Met at a house party during our last year of highschool. Drinking, playing cards and this girl pulls me in the bathroom to partake in something else. She tells me her boyfriend thinks I’m hot and wanted to know if I was open to fooling around. He’s a few years older, cut from landscaping, fun to hang with and fucking sexy in his work boots. So I say yes, she pulls me in for a kiss slow at first, running her hands from my neck to my ass. I get shivers and do the same to her, pulling her against me on the sink. She starts grinding on my knee as we kiss. After she climaxes she whispers in my ear her boyfriend will finish me off. Later that night we all claim our spots in the house, I had the couch and another friend on a chair. I hear someone coming downstairs, trying not to fall in the dark. He comes over to the couch and gives me a little kiss. I’m soon naked under the blankets with him between my legs and trying so hard to be quiet since there is someone just a few feet away snoring. It doesn’t take long for me to climax after a long night of flirting with them both. He gives me a long kiss and disappears back upstairs to his girlfriend.
Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/tt3wa1/my_first_couple_circa_90s