The Dirty old neighbour, [part 1]

So we moved into a new house recently in a very nice and pretty posh neighbourhood,
Everyone was very friendly but one man in particular was overly friendly, he lived 2 doors down from us but he was always calling over unannounced, I do a lot of work on an old car in the garage so he would always drop by to chat, I didn’t mind too much as he was retired and his wife spent most her time with a sick family member.

My girlfriend would always offer him a coffee or a beer, when the weather got a little colder she would invite him inside for a hot beverage.
One night me and my girlfriend were chatting, she told me she thought something odd was happening, she continued to tell me that she thought some of her panties were missing and she has a suspicion that it was John (the old neighbour) as he was the only one who is usually in the house.
She came up with a plan to confirm her suspicions, when she was putting her dirty clothes in the clothes hamper she left the panties she had worn the night before on top of the pile, white silky pair with lace outer trim.

The next day John called over and she invited him in for a coffee, as always his reply was “I could never refuse a coffee with such a gorgeous young woman”, when they were inside, She made an excuse to come get something in the garage, I was working on the car so she came out to me and told me she was waiting a minute to see if he takes the bait, she went back in and after about 20 minutes John called me to tell me he was leaving, he went on his way and my girlfriend came out to me straight away, “my panties are gone” she told me, I couldn’t believe it, but then again I kind of could, he is obviously a lonely old man and my girlfriend is pretty hot and the chance for an old man like John to get his hands on a hot young woman’s panties doesn’t come around to often.
My Girlfriend was shocked and a little annoyed but I could understand John’s actions, I told her to calm down, I told her if all he is doing is taking a pair of panties now and then then it’s not a big deal, she reluctantly agreed because he was always such a gentleman.
In bed that night and she came into the room wearing a hot link pair of lace panties and a white tank top with no bra, she stood in the door feeling her panties and said “do you think John will like these?” I sat there with my mouth wide open I couldn’t believe what she said, I asked her if she was getting into the idea of him stealing her panties, she said “no, it’s weird but your right, it’s only a few pairs of panties”, so we had hot sex that night

The next day was similar, John called over, hung out with me in the garage, went in for a coffee and again stole the panties and left, my girlfriend was coming around to the whole situation but was starting to run out of panties, she didn’t want to have to keep buying new panties just for John to keep stealing them, so she told me she was going to talk to John about it, I told her he would be so embarrassed and it might not be a good idea, she said she was going to tell him she didn’t mind him taking them but he has to return them.

A few days later I was working and she had planned on calling to John to talk to him about the situation, he was surprised to see her and asked her in, he made her a coffee and they sat down, she told him she needed to talk to him about a delicate matter, she told him she knew he had been taking her dirty panties from the hamper, he was so embarrassed he was squirming in his chair, she assured him it was completely ok with her for him to keep taking them but she needed him to return them when he was finished doing whatever he does with them, he told her he had some she could bring home with her but he wanted something in return, confused she asked him what he wanted? He told her he wanted the panties she was wearing right now, she was completely taken by surprise, he asked her what ones she was wearing and she told him she was wearing a red thong, he said “that will do nicely”.
He wanted her to take them off infront of him but she told him that wasn’t happening so she went into the bathroom and removed them and he went and got his collection for her to bring home, the both returned to the kitchen and she handed him her thong and he took it and put it straight up to his nose and took a long deep breath in and out, “mmmm that is heaven” she looked at him almost disgusted, he handed her a bunch of her panties that he had taken, it was like a bunch of wet clothes, they were soaking, she asked him why were they wet? He replied “well you don’t think I just look at them do you?” She was disgusted as she looked at her hand and it was covered in cum, he held her thong up and said” ill enjoy these, and I hope you enjoy what’s in them” she said “how will I enjoy these?” He told her she should try them on before she washed them, she said “I will NOT be doing that John”
He told her she might like it, she said “I know you would like me to wear my panties covered in your cum but It’s not happening”
“Maybe some day” he replied.
As she was leaving he asked her does this mean he can’t call over anymore? She told him of course he could call, she said “I am ok with you taking my panties but you have to return them from now on”
She told him to keep it their secret because I didn’t know, he winked and said “our little secret”
With that she left with about 10 pairs of her dirty panties in a bag covered in John’s cum.

(Part 2 coming soon)

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/zp0zo7/the_dirty_old_neighbour_part_1