Mary said, “What do you mean, you could arrange a spitroast, Josie, sorry I mean mistress.”
Josie said, “It’s okay, I’ll let you know when you need to call me mistress. I’ll let you know later what I mean about a spitroast.
Amy said. “It looks like it is going to storm, let’s go inside.”
We all showered in the outdoor shower before heading into the house. It was late afternoon and thunderstorms were rolling in. After showering, we went inside and changed into dry clothes.
We were hanging out in Amy’s house and started playing pool on her pool table. I made a pitcher of margaritas and brought it to the girls. It started getting rowdy in there. Amy was standing there, lining up a shot with her pool cue and Sarah came up behind her and pantsed her. Got her underwear and shorts all at once.
They were laughing hysterically and after pulling up her pants, Amy chased Sarah around the house. Amy managed to tackle Sarah, but Sarah was holding up her shorts and she couldn’t pants her, so she gave her a massive wedgie instead. Sarah came back into the game room, laughing and trying to get her thong underwear out of her ass crack.
It was Amy’s turn again and Josie was sort of caressing her back and ass as she line up her shot. Just as she was going to shoot, Josie stuck her hand down the back of Amy’s shorts and shoved her finger up Amy’s asshole. Amy squealed and scratched her shot. Josie cackled and ran.
Josie laughed and said, “We’re even now. We’re even. You did it to me first in the swimming pool.”
Amy was laughing and said, “Fine, we are even.”
Amy and Sarah started setting up a new game of pool.
Amy said, “Let’s make this one interesting.”
Sarah said, “How?”
Amy giggled and said, “Loser gets fucked by the winner with one of Josie’s strap ons. Right here.”
Sarah said, “You’re on. I can’t wait to fuck you hard on this pool table.”
There was a lot of back and forth and some smack talk, but in the end, Sarah won. Sarah went to go grab a strap on from Josie’s luggage. She came back out, naked from the waist down, wearing a strap on and giggling.
Amy said, “That thing is pretty fucking big, Sarah.”
Josie said, “That’s the biggest one I brought.”
“I’ve got some lube here, get ready for some fucking,” Sarah said.
I said, “Come on, take off your shorts, Amy.”
Amy took off her shorts and her underwear. She looked a bit nervous.
Josie said, “Take off your shirt too – show us your tits.”
Amy took off her tshirt and her bra, so she was the only one naked in the room.
Sarah said, “Why don’t you lay down on the pool table and spread your legs.”
Amy laid down on the pool table, with her butt up to the edge. Her feet were up on the edge, with her knees lifted and bent and legs spread. Amy looked nervous and giggled a bit. Sarah moved to line up the big strap on with Amy’s pussy. Sarah was quite tall, so it was easy for her to reach the strap on up between Amy’s legs.
Sarah put some lube on the strap on and also rubbed some on Amy’s pussy. Then she slowly worked it into Amy. Amy was moaning a bit. Josie, Mary, and I were watching in awe. Josie was sitting on a bar stool, with her arms wrapped around Mary from behind as Mary stood in front of her.
Amy was starting to enjoy getting fucked by Sarah. Sarah’s hands wandered to Amy’s tits and then she was rubbing Amy’s clit as she fucked her. Sarah bent down and sucked Amy’s nipples as she fucked her. Amy was moaning and whimpering now. Sarah seemed to be enjoying it to. Amy had an intense orgasm, wrapping her legs around Sarah tightly and Sarah bent down so they could kiss.
Then Sarah pulled out the strap on and Amy gave a little groan like she did not want it to come out yet. Amy hopped off the table and came over to kiss me. I ran my hands all over her naked body.
Amy said, “that was fun, but don’t worry, I still prefer your real dick.”
Mary said, “Josie, eh i mean Vampire girl, eh I mean mistress, ?“
Josie said, “You may call me vampire girl or mistress now.”
Mary said, “Mistress, is that strap on how you were thinking of a spitroast earlier?”
Vampire girl smiled and said, “Sort of, I’ve got a few ideas.”
Mary looked at her innocently.
Vampire girl said, “Mary, go to my luggage and find a butt plug.”
Mary said, “A butt plug? I don’t even know what that looks like? I was thinking of normal fucking, not anal.”
Vampire girl said, “Are you saying no to me, Kitten? Do you want to disappoint your mistress?”
Mary said, “No, I’m sure I can figure it out.”
Mary scurried off to go get the butt plug. She came back carrying one, rather embarrassed as she held it up, looking not sure if she grabbed the right thing.
Vampire girl said, “Good job kitten – that’s a good one.”
Mary smiled, she was happy to please Josie.
Vampire girl said, “Alright, kitten, go bend over that pool table over there for me.”
Mary gulped and slowly made her way to the pool table. She bent at the waist to lean on the pool table.
Vampire girl said, “Pull down your shorts and underwear Kitten.”
Mary nervously said, “Do we have to do this in front of everyone? I’ve never had anything in my butt before, not even a finger.”
Vampire girl said, “Pull them down.”
Mary was red faced as she lowered her shorts and underwear just below her ass and bent back over. Amy, Sarah and I watched intently.
Vampire girl said, “Spread your cheeks.”
Mary reached back and spread her ass cheeks, as she leaned over the pool table, exposing her puckered little butthole. Mary’s eyes were wide and her face was red.
Vampire girl made her way over to Mary holding the butt plug. She grabbed the lube and put some on her finger. She slowly massaged her finger into Mary’s puckered butthole. Mary made a little grunt and squinted her face. Vampire girl put lube on the butt plug and slowly began working that into Mary’s butt.
Mary said, “This is kind of embarrassing with everyone quietly watching. No one is talking.”
Sarah said, “Nice ass, Mary.”
Josie was working her way up to the widest part of the butt plug. She started using her other hand to touch Mary’s pussy. Mary was lightly moaning. Finally, Josie got it all the way in. She touched Mary’s pussy and fiddled with the butt plug a bit. Then Josie stopped and told Mary to pull up her pants.
Mary said, “I’m supposed to just have this thing in my ass?”
Josie said, “Kitten you’ll have that in your ass until I decide to take it out.”
Josie said, “Alright, Sarah, you won the last game. I’m up. If you beat me, you get to fuck Mary in the ass with a strap on. Mary looked at her with a terrified look. If I win, I get to pierce your nipples. Ask Amy how that was.”
Amy said, “It was fucking painful, scary and also she made me have a ton of orgasms while she did it. It was not for the faint hearted, but it was hot.”
I said, “I enjoyed watching, but I was also horrified.”
Sarah said, “This is pretty high stakes. I kind of want my nipples pierced, but I’m not sure I want it the way you did Amy. I heard your screams.”
Josie said, “Well?”
Sarah said, “Fine, I’m in, but I’m nervous as fuck.”
While Sarah carefully thought about her break, Josie had one hand down the back of Mary’s shorts manipulating the butt plug. Mary was making funny faces of pleasure and surprise. Sarah had a nice break and sunk a couple of balls.
Josie looked at Mary with an evil grin and said, “I hope I don’t lose, Kitten.”
Mary looked worried.
Josie did a nice job sinking a couple of balls. Mary looked relieved. Josie sat on a bar stool and beckoned Mary over to hug her. Mary was facing her and as they kissed, Josie had her hand down the back of Mary’s shorts, touching the butt plug. Mary squirmed a little in Josie’s arms.
Josie said, “Are you worried about taking a dick in your ass?”
Mary nodded yes.
Josie said, “But you also want it don’t you.”
Mary was burying her face in Josie’s shoulder and faintly nodded yes.
Sarah sank a couple of balls. Mary looked over nervously.
Josie then proceeded to run the rest of the table. She only needed to sink the 8 ball. Sarah now looked really nervous.
Josie said, “Sarah, you want those nipples pierced don’t you?”
Sarah said, “I’m not sure. I’m pretty freaked out right now honestly.”
Josie was sort of looking at Sarah and then Mary as she lined up her shot. She was grinning and it looked like she was thinking about whether she preferred having Mary assfucked or piercing Sarah’s nipples.
Josie then looked back to her shot and she scratched the shot. It was blatantly obvious it was on purpose. Sarah exhaled in relief. Mary put her face in her hands.
Josie grinned and said, “Sorry Kitten, I lost your ass. Sarah, go put on a strap on again. There is a smaller one in my bag.”
Mary said, “Thanks mistress”, relieved that it would not be the big one Sarah used on Amy.
Sarah came back wearing a smaller strap on. Sarah said, “Sorry roomie, but you might like it.”
Josie said, “Take off your clothes kitten.”
Mary looked nervous as she stripped off all of her clothes. We could see the butt plug in her ass.
Josie said, “Sarah, bring that strap on over here and fuck Mary’s pussy first.”
Sarah bent Mary over the pool table. Mary was holding herself up with her palms on the pool table. Sarah put some lube on the strap on and worked it into Mary’s pussy. She started out slow and gentle. Her thrusts were pushing into the butt plug too and Mary opened her mouth in pleasure.
Amy said, “How is that Mary?”
Mary moaned, “It feels fucking good.”
Amy said, “Jack, I might want try one of those sometime with you.”
Josie said, “Why don’t you go get another strap on Amy?”
Amy came back naked, wearing a strap on.
Josie said, “Sarah, stop for a second. I want you to slowly, gently pull out that butt plug.”
Mary said, “What are you doing? Why are you taking it out?”
Josie said, “Amy, go lay on the floor over there.”
Amy laid down on a throw rug, with her strap on sticking up.
Josie said, “Mary, go fuck Amy.”
Mary went over to Amy, straddling her and slowly working that strap on into her. She rode up and down on it.
Mary grinned at me and said, “Take off your pants Jack, I want to suck it. Like a spitroast.”
I took off my clothes and walked over, so she could suck my dick as she rode
Amy.
Josie said, “Sarah, lube up that strap on and fuck her ass.”
Mary pulled her mouth off my dick and said, “What?!”
Josie said, “it’s like when you had the butt plug in.”
Mary nervously said, “Okay,” and went back to sucking my dick.
Sarah got on her knees behind Mary and slowly worked the strap on into Mary’s asshole.
Mary pulled her mouth off my dick and said, “Holy shit.”
I shoved my dick back in her mouth. Mary was moving herself up and down on Amy’s strap on as Sarah fucked her ass. I was gently fucking her mouth. Josie had a hand down the front of her shorts, touching herself as she watched.
Josie said, “Jack, your turn, fuck her ass.”
I pulled my dick out of Mary’s mouth and said, “You want me to Mary?”
Mary said, “Yes.”
Sarah slowly pulled out. I moved into her place, lubed my dick and slowly worked it into Mary’s butt. It went in fairly easily since she had already had the butt plug and the strap on in her. Amy and I were double teaming Mary, which was sort of odd, but hot. Her asshole was so tight on my dick and I was so horny from the build up I didn’t last long. I slowly pulled out and came on her ass and back. Mary collapsed on Amy and Amy hugged her and kissed her.
Sarah said, “How was that Mary?”
Mary said, “Kind of exhausting, but good. I liked getting fucked with the butt plug in my ass.”
Amy said, “That seems really good to me. I want to try it sometime.”
Josie said, “Kitten, why don’t you go shower. And, Jack go wash off your dick and then make us some dinner.”
Mary and I went to shower together. Then, we came out to the kitchen area where everyone was hanging out.
Amy said, “I’m so sad we have to go back to college tomorrow.”
Mary said, “I’m going to miss Vampire girl,” and she gave her a big hug.
Josie looked quite happy with Mary hugging her.
Josie said, “my college is not that far away. We can visit each other now that I have met all of you.”
Amy said, “Jack, you and Josie should spend the night together tonight.”
I said, “What, with my ex-gf?”
Josie said, “Amy, this doesn’t bother you?”
Amy said, “No, Jack loves me. I like the idea of you two having a nice night together.”
Josie and I kind of looked at each other and shrugged.
Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/vfivch/my_gf_amy_and_her_friends_sarah_mary_and_josie
Very nice hoping for a part two
!updateme
Updateme