ll kick you out and claim you tried to force yourself on me.”

I froze. My emotions whirled within me, filling my head with irrational thoughts. But I relented, letting go of her waist.

“That’s right,” She purred, resuming. From across the room, I could hear blankets shifting, movement, Bianca moaning slightly, and a faint buzzing. I kept my eyes on Cassie, watching her perfect tits jiggle and bounce as she rode me. The thought of Bianca fucking herself with a vibrator, only feet from us, pushed me over the edge.

I came, shooting off ropes of cum onto my own abs. Cassie gasped with delight as I twitched my hips involuntarily, rocking back and forth as I came. She shifted her clit to hit my head, and she came again too, her eyes closed in bliss.

Then she was hopping off the bed, throwing Kleenex at me.

“That was fun. Now get out.” Cassie smirked.

“W-what?” I was several seconds behind the rest of the world.

I sat up shakily, dabbing at my torso with the tissues. Cassie sauntered over to me, still nude and glorious. She ran a finger along my abs, swiping up some of my cum. Still maintaining eye contact, she popped her finger in her mouth and sucked it clean.

“I said get out,” Cassie said. “You can’t stay here. Sorority policy.”

I was getting to my feet, clumsily pulling my clothes back on. I could see Bianca, her smile wider than a Cheshire Cat. She was still mostly covered by her blankets, but she sat up and they slipped off her shoulders, revealing her bare tits. She giggled. I stood frozen like a thunderbolt had just struck me.

Cassie sidled up to me, pressing her naked body against me. She whispered into my ear.

“Seriously, get the fuck out of my house. You’re fun, but you can’t stay. And I’m gonna have Bianca eat me out so I come for the third time tonight, and you’re not allowed to watch.”

I was still processing what she said as she was guiding me out of her room. I barely had time to get all my clothes on before I was in the doorway.

“Oh, and the presentation tomorrow, Eric, honey? We’re gonna do it my way.” Cassie smiled.

Before I had time to reply, she was swinging the door closed. I caught a glimpse of her pussy and ass as she climbed into Bianca’s bed, but the door shut before I saw anymore. I stood there dumbly for a few seconds, before slowly turning and making my way out of the house.

I passed the house bathrooms on my way to the stairs just as another girl walked out, wrapped in a towel.She was also beautiful- seriously, where the fuck was this sorority getting these girls- with startling blue eyes and dark hair, which was wet and dripping across her shoulders. She met my eyes and smiled, dropping her towel for a second to reveal her still wet tits. Then she was bundled back up and walking past me into her room.

“Fucking hell,” I said, my senses slowly coming back to me. I was getting the sense that I couldn’t stay a second longer in this house before I probably spontaneously caught on fire. I stumbled down the stairs and practically sprinted out the front door, into the night air. My head reeling from all that had happened, I slowly started making my way back home- towards where I knew Jamie was waiting.

*More to come. I switched things up quite a bit with this chapter, let me know your thoughts. Was the timeline too confusing or annoying? There’s certainly more that can be told with this story, but I’m afraid of people’s patience wearing thin as the series stretches on, especially since it’ll require more and more investment (such is the nature of these multi-part stories). What do you think?*

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/12ccq78/guilty_pleasures_pt_5_getting_with_my_sorority

1 comment

Comments are closed.