This is a sequel to [this story.](https://reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/yqa469/m_walking_in_on_my_roommate_f_leads_to_my_first/) Check out Part 1 for the backstory.
___
___
*“Oh hey, I forgot to tell you. Ashley texted me, her trip got cut short. She’ll be home in like an hour.”*
My anxiety shot from 0 to 10. Two minutes ago I was balls deep in our roommate Meghan’s asshole. Now she had let me know my girlfriend Ashley is on her way home as her bachelorette weekend had ended early, evidently.
First things first, I needed a shower to clean up and regather my thoughts. That was easier said than done. I was supposed to act normal just an hour after cheating on Ashley and having some of the best sex I’ve ever had?
The only consolation was that at least now I knew the secret was safe. After walking in on Meghan fucking her dildo on the bathroom floor, I thought I’d have to explain to Ashley that I wasn’t being a creep and it was a simple mistake. Now, we were both in it together.
What if Ashley wanted to fuck when she got home? She had a pretty high drive and we always fucked when we hadn’t seen each other in a few days. I remembered the packet of generic viagra pills I’d purchased on a lark from one of those websites that will prescribe to basically anyone. I took three little white pills so at least I knew I could get it up.
After my shower I changed the sheets on our bed and laid down to try to relax before she got home.
___
“Hey sleepyhead!”
I must have dozed off. Ashley was at the foot of the bed setting down her luggage.
“Long day at work?” she asked.
“Uhh yeah. I was so exhausted when I got home I must have passed out. What happened with the bach party? I thought you were coming home tomorrow?”
“The AirBnB screwed us and double-booked for tomorrow! Plus we were all so hungover today we decided to just call it. Ooooh! Fresh sheets?”
She stripped inelegantly down to her black bra and matching thong, lifted the blanket and crawled in to bed next me.
Now, despite my near-obsessive fantasies of our roomie Meghan, Ashley was not hard on the eyes either. She was 5’3” with fair white skin, blonde hair and blue eyes. In quite the contrast to Meghan, Ashley was rail-thin with narrow hips and she’d be right at home on r/cutelittlebutts.
“I missed you.” she whispered affectionately as she cuddled up closer to me.
“I missed you, too.”
“I’ve been crazy horny all weekend. Those girls never stop talking about sex and I’m always hornier when I’m hungover,” she said as she slid her hand under, under the covers and down to my cock.
*Thank god I took that viagra.*
___
I suppose I could have spurned her advances or lied about a headache but for some reason it never occurred to me to turn her down. As she was stroking my dick under the covers my mind flashed back to my encounter with Meghan. It wasn’t more than 10 seconds before I was back to full rigidity.
Thinking about Meghan felt wrong. As a matter of fact it was objectively wrong, but I couldn’t help it. Feeling Ashley’s warm hand stroking me while dreaming of our roommate’s tight little asshole turned me on immensely.
When you’ve had sex with someone for a few years, non-verbal sexual cues become a mutually understood language. With Ashley’s head next to mine, just the slightest twitch of my shoulder told her to get down there and start sucking.
She pulled back the covers and positioned her ass near my head. I grabbed her leg and pulled it over my head into the 69 position. With her pert little butt now directly in my face, I reached up, pulled her thong to the side enough to expose her asshole and took one long lick, slowly and firmly.
I had of course seen her ass hundreds of times but we had never done any sort of “butt stuff”. She had once rejected anal sex and I left it at that, not attempting to split hairs over eating ass, slipping in a finger or trying a plug. But after witnessing Meghan stretching herself on that huge pink dildo, and then fucking her ass raw, breaking that barrier with Ashley seemed trivial. *It was what I wanted, so it was what she was going to get.*
My balls were already empty. I wasn’t asking for sex, it was Ashley who initiated and needed it. Something in my psyche decided if we were going to do it, we were going to do this all my way.
___
Ashley let out a long, low moan. Without even speaking a real word she communicated her surprise, her pleasure, and her acceptance that I was eating her ass and that was that.
I tongued broadly across her hole while my fingers held her panties to the side. I grasped her ass firmly with my other hand, spreading her small cheeks. As I mentioned, Ashley’s ass was small and tight. It didn’t need to be gripped and spread to reach her little pink asshole. This was an act of exposure. Of dominance.
I slid my fingers down and pulled her panties further to reveal her shaven pussy. I licked the length of her hood to her clit and teased it gently side-to-side with my tongue. I swirled around it, very gently sucked her clit into my mouth and began to tongue it more firmly. I was so concentrated on eating pussy I intermittently forgot I was getting my cock sucked at the same time.
Ashley let out an “mmmm” and pulled her lips from my dick.
“You like to be my little slut, don’t you?” I asked her pointedly.
“Mmf, yes.”
“Yes what?”
“Yes, sir.”
*Atta girl.* I reached my hand up a bit further and began to swirl my fingertip over her pink asshole while I took her clit back in my mouth. Visions of Meghan flashed in my mind and just as quickly vanished.
After a minute, she gasped, “I’m gonna cum.”
I continued tonguing her clit and slowly sank my finger into her ass.
“Oh fuck! Yes, don’t stop!”
She moaned as she came, my finger slowly pulling out and pushing smoothly back in. *Well, well, well. Maybe Meghan isn’t the only anal slut in this apartment, after all.*
I spanked her ass firmly and she took her cue to raise off of me. She laid on her back and spread her legs wide. I penetrated my spit-soaked cock deeply into her tender bubblegum pussy. Grasping her thighs, I pushed her knees nearly down to the mattress and railed her with my full length.
“Are you going to be a good girl for me?” I asked.
“Yes! Yes!”
I stopped fucking mid stroke.
“Yes, sir!”
I resumed, then swung her left leg over to meet her right, placing her on her side. I reached down with my right hand and slid my thumb into her ass as I continued to fuck her pussy. This being my second sexual engagement of the afternoon, and with my cock propped up by enough viagra to raise a barn, I imagined this session could last quite a while.
It was just then that another image of Meghan popped into my head. Remembering the sensation of her ass gripping me tightly, wringing my cock from balls to tip as she had arched her back to the mattress. Riding me with her small, pierced tits in my face. Lowering herself to her knees to accept my load with a smile.
“Oh fuck, I’m going to cum,” I grunted.
“Ooh yeah, you wanna cum on my tits?”
I had drifted so deep into my recollection of fucking Meghan I was almost startled to hear those words in Ashley’s voice.
*…Cum on your tits?! Surely, you’re joking. I just blasted ropes all over our roommate’s face, you think cumming on your tits is going to be a thrill?*
“I’m going to cum in your pussy,” I declared matter of factly. Never before had I been so dismissive or dominant with Ashley. The power I felt from knowing I had just fucked another girl, and the power I gained from having now claimed Ashley’s asshole as my own property, assured there was no further discussion to be had.
I pushed my thumb as deep as it would go into Ashley’s ass and gripped my hand firmly across her cheek. I used that grip to pull her ass toward me as my cock tightened and pulsed my cum deep into her pussy.
I withdrew both my thumb and cock from their respective holes, gave her another firm spank on the ass, and finally gifted her her reward: “Good girl.”
___
“Umm wow, that was incredible,” was almost all Ashley could muster. “I think I need a shower. Where did *that* come from?”
“I guess I just missed you.”
I hadn’t quite breached the boundary of full anal with Ash, but progress was made.
She rolled out of bed and grabbed a fresh pair of panties from the dresser to take to the shower. I redressed and left the room to the kitchen to grab a drink of water.
“That sounded fun,” I heard quietly from behind me. I turned to see Meghan, popping her head out from behind her own bedroom door.
The shower turned on from Ashley’s and my bathroom. “How much did you hear?” I asked.
“Every word.” She replied coyly. She opened the door wider to reveal herself fully nude. On the bed behind her was that infamous pink dildo. “Next time we fuck, I want you to come inside me too.”
___
___
*Thank you for the warm reception and many follows on Part 1! Stay tuned for more stories of my secret affair with Meghan and my determination to turn Ashley into the perfect girlfriend.*
***Please feel free to comment or DM with your experiences reading these stories!***
Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/yr9of3/m_my_girlfriend_returned_home_early_and_horny