So it all began like this…I was watching tv on the floor with a blanket at my new apartment, (not much furniture yet). My GFs sister, let’s call her Rachel, 21 years old at the time, came over. It was just me, my gf (23 years old back then), and Rachel, who by the way, had a boyfriend of her own. As Rachel comes in, she takes her shoes off, and she’s now barefoot. She joins me and my gf on the floor to watch tv, laying on top the blanket.
Rachel later asks her sister if she thinks her feet look ugly, and begins to compliment my Gfs feet. Rachel has her feet out wiggling her toes, describing them out loud, meanwhile complementing and touching my gfs feet. Rachel’s describing details like toe shape and length, arch shape, sole smoothness, all sorts of details. Rachel claims to envy her sisters feet and admits to being jealous. Honestly Rachel’s feet are far better looking in every aspect she described. Perfect arch, smoothness, well taken care of toenails. Rachel definitely cares about her feet, much better than my gf does, even though my gf has cute feet, and I’m sure Rachel can tell she has pretty feet even though she claims to envy her sisters.
Second encounter:
Rachel invited her mom, sister and I over to her BF’s house for the winter holidays. Her boyfriend has a few friends over as well. Rachel was barefoot, and wearing black tights with a red top. It was a small basement apartment, so the place was a bit crowded, and her bf decided to head out with his boys for some drinks. Rachel is playing host, serving us food and keeping us entertained. As it gets late we settle in and watch a movie. We take the lights out and Rachel puts her bare feet up on the coffee table in front of us. The bottoms of her feet are slightly dirty. Her toenails were painted pink, and her soles were smooth. Her mom mentioned to her, Rachel, clean your feet, they’re dirty. Rachel replies that she likes having her feet dirty, because it gives her bf something to lick, and she begins laughing as to make it uncertain if it’s a joke. She smiles and leaves her feet there and just wiggles her toes throughout the movie.
As her bf comes back, he looks at Rachel in anger telling her to take her feet down, and to “stop displaying herself” for everyone to drool over. It was kinda awkward. As he left, and mostly everyone left the room to ease out of the tension, I’m left alone with Rachel who says, “it’s whatever, don’t let him get you scared, you can drool on whoever you want” then she got up and left.
Third encounter:
A few weeks later, as I visited my gf, I was spending the day with her, Rachel and their mom. In the evening, we were casually watching some TV, and chatting, sitting on a couch. I was at one end, mf gf in the middle, and Rachel on the other end. I had my hand on my gfs shoulder, and then began to rub her back. I was doing this without much thought, and worked my way down her back and eventually started rubbing and gently massaging her feet. About 5 minutes later my gf got up, and…. Well I was still massaging a foot.
As I look over to Rachel, she has a smirk on her face, a quite cute innocent, yet guilty smile. I retracted my hand the second I realized, but I was mesmerized by what just happened….she knew the whole time. Of course we go on like nothing has happened.
Then finally:
It was Rachel’s birthday. She rented an air bnb for a week and invited a few people over. One rainy day, actually on the day of her bday, she wore a baggy black sweater, with black panties, no pants and barefoot. We were bored doing various activities as it was raining this morning, and she came out of her room dressed “half dressed”. Her bf told her to put some pants on, and she laughed and said it’s her birthday and she’s doing whatever she wants today.
As I’m sitting on the carpet, doing a jigsaw puzzle on the livingroom floor, everyone eventually left the living room, off to find things to do or just whatever’s… And Rachel comes by and sits on the couch dangling her bare foot about 15 inches in front my face. She then begins to tell me how lucky I am to have her sister as my gf, because she has nice feet. I agreed, but lied and said I’m not really into feet so it’s not a big thing for me. Rachel then moved her foot closer to my face, and asked me if I thought she had nice feet. I said yeah sure, they aren’t ugly. She then asked me if I would lick them. I stammered wha… Wha… What? She said lick them a little, please. My boyfriend is being a jerk and it’s my birthday, but I just really want someone to lick them. I was in shock. She looked around, and didnt see anyone nearby, so she took her opportunity. She put her toes on my lips and asked me to stick my tongue out. “I can’t” I said to Rachel, as she began to slide her foot onto my tounge as I spoke. She’s began to moan a little, and said “you’re making me wet, suck my toes a little” she then took her other foot and put it on my dick outside my pants and began to push hard against my shaft and stroked me hard from the heel of her foot on the head of my cock, all the way to the bottom with her toes wiggling and pushing into my balls. She was moaning slightly as one foot stroked my cock quickly and she used her other foot to push her toes into the back of my mouth and slide her soft smooth sole, spread flat onto my tounge, I just burst. I blasted cum into my pants as she kept stroking and she began to take her foot out my mouth. My pants got wet and she felt it on her foot, as my cum wet the bottom of her sole as she slowed her pace and gradually she slowly stopped stroking me. I went to the bathroom to clean up and she sat there with the biggest smile on her face.
The cherry on the cake was about 2 hours later we were all gathered around playing truth or dare, and she dared her boyfriend to lick her foot for 10 seconds in front of everyone. She gave him the foot I came on and she looked right at me and smiled as her bf was disgusted to lick her foot even though I doubt he even knew what happened earlier.
It’s been about 3 years now, Rachel and her bf broke up. Rachel moved out of town and I hardly see her given the pandemic. I’m still dating her sister and I have never told her. I think about Rachel’s feel all the time. Almost every time I have sex with my gf, or almost any time I need a little boost to cum, I think of Rachel.
Source: reddit.com/r/sexystories/comments/u72qb9/my_gf_sisters_feet