Jack and Amy work at a summer camp the summer after graduating college. Chapter 4. Amy punishes Jack’s bratty “little sister”, Molly. [MFF 19+] [ENF]

Molly was standing in my tent, as I laid in my cot looking up at her. Molly was standing there in her shorts and tshirt, looking at me nervously and touching her bare neck. The black choker that my gf, Amy, put on her neck was missing. When Amy put the choker on Molly, she told Molly and me that if she (Amy), took it off her, then Molly could fool around with me. Molly started to unzip her denim shorts and slid them down. She was wearing some ordinary yellow, cotton panties underneath. She pulled her tshirt off over her head and had a white bra covering her small breasts.

“Molly, so Amy told you to come visit me tonight?” I had a nagging concern that Molly was up to no good.

There was a hesitation, her face turned a little red and she said, “uh, huh, yep” and she started taking off her bra.

“So, Amy took off your choker?”

Molly was looking away from me and said, “Honestly, yep, that’s what happened,” and she slid off her panties, so she was standing there fully naked in front of me. She had nice, firm looking little tits and a bit of blonde bush between her thin legs. “What do you want to do?”

“So, if I ask Amy, when she gets back, she is going to tell me the same thing?”

“Um…you don’t need to do that…she…that would make it awkward…”

“I think you’re lying Molly.”

She hesitated and looked around, covering herself with her hands a little, and moving her feet around. “Jack, what difference does it make. I’m not going to tell anyone…and, anyway, I think she was planning to take the choker off for you sometime…why not now?”

It pained me to say, “put your clothes back on Molly.”

“Jack, this is fucking embarrassing. Seriously, just like…let’s fool around…I will do ANYTHING you want. Let’s have some fun. I’ve never given a blowjob before and I want to do it.”

Oh, man, she was not making this easy. “Molly, no. I am not cheating on Amy.”

She started putting her underwear back on, “Alright, but just please don’t tell her…”

“I have to tell her Molly. She warned you that you would get in trouble if you took that choker off yourself.”

Molly looked really nervous, “I was just horny and Amy is not around. Now, she’ll probably never let me do anything with you.” She was pulling up her shorts.

“Look, if Amy let me, I would enjoy it too, but I’m afraid you’ve broken her trust here.”

She looked at me pleading, “Seriously Jack, let’s just fuck around and I promise I will never tell anyone.”

“Seriously, you need to leave my tent.”

I waited for Amy to get back from her night off and she came into my tent and said, “I’m surprised you’re still awake. I thought I was just going to join you in your sleep.”

“I’ve been waiting for you to get back, so I can talk to you.”

“What’s up?”

I sighed, “Amy, Molly came here to visit me tonight and…she was not wearing the choker.”

Amy looked worried, “Did you fuck her?”

“No, I was suspicious. Something did not seem right. When I quizzed her, she seemed cagey, like she was lying.”

“That’s because she was lying. Jack, I did plan to take that choker off her sometime and let you two have some fun, but I did not do it tonight, so I am glad you sensed it was not right,” and she kissed me.

I said, “Maybe you need to give me more of a heads up, I don’t think she can be trusted with the choker thing.”

“Clearly not. She is a horny little thing.”

I sighed and said, “No kidding.”

Amy laughed a little and shoved her hand into my boxers, touching my dick. “Poor baby, was that a tease? I bet it was tempting.”

“Amy, she stripped fully naked while I quizzed her, before I figured out that she was definitely lying.”

Amy was stroking my dick, “She has a nice body. I bet you enjoyed watching her strip.”

I nervously nodded yes as Amy pulled off my underwear.

“Well, I want to let you play with her, but she really needs to be punished for this. She is kind of an unruly brat. I don’t know why I like her.”

“Maybe you like that she is a brat? It turns you on that she is this sneaky little brat?”

Amy was pulling off her clothes, “Maybe. I’m just glad that I can trust you, Jack,” and she moved down to suck my dick.

“Amy, you’re just hot as shit and I’m in love with you. As I’ve said before, if you wanted to stop messing around with other girls and have it just be the two of us, I would do that.”

Amy pulled her mouth off my dick and moved up my body to put my dick inside her vagina. “I know Jack, and I love you too, but I still enjoy playing with other girls. And I even like having you fuck with hot girls. Do you want to keep doing it?” as she rode me.

“Amy, I am having fun too and I am totally turned on by you playing with girls. I just don’t want you to feel like you are doing it for me.”

She was riding up and down on my dick, “No, I want to keep doing it Jack. It’s not just for you…I’m going to have fun with Molly here…and you will too…I promise.” The cot was making a lot of squeaking noises as Amy rode my dick up and down until we both came.

The next day was a day off for the entire camp staff and the campers were leaving the camp that day at the end of the week. Molly was very nervous around Amy and me. She had put the black choker back on. Once the kids left camp, we were standing near the main building, Amy called over to Molly, “Molly, come over here.”

Molly looked incredibly nervous as she approached the two of us, “Hi Amy, what is it?”

Amy did not mention anything about what Molly had done the night before, she just said, “Jack and I are going to row out to that island in the middle of the lake, jump off some rocks, swim around and cool off. Do you want to come?”

Molly smiled broadly, “yes, that sounds fun!”

Molly, Amy, and I put on swimsuits and hiked down to the lake. We hopped in one of the big rowboats and rowed out to this rocky island in the middle of the lake. Both girls were wearing one piece swimsuits. Amy was wearing a red one, with high cutouts for the legs, so that her hips were quite exposed, the crotch barely covered her labia, and her ass was pretty much bare. Molly had a more modest, black, one piece on and was staring at Amy’s body almost as much as me.

We got out to the island and played, jumping off rocks, and swimming around the deep water. Finally Amy said, “I’m getting hungry. Let’s head back, what do you guys think?” We both agreed.

Amy said, “Molly, I need you to give me that black choker.”

Molly looked confused, but then smiled, thinking that Amy was about to let her play with me. But, after she took it off, Amy said, “You need to earn this back.”

“What?”

“I know that you took it off and I told you that you would be in trouble if you did that.”

“I’m so sorry, Amy…I…just…how do I get it back?”

“Take off your swimsuit.” Molly did as she was told, taking off her swimsuit and standing, looking around nervously on the small beach of this island, covering herself a bit with her hands.

“Molly, you are going to swim back to camp…”

Molly looked from the island back toward the dock and the beach at our camp. “But, Amy…it’s pretty far.”

“You are very strong swimmer and we are going to follow you in the rowboat.”

“It’s not that…it’s just…I’m naked…I can see a bunch of the guys from camp are there, jumping off the dock and stuff.”

Amy just looked at her and shrugged her shoulders. “Yes, you’re going to swim right up to the dock and walk right up on shore. I will be waiting with your swimsuit.”

Molly was bright red, looking at Amy and me and then towards the camp. She slowly walked into the water and started swimming towards the shore. We followed her closely in the rowboat and I could see her bare ass near the surface as she swam. As we approached the camp, she tread water and said, “Um, there’s a lot of guys there at the waterfront…” she was giving Amy a pleading look.

Amy said, “You will swim to that dock, climb out and walk at a normal pace to the shore. No running and no covering up. Meet us at the guard shack. Then I will put the choker back on you.”

Molly said, “fuck…this is embarrassing.”

“Should have thought of that before you decided to be a disobedient brat.”

Molly went back to swimming. We rowed into shore and got onto to the beach in time to see her climb out of the water and slowly walk down the long metal dock, as instructed. At first, the guys were just silent with mouths wide open in shock that she was naked in broad daylight. Then, there was loud whistling and cheering and some guys running along to make sure they saw everything. There were some yells of “nice ass Molly,” and “look at her little tits”. “Nice pussy.” She was beet red, but she did as she was told. We went into the guard shack and Amy gave her the swimsuit to put back on.

Amy put the choker back around her neck and Molly said, “Thanks.”

The three of us walked together up a trail to the base camp. Molly had sort of a funny smile on her face, as we walked. Amy put her arm over Molly’s shoulders and said, “You liked that didn’t you…”

Molly giggled and nodded, “yes.”

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/10x2d4r/jack_and_amy_work_at_a_summer_camp_the_summer