[M]y success[F]ul Tinder Match – Part 2

*Author’s Note: Part 2 of 2. Part 1 got hot and heavy! Let’s see if Heather has anymore tricks up her sleeve. You can find Part 1, plus all my other stories, on my community page (link in comments). Enjoy, and as always DMmeYOURpussies!*

**- Heather and I: Part 2 -**

We drifted off to sleep, but I woke abruptly before the sun was up. Heather was gone. I wasn’t hoping to have a “couples” Sunday or anything, but I was hoping for some sultry morning sex. I went out to my stoop and smoked a cigarette in the cool air and tried to not dwell on being left alone in bed. The feeling was fleeting though as I began applauding myself for getting out from under the weight of heartbreak and delighted in those words… *No one has ever made me cum like that.*

Later that morning Heather texted me saying she had to be at work at six, was sorry to leave without saying goodbye, and that she wanted to do it again. I responded with one word, “Absofuckinglutely.”

The week came and went as I daydreamed at work about the tasty little pussy I devoured. I texted Heather asking if she wanted to take me up on the dinner rain-check.

She responded with, “Let’s skip dinner again and repeat last weekend.”

Giddy, I texted back, “No problem with me. I was hoping to order the same thing I had last Saturday. Best tasting meal I’ve ever had!”

She responded with, “Yum, I enjoyed what I tasted too. Hoping for a lot more tonight.” With that, I went for a run, jacked off in the shower, making sure to go slow while visualizing her body in detail because tonight I was going to give her a lot more.

This time when I answered the door she was wearing black yoga pants and a tight white workout top. I laughed and asked, “Are these easy access too?”

She giggled and blushed, “No lie this time, these are really the only other clothes in my car.”

I ushered her inside, taking my time to check out her tight little ass. I could tell she was wearing underwear this time, but once she got inside in the light I saw she wasn’t wearing a bra. Her dark nipples were showing through the skin tight white top, and again they were hard and deliciously pointy. By the time my eyes moved up from her tits to meet her eyes she had a naughty smile across her face.

Unlike the last time, we chatted a bit while drinking cocktails on the couch. I couldn’t help myself though as I stroked her legs, mentally drooling over the sweet nectar waiting in between. She began getting flushed as she ran her hands through my hair and I slowly inched my hand around her legs and grasped her ass. God was her ass amazing. It was bubbly, yet firm and I could tell her workout clothes were put to good use inside a gym. When I moved my hand from her ass and pressed it down across her pussy, she immediately got up and walked into my bedroom.

We lay on the bed making out and dry humping for a while. Both of us enjoying the process moving at a slower pace this time around, allowing our hands to explore each others bodies. Her gym clothes were so tight though I couldn’t reach under them and feel her soft skin, so I took off my shirt and helped her get her top off. Those beautiful perky tits popped out as she lifted her arms and I barely finished taking her top the rest of the way off before my mouth was sucking on one of her hard nipples. She gently moaned while moving her hand over my crotch, rubbing me hard through my pants. I leaned her back onto the bed, stood up and took my pants off, releasing my cock to those adoring black eyes. I leaned forward and grabbed the waistline of her yoga pants ready to pull them off and once again glimpse her mouthwatering mound, but she grabbed my hands and looked me in the eye with an embarrassed expression. It caught me by surprise considering how comfortable she was last weekend, so I stopped and asked if everything was okay. She turned her gaze away from me and said she got her period earlier that day.

“Oh,” I said, “don’t worry. We don’t have to have sex if you don’t want. But I really don’t mind fucking a woman on her period.”

She turned back to me, relieved and said, “Thank you, but I don’t like having sex on my period. I just didn’t want to ruin our night.”

She reversed positions on the bed, laying on her belly with her head towards me, grabbed my cock and put in in her mouth. While slowly sucking on just the head, her eyes drifted up to mine. She removed my cock from around her lips with a satisfying pop sound and said, “Is this okay?”

“Oh god yes!” I moaned.

She smirked and replied, “OK, cuz last time you didn’t really let me suck your cock at all. I wasn’t sure if you liked it.”

The memory sprang back into my mind, and now it was my turn to be embarrassed. I looked down at her, my cock in her hand with her tongue flicking inches away from it, and said, “Last time you made me so hot I was about to cum in your mouth after 30 seconds, so I moved you up to kiss you.”

Giggling, “Hehe, thank god cuz I love sucking dick,” then licked the precum off the tip and started blowing again with enthusiasm. She continued as I held her hair back and marveled in the sight of my cock getting sloppy wet. Knowing sex was off the table I allowed the pressure to build, my cock beginning to throb. I was just about to ask if she wanted me to cum in her mouth, when she must have felt my orgasm coming and stopped abruptly.

She looked up at me with such an innocent look and pleaded, “Don’t cum yet. Do you like fucking girls in the ass?”

I swear it took all I had in me to suppress exploding right then and there all over her face. I focused, clinched the muscle between my balls and asshole to stop the cum fountain from erupting, and ecstatically said “Yes!”

She gave a sly little grin and rolled over on her back, lifted her legs and took off her pants and panties. She lingered there with her legs in the air letting me get a glimpse of her asshole, her tampon string hanging out of her tight pussy lips. She dropped both her legs to one side, knees up to her chest, allowing her ass to spread.

Turning to look over her shoulder, she said, “You’ll have to warm me up before sticking your cock in there, my asshole is tight.” With absolute delight, kneeling on the ground next to the bed, I wet a finger and started to rub her asshole. She gently sighed with pleasure and said “Lick it. Get it wet.” Gladly, I spit right on her tight puckered asshole, flattened my tongue and worked it all over. I moved my head back, wet my finger again and gently inserted it, all the while stroking my cock. Her asshole slowly relaxed and I started to work my finger back and forth. Looking up at her, her face strained, she made a combination of noises, ranging from grunts to moans to little squeaks. I asked if she liked it and she said, “I just want your cock to fuck my ass.”

“Yes please,” I replied as she got on her elbows and knees.

“This position will open up my asshole better,” she said as I was already putting on a condom and grabbing lube.

With her ass up, her back arched, me on my knees behind her, looking down on her remarkable tight ass with her ever so enticing asshole waiting to get split open, I took just a second to thank my lucky stars. That second is forever imprinted on my memory. All these years later, all I have to do is close my eyes to see that sight again.

I squirted some lube on my fingertip, rubbed in on my dick, then massaged some around and in her asshole. Already warmed up and now loose in doggystyle position, her asshole quickly ate up my cockhead. I worked it in and out slowly, steadily picking up the pace and going deeper until all seven inches were in. I was grunting with pleasure at how tight she was, and how the wonderfully different feeling an asshole feels compared to a pussy. This was not my first time anal fucking, but it is a treat every time. I honestly couldn’t tell which was tighter around my cock, her asshole or her pussy. Let’s just say that was a very good problem to have.

She continued her various noises, only louder, and her head was tilted all the way back in a position of both pleasure and pain. I was really pounding it, our bodies slapping against each other, when she yelled, “Fuck me harder!”

I thought to myself, *Goddamn, I’m already fucking you hard.* I slapped her ass, she gave a yelp, and I moved myself into a squatting position, feet planted next to her knees, hands gripping her hipbones. I then really gave it to her, thrusting as hard and fast as I could. She was yelling repeatedly, “Fuck! Yes!”

That only lasted a few minutes before my thighs were aching from squat thrusting and I began to slow. She turned her head and said, “Let me finish you with my mouth.”

As heavenly as fucking her asshole was, I was honestly relieved to relax and let her finish the job. I pulled my cock from her asshole, which was gorgeously spread open wide, slapped her ass again, and lay down on my back. She gingerly crawled off the bed, sweaty and red faced, and walked around to kneel on the ground. Snapping the condom off she proceeded to gobble up my whole dick eagerly. After fucking her ass so vigorously I wasn’t sure if a blowjob would get me off, but she changed tactics on me. Removing my cock from her mouth, she spat on it (which is always hot), grasped it and using her thumb began rubbing the backside right where the shaft meets the head.

“Oh fuck that feels good,” I told her with my head back, arms behind my head in pure ecstasy.

Then, she put the cherry on top of the whole experience as she began firmly licking in between my asshole and balls. This was a new sensation for me, and it was unbelievable.

I said those wonderful words to her again, “I’m gonna cum.”

She didn’t remove her tongue from my taint, just moaned a “Mmmhmm.”

My cock swelled, she increased the speed of both her thumb and tongue, and I shot a huge load all over my stomach. I shuttered as she stroked all the cum out of me, then slowly rose, making sure to slide her hard nipples up my thighs, and with eyes locked onto mine, began licking up my cum.

Now it was my turn to say, “No one has ever made me cum like that.”

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/twyjd6/my_successful_tinder_match_part_2