We met up at Sarah and Mary’s place. Mary looked incredibly nervous. Mary was a little more petite than either Amy or Sarah. For anyone who has not read the prior stories, Amy had light brown hair, incredible blue grey eyes, perfect medium sized tits, thin body and great ass. Amy and I were about the same height, kind of average height for a guy and she was a slightly tall for a girl. Sarah was very tall for a girl (almost 6ft). She had dirty blonde hair, she was thin, with fantastic long legs, thin body and small tits.
Mary was a bit shorter than Amy and me, probably 5’5”. She was a serious athlete with an athletic scholarship, playing field hockey. She had nice, athletic legs, great ass, small tits. She had light blonde hair, perpetually in a pony tail due to her athletics. She walked around campus with an intense look on her face because all she did was exercise, study and work. But, under that intense look, was a pretty face.
Mary was, no surprise, wearing baggy athletic shorts and a tshirt when we arrived. Sarah said, “please tell me you showered after practice, Mary.”
Mary said, “Of course I showered, these are my around the house shorts.”
Sarah said, “We might need to get you a little fancier for this weekend when Jack sets you up with his friend.”
We all moved into the living room on a couch and a love seat. Amy and I were sitting next to each other and Sarah and Mary were next to each other.
Mary said, “I’m so nervous, how do you get started?”
Amy said, “We have lots of time, let’s get you comfortable. Let’s talk a bit. So, you’ve never had a guy go down on you?”
Mary said, “No, both of my boyfriends wanted to, but I was too nervous.”
Sarah said, “Why were you nervous?”
Mary said, “I thought pussies were weird looking.”
I said, “Mary, pussies are not weird looking – they are fucking beautiful.” Amy and Sarah laughed at this.
Mary said, “Well, I agree with you now. This is sort of embarrassing, but I see my field hockey teammates naked all the time in the locker room. I’m not trying to stare, but I’ve seen a lot of pussy and I’ve started to think they look really nice. I’m not as self conscious about mine anymore.”
Sarah said, “Can just anyone use that locker room after field hockey practice?”
Amy said, “That does sound interesting…”
“That’s not really fair,” I said.
Mary said, “All three of you are creepy, but I’ll admit there are some attractive girls on the team. I saw one girl has hers completely shaved sometimes.”
“Wow, I’ve never seen that in person,” I said. (This was in the 90s. Back then every girl I saw had bush. Neatly maintained, not crazy 70s bush, but there was bush.)
Mary nervously said, “Well, you’re going to see that today”, looking away from everyone.
Sarah said, “Wait, what?”
Mary said, “I don’t know, I liked how hers looked. I just wanted to look nice for you guys.” She was very red faced.
Sarah was sitting right next to her. She reached over and pulled the waist band of Mary’s shorts and underwear away from her and looked down her pants quickly. Mary looked shocked.
Sarah said, “It’s definitely shaved and it is fucking cute.”
Mary was embarrassed.
Amy said, “Share with the class.”
Mary said, “No way.”
Amy said, “If you’re too embarrassed to show us your pussy, this is going to be a boring afternoon.”
Mary stood up. She let out a sigh. Then she pulled down her shorts and underwear for all of us to see her shaved pussy. She pulled them back up.
I just said, “wow.”
Amy said, “Do you want me to do that, Jack?”
I said, “I love yours with bush the way it is, but it is interesting just for variety. I’m going to have to lick Mary here to be sure.”
Sarah said, “Yes we all have to try it out.”
Mary was very embarrassed.
“Well, I’m fucking hard now”, I said.
Amy said, “Why don’t you show everyone?”
I said, “Are you guys going to get naked at the same time?”
Amy said, “No, I want you to get naked for the three of us.”
“Really?”, I said
Amy said, “Oh my gosh, you’ve never been shy before.”
“This is a little weird with the three of you just looking at me here,” I said. But I stood up and took off my shirt and unzipped my jeans. I pulled them off and then dropped my boxers, so I was standing there totally naked with a raging boner.
The girls were whistling and making other horny catcalls at me.
“Alright, Mary said she likes sucking dick, so why don’t you go over there and let her have a turn”, Amy said.
Mary nervously said, “It’s been kind of a long time and I have never had people watching me before.”
Amy said, “I thought you wanted to suck my boyfriend’s dick? I’m not going to let you two wander off to some other room, I’m going to watch.”
I walked over to stand in front of Mary with my boner, which was almost painfully hard at this point from the girls looking at me.
Mary reached up and grabbed it, giving it a few strokes and looked up at me nervously. Amy squeezed in next to Sarah to get a better view.
Sarah said, “Go on, suck his dick.”
Mary put it in her mouth and started slowly sucking me.
I said, “That feels fucking good.”
Mary said, “Thanks” and continued her sucking.
Amy said, “It’s like riding a bike. Looks like you’ve done that a few times before.”
Amy had unzipped the fly of Sarah’s jeans and her hand down the front touching her as they watched.
Mary paused and was stroking me and said, “I do love it. I’ve only sucked two before, but I sucked both of those guys a lot.”
She sucked some more then paused to talk again.
“Sometimes I just want to suck dick and not even have the guy do anything to me,
I like it so much”, she said.
Amy said, “same”
Sarah said, “me too.”
She licked the head of my penis and then she kept going.
Sarah said, “Well, Amy and I like it too, so you’re gonna have to share.” Sarah was next to Mary and moved her head so she could suck me. Mary took it out of her mouth and let Sarah take over. While Sarah was sucking me, Amy was fingering her and Mary was watching closely. Sarah let Mary take a quick turn on my dick then continued.
Finally Amy said, “That’s my dick, let me have a turn.”
I moved closer to Amy, she pulled her hand out of Sarah’s pants and started sucking me. As she sucked me, Sarah started kissing Mary aggressively. Mary looked surprised at first, but got into. Then Sarah plunged her hand down Mary’s shorts to start fingering her. Mary broke the kiss and gasped.
I was getting really close to cumming. Amy could tell and really went at it sucking me until I came in her mouth with a loud moan. She opened her mouth to show Mary the cum because Mary said she could not stand cum in her mouth.
Mary said, “I don’t know how you can stand that, Amy.”
Sarah turned to Amy and they started open mouth kissing, with the cum in Amy’s mouth. I had never seen them do that before. I think they were just trying to freak out Mary. Mary looked shocked. I probably did too.
They both swallowed and licked their lips as they stopped kissing. Sarah kissed Mary again.
Mary stopped kissing said, “It’s not that bad in just a small taste like this, but a full load, is fucking nasty.”
I said, “Okay, since you guys made me get naked first, I feel like I should get to lick Mary first.”
Amy said, “Oh, poor baby had to get a blowjob from three hot girls.”
Mary nervously said, “if you don’t mind, I would like Jack to go first, since I’ve never been with a girl and I’ve never had a boy do oral on me.”
Amy said, “Fine, but Sarah and I get some too. Take off your clothes Mary. We want a good look at you.”
Mary stood up slowly. She took off her tshirt. She was, of course, wearing a sports bra.
Sarah said, “Do you only ever wear a sports bra?”
Mary said, “I like them.”
Amy said, “Check out her abs and she has some nice arms there.”
Mary pushed down her shorts. She was wearing some ordinary bikini underwear. She was thin, but in a fit way. She had some muscle, but was not overly muscular. You could just tell she worked out a lot.
She pulled off her sports bra revealing her small, firm tits.
Sarah said, “look at those cute tits. I thought mine were small.”
Mary said, “You’re making me more self conscious.”
Sarah said, “No, you look awesome, I like them. I mean it, those are really cute.”
Mary finally pulled off her panties, showing us her bald pussy again. She was standing there naked and bright red as we stared at her. Amy and Sarah were also taking off their clothes finally.
I said, “Sit down Mary.”
She sat on the edge of the couch. I knelt down on the floor between her legs. I was already getting hard again. I spread her legs wider. I had her lean back and I put her feet on the edge of the couch with her knees bent and legs spread wide to give me access. She was covering her face with her hands in embarrassment. I moved my face down, kissed her inner thighs and then licked her pretty, shaved pussy.
Amy said, “How is it Jack?”
“It’s terrible, you won’t want any”, I said.
Mary said, “What?”
Amy said, “he is fucking with us, he wants it all for himself.”
Amy moved to sit on one side of Mary and Sarah took the other side. Amy and Sarah each started sucking on a tiny tit. Mary was breathing heavy and whimpering. I fingered her and spread her labia, so I could see the pink inside of her pussy and lick her clit. The girls stopped sucking her tits to look down at me for a minute. I looked up at the three of them as flicked my tongue on her clit. Amy and Sarah were running their hands all over her body.
Finally Amy said, “My turn” and she moved down to the floor and I reluctantly moved out of the way.
Amy was on her knees between Mary’s legs, looked at her and said, “Are you okay with a girl having a try?”
Mary just nodded her head yes.
Amy buried her face in Mary’s pussy, licking her. She said, “Jack’s right, Sarah, you won’t like this at all.” Then went back to her licking and sucking.
Sarah said, “fuck off, she’s my roommate.”
I moved between Sarah’s long thin legs and started licking her. Mary was now having an intense orgasm from Amy’s licking. Amy moved up and kissed Mary on the lips, with her mouth covered in Mary’s scent and taste. Mary kissed her back hard.
Then Mary said very meekly, “Can I try licking you Amy?”
Amy sat on the couch and spread her legs. Mary moved between then, but before licking her, she stopped to suck on Amy’s perfect tits.
Mary said, “You’ve really got beautiful tits Amy.”
Amy said, “Thanks, I get that a lot.”
Mary made her way down to Amy’s crotch. I stopped licking Sarah and both of us looked over to watch Mary lick pussy for the first time.
Mary said, “Everyone’s watching”, and we just stared at her, she furtively kissed and then licked Amy’s pussy. Then she started just really going for it.
Amy said, “that feels great Mary.”
Mary said, “I love this, you taste so good Amy.”
Mary continued licking and fingering Amy, I went back to licking Sarah. Amy and Sarah were both moaning.
Mary said, “I want to taste Sarah.”
Mary and I switched places. It would be fair to say that Mary clearly enjoyed licking pussy.
Amy said, “Jack, I want you to fuck me, but don’t cum inside me.”
Sarah said, “Mary, I want a turn licking you.” They switched places.Sarah knelt in the floor in front of Mary and started licking Mary’s pussy.
Amy, got off the couch and laid on the floor with her head under Sarah’s spread legs. She started licking her. I moved between Amy’s legs and slowly fucked her.
We did that for awhile, then Amy said, “Jack, fuck Sarah.”
I moved behind Sarah, so now my legs were spread across Amy’s chest with a knee on either side of her. Sarah had her legs spread wide so she was low over Amy’s face as she leaned into Mary’s crotch to lick her. Amy put my dick in her mouth briefly and then guided my dick into Sarah.
Amy licked my shaft and Sarah’s clit, as I slowly worked my dick in and out of Sarah.
Sarah paused her licking and said, “Oh fuck that’s good.”
Mary was running her hands in Sarah’s hair as Sarah licked her. I pulled my dick out occasionally and Amy licked and sucked it. Then I would plunge it back into Sarah. Finally I felt like I was going to cum.
I said, “I’m going to cum.”
Amy grabbed my dick and sucked it until I came in her mouth. Amy swallowed, then continued licking Sarah. I moved down and licked Sarah’s asshole briefly, just a quick rimjob and that sent her over the top with Amy licking her pussy and me licking her butt at the same time.
Sarah said, “Jack, you nasty boy, that felt incredible.”
“I couldn’t help it, your ass looked amazing there”, I said.
We all sat in the couch together, just sort of touching each other.
Amy said, “How did you like it Mary?”
“Um, that was fucking awesome, are you sure we can’t do this again sometime?”, Mary said.
Amy said, “We’ll have to discuss that.”
Sarah and I looked at each other as Amy said that.
Sarah said, “But no one has anywhere to be this afternoon, so we can keep going.”
So, we hung out on the couch. Sarah and Amy started making out and touching each other, so Mary and I also started kissing and touching each other. We spent a long time kissing and touching each other. My dick was getting hard again.
Mary said, “Amy, can I suck Jack’s dick some more?”
Amy paused kissing Sarah and said, “Go right ahead.”
Sarah got on her knees in front of me and started licking and sucking my dick while looking up at me. Amy and Sarah stopped kissing and just fingered each other as they watch Mary. I was now very hard again.
Mary said, “I loved licking your pussies girls, but I really do need some dick. (She sucked some more and paused to talk again) Today really just reminded me how much I enjoy dick. Like I need to fuck someone ASAP.” Then she continued blowing me.
Amy said, “Jack, do you want to fuck that little pussy?”
I said, “Sure.”
Amy said, “You have to be gentle with her, she hasn’t been fucked in a year, so she is basically a virgin again. I want to watch you fuck that bald pussy.”
Mary said, “Oh my god, thanks Amy.”
Amy said, “I want a nice view of this, so get on your back, Mary.”
Mary laid down on the floor. I moved between her legs.
Amy said, “Jack I want you to fuck her on your knees, so I can watch your dick go in and out of her.”
Amy and Sarah moved down to the floor on either side of Mary. Amy shoved a pillow under Mary’s ass and another for her head. I was rubbing my hard dick on Mary’s pussy. I rubbed the head around and then moved the shaft up and down on her clit. The girls were rubbing her thighs and her chest. Amy rubbed Mary’s clit. I was teasing the hell out of Mary, putting my dick just slightly in and back out.
Mary said, “come on Jack, please…”
I said, “Should I fuck her Amy?”
Amy said, “I don’t know, maybe not.”
She winked at me.
Mary said, “Oh my god, please you have to.” She was trying to push her pelvis into my dick.
Finally, Amy said, “No, I am going to do it.”
Amy moved behind me on her knees, put her arms around me and grabbed my dick. She started rubbing my dick around the way I had been. Then she pushed me into Mary. Mary gasped loudly.
Amy was thrusting herself into me and pulling back, so it was like she was fucking Mary. Mary was going pretty wild. Sarah moved down and was sucking one of her little tits. Amy would pull my dick out and tease Mary.
Amy said, “It is fun fucking girls.”
I said, “Amy, I’m about to cum.”
Amy said, “Hey Sarah, come suck my dick,
waving my boner around.”
Sarah moved her head down and sucked my dick with Amy behind me, pretending it was hers. I came in her mouth, not that there was much cum left in me. I collapsed on Mary and we kissed.
Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/ufli8t/my_gf_amy_has_me_fuck_her_best_friend_while_she
Very hot series so far !!!
Thanks. That’s hot.