Buddy fun turns into orgy

I always had my suspicions about Nathen. Ever since high school, he carried himself with this inexplicable swagger. He was handsome of course, but always seemed to lack some depth for emotional connections. Based on our conversations, he had the capacity to carry his emotions, yet he never extended it to the girls that he was involved with. Something always seemed to be missing.

Nathen and I got to know each other through sports in school. He played opposite me on the soccer field—I played left wing, him right. He was also a fellow lightweight on the wrestling team, which offered me up the first opportunity to see what all the girls must have been gawking at.

His frame was small, much like my own, but he filled out the lower part of his singlet quite impeccably. I didn’t really get to see much from an anterior perspective, but on one occasion in which he was slightly overweight, he dropped his boxers to expose a chiseled posterior when stepping back onto the scale. Dimples graced his glutei like that of a gladiator. As soon as I noticed how this was making me feel, I immediately looked away. After all, I was straight and had a girlfriend.

And she was awesome, but much like high school love—it burned bright, fast, but not for long.
She is another tale on her own, so I will get back to the matter at hand.

Nathen and I grew quite close over the years and I may have snuck in a couple of random ass grabs after a good performance on the pitch or the mat. We also went to the same college so shared a few late nights just drinking and talking shit about our high school days as well.

Nothing ever happened during that time. We eventually graduated from college and went separate ways. I went to grad school and he went to work.

I experimented with guys through grad school, but still identified as straight. But, I was always stressed and needed release, so I ended up finding a fellow to commiserate with. Aaron was a skinny, tall blonde with the largest cock I have ever seen—bigger than what I had seen in porn. He loved to “take care of me” basically anytime I reached out. Anytime that I would need to blow off some steam he was there to embrace me and take my cock down his throat. With ease—might I add. We never actually had sex and he never expected reciprocation. He just enjoyed taking my cock and swallowing my cum. I would always cum to the thought of his huge cock, but was always too scared to reach out and grab it or take it in my mouth.

Some other ladies and gentlemen entered the picture intermittently throughout those sex-crazed days, but time went on and I moved to “the big city” to start my career. A couple of years went by and I met a woman who stole my heart. For my birthday she took me to a local brewery and invited Nathen and some other good friends from my past that I kept touch with intermittently over the years.

We were at the brewery and having a laugh over some beers and who should walk in? Aaron. At this point, I was overwhelmed with emotions as I had lusted after Nathen, hooked up with Aaron, and was having regular—almost too frequent sex—with my girlfriend.

I went into panic mode and went to the bathroom. At this point, I didn’t know if Aaron even saw me. I splashed cold water on my face and tried to collect myself. At this point, I didn’t know what to do. My girlfriend knew I now identified as bi at this point, but would she be cool with meeting they guy that got be through grad school on a sexual level? My instinct told me “no”.

I walked out of the restroom and immediately to the line for drinks. At this point, I needed about 5 to quell my nerves. I look over in the second line over and Aaron is there. He shoots me a wink. Although he had spent a lot of time with my dick in his mouth, he was respectful of the fact that most knew me as a straight man. He said nothing and didn’t even approach my group at the brewery.

The crowd got a little boisterous for my taste, so we left shortly after the silent encounter between Aaron and myself. A few friends left and Nathen, my girlfriend and I were left to retreat to the condo for some additional drinks and music. Nathen and I love to listen to this one band that my girlfriend doesn’t particularly care for, so we jammed out while she showered to “get a way from this for a bit.”

From there we got to talking about love lives and eventually our sex lives. Turns out Nathen’s girlfriend at the time was celibate, but apparently loves to send provocative pictures and really enjoys sucking dick (his words not mine). She happened to send a snapchat while we were talking, and it turns out she has what could be defined as near-perfect tits. He noticed that I saw and said, “might as well get a proper look,” so turned the phone my way and they were incredible. At this point my girlfriend was in bed. Blood started to rush to my cock and I was wearing extremely thin pajama pants. I didn’t have the opportunity to pivot on this as he saw my penis begin to inflate, so I asked him if he wanted to watch some porn. From my POV, this was a “hail mary” to distract from my engorged penis and to (selfishly) see if he was interested as well.

*Ping*

I receive a text from Aaron saying it was good to see me and that he wanted to see more of me. I escaped to the bathroom to respond; to also let Nathen respond to my panicked attempt to watch porn. I told Aaron about my current situation and he asked to come over to observe.

I ended up going back out to the living room to meet Nathen and we had more drinks without responding to Aaron. Nathen asked what kind of porn I like, then pulled it up on his phone. I was sitting there on the couch in awe; starting to stroke myself.

*Ping*

From Aaron, “I guess that’s a no.”

I have always been a people pleaser and even more so after drinks, so I told him to come over and join us.

I looked up from my phone to see Nathen stroking his cock. He looked over at me on my phone, “you’re not watching. Is everything okay?”

“Yes, we just may have a visitor in a bit.”

“Okay, can I see a bit more before this mysterious visitor arrives?”

“More of what?”

“You. Dummy!”

“Like…my cock?”

“Yes. I will show you mine too.”

I hesitantly looked down at my crotch. He could obviously see my erection, but not bare. I reluctantly pulled my elastic waistband down.

He immediately grabbed hold. “I have been waiting to put my hands on you for a long time”

“Really? Why?”

“You intrigued me”

*Ping*

*GATE ACCESS REQUEST FROM AARON ___*

*Granted access*

As Nathen is stroking my cock, “have you ever done this before?”

“Once”

“Is this the guy?”

“Yes”

His hand grasped me firmer, “well I better get in my time now”

Next thing I know, his face is all over my cock and he is trying his best to swallow it.

*Knock, Knock*

Aaron has arrived at the door and I greet him with no pants on and a raging hard-on, still wet from the brief suck from Nathen.

Aaron—being in this situation before—immediately takes off his shirt. “So are we doing this or what?”

Nathen responds, “you may want to lose those pants too.”

Aaron pulls down his pants to unveil his large flaccid phallus.

Nathen, “Nice. Think you may have competition.” As he lets his pants fall to the ground.

They both are 10 inches long, with girth to make you salivate. Nathen is harder than Aaron at this point.

I was floored to see two enormous cocks right in front of me. I finally knew why all the girls flocked to Nathen in high school.

Aaron got on his knees in front of me on the couch and began to suck my cock. Shortly after, Nathen joined in, both kissing each other across my dick. This went on for about 20 minutes and then came to a screeching halt as my girlfriend entered the room.

“What. The. Fuck.” She said as Aaron and Nathen jumped away from my cock.

“Why the fuck wouldn’t you wake me?!”
She proceeded to disrobe. Nathen jumped up and began sucking on her tits. Aaron proceeded to deep throat my cock.

As I placed my hand on Aaron’s head he suggested that the others join. I admittedly had some difficulty since the two studs were much bigger than me, so I suggested that I fuck my girlfriends pussy. Aaron and Nathen looked at each other and grinned as Aaron suggests, “I guess that means asses are open?”

“Sure” I said.

As my girlfriend rode my cock, Nathen put some lube on me and began to fuck my ass. At the same time Aaron did the same in my girlfriend’s ass. At that moment we were all connected. Nathen and Aaron were kissing above my girlfriend and I, but we were both filled and in sheer ecstasy. She began to cum on me and I came in response.

Subsequently, she removed herself from me and we were all on her own. Both Nathen and Aaron came on my cock. They, then proceeded to lick each others cum off of my cock.

Aaron left and my girlfriend went to bed, but Nathen and I had another round later that night.

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/k0xidd/buddy_fun_turns_into_orgy