Blackmailing my gf Amy (Part 4) (MFF 21) [blackmail role play]

For background for any new readers, my college gf Amy and I (Jack) were playing a game, in which I was a guy named Jason, who is blackmailing her using nude photos I took. In case it is confusing, Jack is Amy’s bf and sometimes he pretends to be Jason. Amy wants Jack to make her do things and not stop when she is calling him Jason, but if she wants him to stop, she just says his real name, Jack. Also, Hyun is our hot lab partner, who has been having sex with us and she is also getting in on this blackmail game. Since I have not described them in a long time, Amy is about 5’9″, with long brown hair and really unique blue/grey eyes. She has medium sized, perfect tits, a nice ass and thin body. Hyun is a Korean/American girl with black hair, brown eyes, light skin, small tits, a very thin body and nice, long legs and is about 5’6″ or so.

Amy, Hyun and I went back to Amy’s apartment after Jason (my alter ego that was blackmailing Amy), blackmailed them for oral in the darkroom lab in the biology department. Amy and Hyun were quite horny from fooling around in the dark room and Amy said that Hyun could fuck me, because she owed her for helping her out with Jason, but really just because Amy gets off on watching me fuck hot girls.

Once we arrived at Amy’s, we went straight back to her bedroom, all three of us removing our clothes as we got to her bed. We got on the bed, naked, and the three of us were touching each other and taking turns kissing each other. After we made out like this for awhile, Amy and Hyun were laying next to each other kissing and feeling each others’ naked bodies, so I made my way down from licking and sucking Hyun’s small, firm tits, down her flat stomach toward her crotch. I kissed and licked around her trimmed, dark bush. Then, I spread her long, thin legs and kissed her inner thighs, and started licking her pussy. I looked up as I licked her and saw Amy break the kiss with Hyun to look down at me, as I licked her friend. Amy smiled at me, and ran her hand up and down Hyun’s bare skin. She lightly fondled her small chest and then made her way down Hyun’s stomach, running her fingers through her soft bush.

Amy started touching herself, while kissing Hyun and I moved up between Hyun’s legs to fuck her. the girls stopped kissing and Hyun was looking at me, biting her lower lip, with her legs spread wide, ready to be fucked. I grabbed a pillow, shoving it under Hyun’s butt, and was on my knees, slowly working my boner into her wet pussy. Amy was leaned against some pillows and fiddling with her clit, right next to Hyun, watching intently as my dick entered her friend. I was holding Hyun’s legs open and up, by her nice thighs and I had a great view of my dick going in and out of her pussy. I had to pull out and go back down on her for a minute, her pussy looked so nice from that angle.

I moved back into position to fuck her and slid my dick into her now soaking wet pussy. I continued thrusting my dick all the way in and almost all the way out to give her the full length of my dick on each thrust. Hyun was quite flushed, breathing heavy and whimpering. Amy’s hand was moving fast on her own clit and she reached down with her other hand to rub Hyun’s clit, while I fucked her. I was about to cum and I pulled my dick out, stroking it and shooting cum on Hyun’s flat stomach, with some landing in her bush. Both Hyun and Amy flinched in happy surprise as my cum shot out and they both moaned a bit and then kissed each other. It was not much cum, because Amy blew me only a little before this, so Amy just went down and licked up the cum off Hyun’s little belly and then briefly sucked my softening penis.

Amy and Hyun were making out and I got off the bed to go pee in Amy’s bathroom. When I cam back, Amy was leaned back on some pillows and Hyun had her face between Amy’s spread legs, eating her out. I kissed Amy and then sucked on her tits, while Hyun ate her out. After Amy came, we all laid there naked for a bit, just touching each other and chatting. Amy finally said, “Jack, can you go make us some food? I’m starving now.”

A couple of days went by and Amy and I purposely had no sex and I did not masturbate. Jason was supposed to come by to collect some pussy from Amy on Thursday in exchange for not showing Jack the photos. They had agreed that Jason would come to her apartment between 1-4pm to fuck her, but I thought I would make it a little more interesting by arriving at noon. I had a key to her apartment, so I just let myself in. As I slowly opened the door, I immediately saw Amy standing in her small kitchen, which was sort of one room with the living room. As soon as she saw me, she knew I was Jason and not Jack. Amy said, “Shit, not you, I don’t want to do this Jason.”

I shut the door behind me and started walking quickly and purposefully toward Amy. I said, “Amy, you look really fuckable right now and you agreed I could fuck you or do you want Jack to see those photos – maybe the one with my dick in your mouth?”

Amy was fresh from the shower, her hair was still wet, and she was just wearing some panties and a little tank top as she was wandering around her apartment. She said, “Jason, I don’t want to fuck you,” and she ran into her bedroom, trying to shut me out, but I chased her and put my foot in the door before she could shut it. I shoved it open and threw her on her bed. She was kicking her legs at me, but I grabbed them and dragged her body to the foot of the bed. I unzipped my pants quickly and she tried crawling away on her bed, on all fours. I grabbed her by the back of her panties and just tore them off, ripping the waist band and throwing them across the room.

I got on top of Amy, as she was in that prone position, so she could not move and I started rubbing my dick on her pussy. Amy whimpered, “Come on Jason, let me just suck your dick. I’ll do a really good job. Just don’t fuck me.”

I was fingering her and put my hand under her to rub on her clit. I hissed in her ear, “I’m going to fuck the shit out you, Amy.” Her pussy was getting wet and I was able to start slowly working my dick into her. She was making little grunting noises and said in a strained voice, “just don’t cum inside me asshole, please.”

I just fucked her in that prone position, I had one hand underneath the front of her to play rub on her clit as I fucked her. She was making little whimpering noises as I pumped my dick into her, humping her into the bed. Finally, I was making noises like I was going to cum. Amy said, “Hey, Jason, seriously, do not cum inside me. Anywhere else,” and as I came inside her, I said, “oops” and laughed. I climbed off her and threw one of the photos on her bare ass, saying, “You really earned this one back with that nice pussy.”

Amy said, “Get the fuck out of her dickhead.”

I zipped up my pants and left her apartment, coming back in just 5 minutes later. I let myself in with the key again and Amy was in the kitchen, wearing a different pair of panties and making herself a smoothie. Amy said, “Jack, sweetie, I’m so glad to see you,” and came over to hug and kiss me. We stood there hugging and kissing, my hands moving down her lower back to feel her perfect ass over the top of her panties. I said, “Amy, I really want to fuck, we haven’t had sex in days, and you know I love it when you wear stuff like this.”

Amy gave me a naughty grin and led me by the hand back to her bedroom. She stripped off her little shirt, revealing her perfect tits. We stood, hugging and kissing at the foot of her bed. She pulled my tshirt up, helping me remove it. I took off my pants and underwear, I was already getting hard, even though we had just fucked. We climbed into her bed, kissing. She started stroking my dick and I slid a hand into her panties. It was very slippery and wet from Jason fucking her. In fact, I could feel she had not cleaned up my creampie yet, leaving it there on purpose, knowing I would come back and fuck her as Jack. I moved to pull of her panties and I could see that they were wet in the crotch, she pretended to be nervous and pulled them off, throwing them, so I would not see the wet stain.

I said, “Wow, Amy, you are already just soaking wet,” as I moved my fingers in and out of her, and sliding my fingers over her swollen clit.

Amy nervously said, “I was masturbating before you came…like you said, it’s been a couple of days.” I started kissing my way down toward her crotch, but she stopped me, pulled me up toward her and nervously said, “I just want to be fucked.” I said, “Well, that’s unusual for you to not want oral?”

Amy was grabbing my dick and rubbing it on her wet pussy. She said, “Jack, I really just want your dick. Fuck me hard.”

So, I slipped my dick into her pussy, which was very slippery with my creampie and her own juices. We fucked for a long time, we fucked in missionary, kissing each other. Then, she pushed me off her, and climbed onto my dick, riding it, holding herself up with her hands on her headboard. She was grinding her incredibly wet pussy on my dick with it all the way up in her. Then she would slowly lift herself so that most of my dick was out, then lowering herself on it again. She was edging me, making it last a long time. I kept rolling my head back in pleasure, reaching my hands up to fondle her tits. We were both a little sweaty and breathing hard, by the time I finally came inside her again. By now, her pussy was just soaking, my dick was slick and my whole crotch area was a bit wet from our juices leaking down out of her.

She collapsed on top of me and left my softening penis inside her, as we hugged and kissed. Then, she flopped over next to me, still breathing a little heavy and still a little flush. I could still feel the wetness on my dick and crotch area, as we laid there kissing.

Amy said, “Jack, that was so hot. Let’s go shower off and then go to class.”

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/105rt6s/blackmailing_my_gf_amy_part_4_mff_21_blackmail