The Mixup (part 2) INCEST

[Part 1](https://www.reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/wgc6gx/the_mixup_incest/)

​

Before I even got back to my room I started thinking about everything that happened the last day. I should however keep in mind that she is still going through an immense emotional rollercoaster. maybe I shouldn’t think too much of everything happening right now? I hadn’t even noticed I was already laying in my bed, my brain had switched on autopilot for my body so I could think for a minute. suddenly I got an idea, I would ask Kimmy when she got back in the morning, she was staying the night at her boyfriend’s house. For now I really should get some sleep.

The next morning I had my usual morning routine, which included me getting a shower, then getting dressed and ended with breakfast. Luckily enough it was just me and Kimmy at the table. I noticed her sitting at the table in her sleeping clothes, which for her meant a pink tank top and some bright colored boxers, this time they were purple.“ I didn’t know you were home already?” I asked her. “yeah, got back in the middle of the night.” why in the middle of the night, is everything alright?” I asked a bit worried. I don’t think I could deal with 2 girls in the house in the middle of a breakup. “yeah it’s fine”, is what she said out loud. although I could hear her whisper something under her breath, something that sounded a lot like “only once”. but I didn’t have the time to think about that since I had something much more urgent I wanted to ask her. “ Can I ask you something about Josy”. “she still feeling down?” I nodded. “yeah, ask away”. unsure what to tell her and what to hide, I just felt like I had to tell her everything to get a honest answer. “ I talked to her yesterday in her room, she wanted me to stay with her for a while. but after I hugged her for a bit, she kinda. ehm”. “well, she what?” she asked, impatiently. “ she kinda kissed me.”

Kimmy usually was very witted with her responses, but it seems like my question made her lose her tongue for a bit. “ How did she kiss you? ” she finally asked after about a minute. “what do you mean?” “show me”. I couldn’t believe my ears, has everyone in this house lost their mind? Does she want me to kiss her now? “what, why?” “ I need to know ”. Well ,I thought, she asked for it. I got up from my seat and walked over to her. I leaned down and grabbed her head. After tilting her head back a little I kissed her with full conviction, like I was sure Josy did to me yesterday. After what felt like only a few seconds I released her. A very quick glance at my watch indicated that we made out for about a minute. I got back to my seat and sat down, but I realized that Kimmy hadn’t moved her head back yet. “you alright?” looking back it’s obvious that she probably wasn’t alright at this moment but how could I have known.

After a while she moved back and with a voice much quieter than I was used to from her she replied, “she kissed you like that?” I just nodded. I couldn’t find my voice when I noticed how red her face had gotten. but after a while she seemed to find her old self again. “damn Kyle, where did you learn to do that.” it took me a few seconds to process this, instead of continuing about our very upset sister, she just seemed very pleased by what just happened. “what, no, I was just showing what Josy did”. she stood up from her seat and moved over to me. dragging my chair back a bit, I never know she had the strength in her. she sat on my lap directly facing me. I could feel my dick getting hard from her pressing against me. “Did I ever tell you why I’m dating my current boyfriend.” I shook my head. “ Because he is decent in bed, I don’t care about him at all. I just love the sex. ”That was not the answer I was expecting. “why are you telling me this”. “because I just realized I finally do actually have feelings for someone. “wait, are you really..” before I could finish my sentence my sisters tongue was finding its way in the back of my throat again.

I could feel my primal instincts coming up. my sister or not, she was sexy as hell and most important of all. she was already making out with me. my hands moved up and grabbed her ass as I could feel her nipples getting hard and poking me through her top. After a while my actual brain came back and I released myself from her hold of my mouth. “what are we doing.” she smiled at me. “Right now we are making out, and in a minute we can go to either your or my room and you can stick this hard thing inside of me.” she grabbed my dick as she said this. I wasn’t a virgin at this point, but it wasn’t far off. I definitely never fucked anyone as hot as her. But should i? I went to talk to her to ask about Josy who was crying in her room and then proceeded to kiss me to deal with those emotions. but now Kimmy and I are making out and she wants me to fuck her. It seems like I need to make a decision right now.

As me and Kimmy are making our way to my room. just walking up the stairs since we’re not quite sure who is home right now. We finally make it inside my room as I grab her and throw her on the bed. she smiles a bit sadistically at me as she says “go on then, fuck me like the cheating slut I am”. I move over to the side of my bed as I grab her top and remove it from her. I grab her boxers and rip those off from her body. My smoking hot sister is laying right here in front of me fully naked. her long hair covering a part of her face. her amazing tits staring right at me. I remove all my own clothes and nearly jump on her with excitement. We continue to make out as I can feel her hands moving all over my body. I reply by doing the same to her. After a while we both reach the important parts. I gently rub her pussy up and down as I can hear soft moans escape from her mouth, which is still entangled with my own.

I can already feel how wet she is from just fingering her as she releases from making out and lies down on her back. “just fuck me already”. she wouldn’t have to tell me twice. but right as I am about to fuck my big sister for the first time I can hear my door open behind me. I nearly jump as my mind starts to think of explanations to this scene, but before I can think of one Josy walks in. Apparently she had been crying again as she was wiping her eyes as she entered. but as soon as she opened them she just stared at the both of us. I could see tears forming in her eyes again as she turned around and stormed out of my room, slamming the door behind her as she left. Kimmy quickly got up and grabbed her clothes. “I’ll talk to her, just wait here”. She got dressed and left me behind. within 24 hours I went from being good friends with both my sisters, to kissing both and nearly fucking one of them.

After about an hour of waiting I decided to just help myself through my case of blue balls, realizing that this talk between the two of them would probably take some time. In hindsight I was glad I did this because 3 hours later Kimmy came back into my room. “Is she alright?” I immediately asked as soon as she walked in. “She’s fine, it’s just ehm. well.” I can’t really remember her being this flustered to tell something, so I knew it had to be big. “You can tell me, what is it?” “you might want to sit down for this”, she gestured at me since I jumped up when she first entered my room. I just obliged and she continued with a story that if she wouldn’t have kept a straight face the entire time I wouldn’t believe it. “She kinda likes you, which I’m sure you suspected by now. she only started dating that other douchebag so she could have sex with the idea that if she had more sexual experience she would be better for you. her words not mine, but it gets better. apparently they never had sex, since that asshole decided her best friend was better. but apparently she still has this fantasy about you, well, raping her.” “So the entire time she was with that guy she just wanted to be with..” I stopped talking as I realized what she ended her last sentence with. I couldn’t help but laugh, but Kimmy wasn’t laughing. “she wants me to… to actually…but why?” “Look I don’t know either, apparently to some people it’s a sort of fantasy that they have, she just said to me that you have to be as rough as possible and that that is the only way for her to not tell our parents what she saw in her. so you better make sure you do this right, because otherwise we are both in some massive shit.”

“Your best bet is to do it tomorrow, nobody else should be home at that time except for me.” “what?” “you know what, are you always this slow?” “no I mean you cant be serious, i’m not raping my own fucking sister!” She looked at me with intrigue. After a while she walked over to me and sat on my lap, she leaned in and whispered in my ear. “either you rape your little sister or you will never see either of us ever again.” She got up and left my room, giving me plenty of time to see her butt jiggle in front of me. That alone was already a pretty good argument to do this. But I should plan this out properly. not to mention is this really something that I am okay with? I know it isn’t fully rape, since she knows about it, but still. Either I fuck both of my sisters tomorrow or I will probably never see either one of them ever again.

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/wipdam/the_mixup_part_2_incest