New Years Eve at my gf Amy’s house. Part 1. My gf Amy tells me a story about her hot past. (MMMMFF 19)

I called my gf, Amy after my interesting threesome with Mary and Josie and told Amy all about it. Amy said, “Do you want me to dress like a kitty?”

I said, “um…holy shit…maybe…yes..”

Amy laughed and said, “I can’t wait to see you on Friday at my New Year’s Eve party. What time are you guys driving up?”

I said, “I think Mary and Josie said we could leave early. They want to get up to your house and claim a good bedroom.”

Amy said, “There’s enough bedrooms for everyone. It’s not going to be that many people.”

I said, “Who is coming?”

Amy said, “It’s just you, me, Mary, Josie, Sarah, Hyun and a friend of mine from high school.”

I said, “Am I the only guy at this party?”

Amy chuckled and said, “You are indeed. I thought it would be weird bringing in other people when all of us have sex together.”

I said, “But, what about your high school friend?”

Amy nervously said, “Well, she kind of invited herself. Don’t get me wrong she is a good friend. I just don’t know what she will think of all of us girls fooling around and I don’t know there’s some other things.”

I said, “Why do you sound nervous about her?”

Amy said, “I think she is pretty hot, but she does not know I have been with girls.”

I said, “So, do you want to hook up with her?”

Amy nervously said, “Yes, I would…but there’s something else…”

I kind of interrupted Amy, “What does she look like?”

Amy said, “Jack, I was try to tell you something.”

I said, “Okay, sorry, I got carried away, go on.”

Amy said, “I had a New Year’s Eve party 3 years ago, I guess I was 19, and she was there. It got pretty crazy.”

I said, “Okay, fine, yes.”

Amy said, “I just want you to hear it from me, because she might start talking about that party, she talks a lot and she likes this story.”

I said, “Hear what?”

Amy said, “Uh…there was a lot of sex at that party Jack.”

I said, “Okay, well weren’t even dating and it’s not like I think you were a virgin or something. I mean you told me that other story about getting spitroasted by those two guys. I didn’t freak out. It was kind of hot story actually.”

Amy said, “Fine, I just, I’m not hiding anything from you it just never came up, so I can’t guarantee I have told you about every dirty thing I have done, but I will tell you anything.”

I said, “Amy, it’s cool, I’m sure you have not heard every dirty thing I have done.”

Amy said, “Alright, so I did not have a boyfriend three years ago at New Years.”

I said, “Dammit, I was already crushing on you and I was sure you had one.”

Amy said, “If you had asked me out back then, I would have said yes.”

I said, “Shit.”

Amy laughed and said, “Whatever, we’re together now. Anyway, Jack do you really want to hear about this party…me with other dudes?”

I said, “Yes, I mean I have been turned on by your other stories.”

Amy said, “Okay, so it was just my friend, four boys, and me.

I said, “Whoa…”

Amy said, “I told you this was a dirty story…are you sure you can handle it?”

I said, “Yes, go on.”

Continued in part 2.

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/yfxn6r/new_years_eve_at_my_gf_amys_house_part_1_my_gf