It was a warm day, you can feel the heat coming in with the sunlight through the window and passing through the curtains. I was sitting naked in the couch while the tv was on in front of me. I can’t really remember what was on, I just remember it was something sexy enough to get me and my friend horny, and then one thing led to another and suddenly our clothes ended up in the floor. Then again I how could I remember what was on tv when I was focusing on the feeling of his lips around my cock and the way he was sucking it.
He was lying in the couch next to me reaching my cock over my lap, just giving it a nice massage with his mouth, just playing with it, we were both just chilling that day, no hurries.
Then it happened, he took my cock out of his mouth and talked to me, he asked me if I had ever thought about doing something else.
-what do you mean? I asked, even tough I totally knew what he meant.
-like, you know… like… well, have you ever thought about, like, fucking? He said
The answer was yes, I had been thinking about it for a while now, but I would never had the guts to suggest it. The idea scared me. I had never done sexual stuff with anyone before, besides the things I had done with him so far of course, but somehow I had convinced myself that those didn’t count, but this! I really was scared of the idea of my first time being with another men. But at the same time that idea really turned me on, and I couldn’t believe he really suggested it, and I was happy he did, but I also was scared because I knew I couldn’t say no. This was going to happen. We were going to fuck.
-Im not sure- I said lying, – would you want to try?-
-Im mean, it could be fun- he said, and by that time I was so turned on by the idea, I was pretty much done with pretending I wasn’t.
-alright let’s do it!- I said to his surprise. This was happening.
As this activity required one party to submit to the other, like the dorks we were we would decide how to do this the same way we did before, so we took a coin and flip it to discover who would be taking the other one’s cock inside of him.
That coin was in the air for what felt like hours, I could feel my heart like crazy. And a weird and sort of warm feeling run through my body when that coin finally stopped moving and I could see the face on it. He won.
So I sat in the couch and watch him prepare, I could feel my heart in my throat, I wasn’t sure how I was feeling. Or even more precisely, I was scared of how I was feeling. I was pretty excited. I couldn’t believe what was happening. He was in front of me putting on a condom he had on his wallet on his cock, in my mind I had the silly idea of it being like a prisoner watching the executioner sharpening the hatchet in front of him. I nervously laughed a little.
We discussed about how to do it, and I decided to do it the old fashioned way, so I climbed in the bed and went in all fours waiting for him, we knew about the importance of lubrication, but didn’t had any proper lube, so we improvised with lotion. I felt how the mattress sunk a little when he climbed to behind me and I felt as he opened up my butt cheeks and let a squirt of lotion fall on my asshole.
I just couldn’t believe, no one, except maybe a doctor had ever seen that part of me before, and even when I had sexual fantasies of fucking with women they would see me like that, I felt kind of humiliating in a way, but I didn’t cared enough about that, it was very hot.
Athen I felt the warmth of the tip of his cock right in my ass.
-are you sure about this?- he asked giving me a last chance of scaping what we were going to do, and a lot of mixed feelings flooded my mind but none strong enough to stop my mouth from saying the words
-yeah, let’s do it!-
So then I felt him grabbing me by the hips and started pushing inside me. I felt a pressure against me and then a really weird sensation, as his cock found it’s way inside me, it started hurt more and more, but never a lot, I could hear his breathing and feel his air on my naked back.
As more and more of him was inside me I started to quietly groan though the sound was almost drowned by the sound of the tv that was still on.
I finally felt him stop pushing, and I heard his voice ask.
-how does it feel?-
-weird- I answered
-do you want to stop?
-no- I said -feels good- it did, after some time I started to enjoy that weird feeling. I could feel my cock rock hard between my legs. I was loving it. So he continued, now slowly pulling out, an then in and then out, going just a little bit faster each time he did it. And the pain I felt slowly started to fade away, leaving only that really weird pleasure I felt.
Each time he pushed I felt that pressure that made me groan, and as I let myself enjoy the situation more and more, that groan become a moan, wich after some time became louder as I found out part of the fun was playing off my submissive role. He had me, I was his. If he had asked for anything at that moment I would have done it. And he was enjoying it too, I could hear the sound of his moans filling the room along mine,
After a while he was pretty much pounding me. My whole body was rocking back and forth with each thrust of his hips. And I was biting on the sheets of the bed, not so much because I need it, but because it was fun.
Then I heard him whispering in my ear,
-are you close?, I am close- and as much as I was loving it I wasn’t really close, at least not as much as him.
-can you hold it a little more?- I asked, -Im wanna cum at the same time- he said yes and we kept going at it, and as he kept fucking me I reached for my cock and grabbed it, then it felt like it was the hardest it had ever been, and I started jerking off as my body rocked back and forth, and then eventually I was pushing towards him.
-I’m gonna cum dude!- he yelled and then thrusted very hard a couple of times, so hard I almost fell. I could actually feel his dick cumming inside me and then he stopped moving for a moment.
-sorry dude did you finished?- he asked
-not yet- I replied
-sorry- he said an then I felt how he started to pull out
-Stop! Don’t pull out- I said, and before he could say anything I started thrusting back at him while jerking off quickly, he understood and started fucking me again, I couldn’t believe what I was doing, by this time, it was actually like I was fucking him, and it was then when a big squirm of cum came out of me and on the mattress, I kept going like that for a while until I finally felt satisfied. And we both fell on the bed tired and catching our breaths. With him still inside of me I could actually feel his cock getting softer.
He finally pulled out of me. And I’ll omit some details but he quickly got rid of the condom. And we just stayed there for a while silent, catching our breaths and watching the TV. It was just commercial ads at that point.
-That was fun- I said
-yeah- he said, and then we said nothing about it for the rest of the day.
After a while we just dressed up, and went out just hanging around for a while. I did walk funny for a while.
I never got the opportunity to return him the favor, as after that encounter we did had a couple sexual experiences more, we didn’t went beyond sucking cock. And a couple months after that he started dating the girl who would later become his wife, so our encounters had to stop when they got serious. We swore to never tell anyone about it, and I don’t know if he did, but sometimes I get the feeling she knows. It’s something about the way she looks at me when we meet.
A month after that I found the girl who would become the first person I got to actually fuck with my cock, and also my first girlfriend. And a couple of months after that I met the boy who would become my first boyfriend. Then my second girlfriend. And so and so.
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/olbin7/two_totally_straight_friends_p3