It was an honest mistake.

We are all so used to frequent Amazon deliveries that we don’t even look at the mailing label anymore. But when my neighbor Ashley opened a package with a vibrating male stroker inside, she knew she had made a mistake.

Later that afternoon, when she knocked on my door with an open Amazon package in hand, I don’t know who got more red. I felt like I was having an out of body experience. I was embarrassed to even buy this thing, and here was my cute neighbor, delivering it personally.

After stuttering and staring at the floor, we finally just broke into a laugh. I told her repeatedly how embarrassed I was, and she assured me it was fine, and that we all had our toys to get us through those moments. She even joked that she will bring up the lube when it gets delivered.

After she said that, I looked at her with a puzzled look, and she asked me whether I knew I needed lube for this toy. Sheepishly, I told her I did not even think of that, then she disappeared in a flash and headed downstairs.

“Here,” she said when she returned, as she handed me a tube. “I have an extra.”

I shyly accepted, and must have had a confused look on my face. Ashley gently explained that once I am erect, I put some lube on my penis and in the sleeve, then gradually start to slide in and out.

And then I heard the sentence that rocked my world: “Would you like me to show you?”.

I was too shocked for words. I was totally stunned. I was reeling. But I must have given an implied affirmative answer. I hardly remember what Ashley said as she explained that it was alright that I was inexperienced in this area…That she had experience with toys like this…That she thought I was a nice guy and good neighbor…and so on.

Before I knew it, I was standing near the couch, and she was helping me slide my shorts and boxers down. “Oh my, hello neighbor” said Ashley, as she dropped my shorts and guided me to a spot next to her on the couch, and from this point, my memory gets a bit sharper.

Ashley explained that first I needed to get hard, and we both knew what that meant. So I started to stroke my flaccid dick, but things were not happening.

“You’re so nervous!” she said as she laughed, “Let me help you out. Lie your head back, close your eyes, and let me get you ready.”

I felt my limp cock slip into Ashley’s hand, and she slowly stroked it and massaged my balls, as my member began to grow. “There we go”, she said, as I gradually came to full staff.

I opened my eyes to watch, and she gave me a coy smile as she popped the cap off the lube. She slowly applied some to my cock, rubbed it all over my head and shaft, then put a little on the opening of the sleeve.

“This is unreal” I thought to myself, as I watched her ease my head into the toy and look up at me with a smile. Slowly she eased me all the way in, little by little, then began to fuck my crazy hard cock with the toy. As she asked me how it felt, and if it felt like a real pussy, I told her I would not last long.

“Come for me Jay. Let yourself go. Fill this pussy with your seed for your neighbor…”, Ashley encouraged me as she stroked a little faster. With that, I felt my hips thrust into the air, and I shot a rope into the pocket pussy. Then another, and another, until I was spent. With that, Ashley got up, grabbed a towel from the cabinet, took the sleeve off my cock, and cleaned me up.

As soon as she had come, she was gone. Within minutes, my phone buzzed with a text, and it was Ashley, saying how much she looked forward to helping her handsome neighbor again one day.

Source: reddit.com/r/Erotica/comments/toodat/it_was_an_honest_mistake