Fucked my g[F23]’s twin sister by [M25]istake

My gf Kylie has an identical twin sister named Kayla. When I first went out with Kylie, I would mix her up with Kayla at times. They even played jokes and pranked me about this. But after going out for about 4 months, I caught on and could tell the difference between Kylie and Kayla. After dating about 14-15 months, we decided to move in together.

When Halloween came around, I was invited to my office Halloween costume party. I decided to go as a doctor and Kylie dressed up as a nurse. The office party was at 5pm and started dying down around 8pm. We called for an Uber because we were both too drunk to drive. When we got home, I was tired, got ready for bed and passed out. Kylie said she wasn’t too tired and went to Kayla’s place. I woke up when I felt Kylie coming to bed. She woke me up saying, “hey babe. I’m horny, can we fuck before I go to bed?” I wasn’t a guy to say no to it, so I told her, “just let me get more awake.” Kylie didn’t wait, she pulled down my shorts and started sucking my morning wood, or evening wood? Kylie continued sucking my cock as I played with her ass and lightly fingering her making her moan softly. I then helped Kylie get out of her clothes. As she kept sucking, I felt my cock throb and my legs tensed, I told Kylie, “I’m about to cum!” Kylie kept going and I shot my load in her mouth and she swallowed it. Kylie wanted her turn so I laid her on her back, kissing her neck, sucking her tits, and moving down eating her pussy. Kylie squealed out loud and panting hard, moaning saying, “oh yea! That’s it! Ahh, keep going!” I made Kylie cum just like she did to me and I could tell. She trembled and her left leg was shaking. Because Kylie was on the pill, we started to fuck wildly like animals raw, gently then rough, reckless abandon smashing her pussy, multiple positions, felt good but…different. I didn’t care and kept going while Kylie was moaning, whimpering, and screaming out, “Oh fuck yea! Fuck my pussy! Keep going right there! Fuck me harder! Don’t stop! Keep fucking me! Make me cum again!” A couple more deep thrusts and Kylie began to shake and convulse again making her cum for the second time as she collapses breathless. Kylie wanted me to cum in her, she began to ride slowly, grinding on me as we were both sweaty. I watched her tits bounce in sweat and I was getting close, I brought her close to me, and started thrusting into Kylie making her scream out loud. She pleaded, “Oh, not so rough. I’m getting sore. Just cum in me, please!” After a couple more deep thrusts, my cock throbbed and I shot my load deep in her pussy draining my balls into her. Kylie let out a deep moan and we cuddled a bit.

After catching our breathe, we decided to clean ourselves up. It was at that point I got a real good look at her and realized, thinking, “fuck, did I just fuck Kayla and not Kylie?” So I said tentatively, “Kayla?” Kayla looked at me and said, “Yes?” My stomach sank and I was shocked Kayla would do something like that. Furious, I screamed at her, “what the fuck are you thinking!? Why would you do this!? Do you have any idea how mad Kylie would be!? Kayla said, “Kylie doesn’t have to know. We can keep this our secret.” I said, “how can you be so calm about this? Where is she anyway?” “She went to IHOP with some friends,” Kayla replied. Still furious, “I still can’t believe this! What am I gonna do?!” Kayla and I were going to talk about it, but the door opens and in comes Kylie…

Fictional

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/12vsyk4/fucked_my_gf23s_twin_sister_by_m25istake