*Backstory: I used to let my dad’s friends fuck me (an over-18 community college student) but they’re mad I don’t have time for them anymore. So, I decided to find them a new (fellow over-18 student) plaything. It feels unfinished there at the end…still debating which way to take it! *
I got tired of all the poker buddies whining about how I wasn’t around to suck them off, anymore. So, one night I invited a girl from class to hang out. She was mousy and had always kinda followed me around, clearly desperate for my approval. I spent a few weeks in study group being nice to her, flirting with her, making sure she would do anything I told her to. The bottle of vodka I stole from my dad’s liquor cabinet wouldn’t hurt, either.
I made us a few Screwdrivers and got her playing “Truth or Dare.” Loosening her up with some sexy “truth” questions I saved the best dare for a few drinks in: “I dare you to kiss me on the mouth.”Her jaw dropped – she was speechless! I took that as a yes and moved closer to her, stroking her hair and smiling sweetly.
She was frozen in shock so I leaned in and kissed her – sweetly, no tongue. Not yet. Her mouth was sweet from the orange juice. I stopped kissing her but didn’t lean back or move away. I kept my face right there, nuzzling my nose against her cheek while I moved my hand down the front of her t-shirt, down to her skirt.
I began kissing the side of her face. As I pushed the skirt’s waistband out of my way and dove my little hand right between her legs I could feel the heat right away.
The swollen, wet flesh my fingers found was not a surprise. Her entire body shuddered, as I softly began to rub the tip of my forefinger on her clit. Circling around and around, feeling her entire, mousy little body melt to my touch.
She remained motionless as I slipped my finger away from her clit and right up inside her, wriggling it around to find her G spot. It didn’t take long! She began moaning “No….please…I can’t…I…”
I knew I had her in my power, my new little slut.
“Take your panties off and get on your belly,” I whispered into her ear, without slowing down the finger I had inside her. “But first, taste.” I slid my finger out of her pussy and into her little mouth. She passed the consent test, greedily sucking her pussy juice and cleaning my finger.
Once she was on the floor, face down and naked from the waist down, I knelt down beside her and began rubbing her ass cheeks. They were flat, but bigger than mine and I knew the dirty old men would love smacking them.
I stuck my finger back in her pussy to get it all lubed up with her own, homemade lube. Slippery from her pussy juice, my finger easily teased her tight, pink little asshole and spread it just enough so I could slide my finger all the way in, deep. She squirmed as she shrieked and I knew I was the first – but not the last, to enter her sacred little hole.
“You’re going to do anything I say, right?” She nodded, “Yes, anything, please fuck me Vada, PLEASE!”
“Oh, you’re going to get fucked,” I laughed. “Tim!”
Tim was in his 50s and looked it. He’d been waiting right outside the door – rubbing his stubby little cock and getting ready for her final test. Nerd girl’s eyes widened but I hastily reassured her – “Don’t worry, he’s just here to help us have some fun. You’re my good girl, aren’t you? You trust me?”
She nodded. “Good girl. Me and Tim are going to fill all of your holes, baby girl. All of them.” I took off my dress to reveal the big, purple strap-on I’d been wearing the whole time. “Tim here is going to stick his stupid little dick in your mouth while I fuck your pussy and finger your tight little asshole. How’s that sound? You ready to be air-tight like the best slut in the world for me?
She nodded “yes,” and wordlessly got on all fours, closing her eyes, opening her mouth and looking at Tim. Tim didn’t hesitate to shove all of his cock in her mouth, up to his wrinkly old balls. I felt kinda bad at how she coughed and gagged but he was pretty small so I knew could handle it. I wasn’t sure he could handle it though, the way he was grunting!
Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/12ansq0/training_a_new_fucktoy_for_my_dads_blue_boner